Quantcast
Channel: Hifi Reviews | Hifi Pig
Viewing all 672 articles
Browse latest View live

Merrill Audio Thor Monobloc Amplifiers

$
0
0

After reviewing the Merrill Audio Veritas monobloc power amplifiers in January 2015 Stuart Smith auditioned the American company’s $4800 Thor amps. 

I’ve had the Thor amps now for around the six month mark and they’ve been doing a great job in the main system having become our reference and so I thought it about time that I finally got around to writing a few words about them for you.THOR2S

Regular readers will remember I reviewed the Merrill Audio Veritas amps back in January of 2015 commenting “Hard to fault in my opinion but I just don’t give perfect tens. Had I the means to buy the review amps I certainly would.” Sadly my financial situation didn’t allow me to make the purchase and so, after speaking with Merrill and him assuring me that the Thors, despite their much more achievable pricepoint offered up a good percentage of what the Veritas would…he also mentioned that many people have found distinguishing the two very difficult. Let’s scotch this one from the off…the Thors are not ultimately as good as the Veritas, but they’re not far off and they cost a lot less, with the Veritas costing $12 000 and the Thors costing $4 800 for a pair.

The Thors use Hypex Ncore tech in the UcD Modules and the cases are, like the Veritas, milled from a solid billet of aircraft grade aluminium. Commercially they are available in a high gloss black finish (mine are a unique pair in opalescent white) and they are pretty dinky affairs measuring just 23cm x 23cm and stand just 9cm high including their Stillpoints. Along the front in pretty subtle lettering is milled THOR and round the back you have the Furutech IEC mains input, a Cardas XLR input that is Silver with Rhodium plate and the absolutely brilliant (in my opinion) Cardas patented speaker binding post that are Rhodium over Copper… I said it in the review of the Veristas, but I reckon these are without a doubt the best way of connecting spade connecters to your amp!  Underneath each amp you have the muting button which glows red when on and looks pretty cool reflecting off the marble slabs I have the amps standing on. A note here is that you must not play about with connections etc even when the amps are muted and you must ensure they are disconnected from the mains!THOR3S

Power output is rated at 200 Watts into 8 Ohms and 400 into 4 but they can be double-height bridged for 700 Watts into 4 Ohms.

THE SOUND

These are Class D amps and I know from experience and reading the various Facebook groups that this technology does not find favour with everyone. However, put down your prejudices and realise that Class D has come a long way in recent years and is not what you may assume it to be. Class D amps have a reputation of being bass light and favouring the midband, but that’s just not the case with these specific amplifiers. I’ve used them with a wide range of loudspeakers (Triangle, hORNS Mummy, Audio Physic Avanti 3 and the Avantgarde Duo XDs) and I’ve never found them lacking in the bass at all… I’ll expand on this in a bit.

I’m not going to babble on about a whole load of specific tunes I’ve listened to with the Thors in place as I’ve listened to just about every genre you could imagine (sadly no Mongolian throat singing but I’m working on that) with them over the months and they seem to perform equally well with everything.THOR6S

Like the Veritas amps what you do immediately notice is an absolutely silent background, particularly when using a passive pre (I used the Bespoke Audio and Music First Baby Reference passives). This was an interesting observation on my part because I thought I needed to have my Coffman Labs valve pre in front of the Thors to stop them sounding cold and sterile…this is clearly not the case. What you do get is a beautiful clarity of sound that is just sparklingly clear throughout the frequency range. The Thors don’t have that certain indefinable quality that the Veritas had but the flavour (or lack of it) is the same and partnered with the passive pre amplifiers I mentioned these are “high-fidelity” in the strictest sense of the word, neither adding nor taking away much at all. Let’s wheel out the hifi reviewer clichés shall we… “an open window to the recording”, “veils lifted”, “see through to the source transparency”… you get the picture I think. This clarity of sound allows you to get the most out of your chosen music and brings you closer to the original recording than I’ve experienced with more conventional amplifiers. It also allows you to change components up stream and be immediately aware of the different seasoning these changes bring to the cocktail.

You’ll be well aware that we like to play pretty loud and you can crank the Thors up to pretty realistic levels with the right speakers, but you don’t get the impression that the flavour of their presentation changes at all…there’s just more volume and that same clarity right to the point where you know you need to turn it down or the neighbours are going to be hammering on the door.THOR7S

The Thors are also fast amps in the sense that they will play quiet to loud bits in your music without missing a beat and the bass is also fast and taut… I like taut bass and anything that doesn’t deliver in this department gets the cold shoulder immediately from me. Deep Purples ‘Smoke On The Water’ was a real treat when the bass guitar comes in, as was our other bass test track from Hardfloor. Drums have slam, hats are crisp and the spatial bits within the mix are all there in front of you. Soundstage and imaging is predominantly a factor of your loudspeaker choice in my honest opinion, but with the Thors in place there is the feeling that imaging is tack sharp and accurate…this is another must for me!

Real instruments sounded real across the board and electronic music had the requisite pace and rhythm with the Thors plumbed into the rig. As I’m writing this I get the impression that the words I’m using suggest a cold and sanitary sound, but that’s not the case I don’t think. A double bass sounds warm and fat (as does synthesised bass) but then hats are steely and razor-sharp…what I’m saying, perhaps badly, is that the Thors add little to nothing to the tonality of an instrument allowing it to be what it is and given the silent backdrop the Thors afford you get to hear all the attack and decay of an instrument. THOR4S

These would be great tools in a studio environment I reckon, but they also do their job in the home setting. They are that “open window” and as such crap recordings will sound crap, as will poor electronics before the amps. Let’s be honest here and say that high fidelity (in the truest sense) is not always the end goal for audio enthusiasts and most like to add a bit of flavour to their set up (some prefer a warmer more relaxed sound, whilst others may favour a faster more steely approach) and with the Thors in place (along with a suitable pre) you can tune to your tastes with the DAC or other source components…and of course your loudspeakers.

CONCLUSION 

The Merrill Thor amps look great, offer a clean and pure sound and cost less than half the price of the Veritas amps and as such I reckon they offer pretty decent value for money. For a reviewer they are a great tool as they just don’t seem to add a great deal of character to the sound and so they are great for assessing other equipment. However, they are also eminently listenable in the home set up and I can honestly say that I’ve never listened to more music than I have with the Thors. They are an easy and yet accurate listen, with enough power to satisfy all but the most power hungry of speakers. Comparing them to the Veritas they don’t seem to have quite the same dynamic quality I enjoyed so much, but they’re really not far off not all.

Here’s the thing… if you want to add colour to your set up at the amplifier link of the chain then you need to look elsewhere, if you want to have an amp that does little but amplify then you need to audition these. I have a lot of amps come and go and I like to hear what they bring to the table in terms of their character, but having the Thors in place just feels like I’ve slotted back in that tool that neither adds nor takes away very much and as such I heartily recommend them.

After writing this review I’ve just read through the review of the Veritas and the two are very similar indeed!

Sound Quality: 8.85RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Build: 9

Value: 9

Overall: 8.95

Price as reviewed $4800 

Pros :

Transparent and revealing

Fast and taut

Relatively good value

Cons :

Transparent and revealing

Not quite as dynamic as the Veritas

Stuart Smith

Designer’s Notes

The Thor Monoblocks were conceptualized to provide a lower priced entry to the VERITAS Monoblocks while retaining as much as possible of the VERITAS Monoblocks. In creating these units, the power and the size were considered independently and coincidently ended up being about half the price and half the power.  When completed the Thors retain between 75% to 80% of the VERITAS Monoblocks characteristics.

The design was to still use Class D and very clean power supplies in which an SMPS power supply was selected.  The original boards are modified and the modifications were decided on by using focus groups that helped with the voicing of the Thor Monoblocks.  The base technology is the UCD from Hypex with 75% of the Ncore technology implemented in this. This is then further modified by Merrill Audio for the final product.

The chambered Chassis is made from Aircraft grade Aluminum. It is CNC’ed out from a solid block of aluminum, then painted with high gloss Black car finish and baked. (The limited edition Pearl White Monoblocks were double baked).  While it is small, the chassis is designed for good airflow to keep the internal operation cool.

As with the VERITAS, the high quality Cardas XLR, Cardas Patented Speaker binding posts and Furutech IEC is used. The Thors also provide for a remote trigger like the VERITAS. There is only 1 Speaker Binding post on the Thors instead of 2 like the VERITAS as the size limited the easy to use layout. Stillpoints Ultra mini risers are also provided and an upgrade to the Symposium Rollerblocks are provided.  Part of the focus group was to test out different power cords to would provide a match to the Thors. Since we could not come up with a cost effective power cord that worked well, a custom power cord was build using Furutechs Silver plated 27 stranded pure copper wire and terminated with Cardas AC plugs. These are only available in US and Schuko. The Cardas plugs were chosen as it complimented the Furutech cable very well in sound.

Internally, silver plated, Teflon sleeved pure copper wire is used throughout from the power supply to the audio signal. All lines are kept as short as possible.  A synergistic fuse is also included to improve the sound. The Fuse is not user accessible as the fuse is the protection of last resort. The synergistic fuse does affect the Sonics hence the extra cost was justified. The Thors have a slew of internal protections.  Should all of them fail, then the fuse will blow. At this point the customer should return the units to see what has failed and have it corrected, which should be an extremely rare occurrence, should it happen.

We were more than please with the final result of the Thor Monoblocks that is being offered at a great price using the economies of scale and design derived from the VERITAS Monoblocks.

Merrill Whettasinghe

 

 

Share


Clearaudio Smart Matrix Professional Record Cleaning Machine

$
0
0

Keeping your records in pristine condition is vital to their longevity and the lifespan of your cartridge. Stuart Smith cleans up his act with the Clearaudio Smart Matrix Record Cleaning Machine at £775.  

German brand Clearaudio produce a couple of record cleaning machines (RCMs), the Double Matrix Professional Sonic and the less pricey Smart Matrix Professional which is the subject of this review. The unit retails in the UK for £775.RCMFRONT3S

The SMP arrives very well packed with a Perspex lid (an option), vacuum arm, record clamp, 100ml of fluid to get you started, a microfiber brush to apply the fluid, some spare microfiber strips and of course the unit itself.RCMARMS

The unit weighs a little over 11Kg, measures 13.58inch square and stands 9.84 inches high. It’s basically a solid wooden box with a thin aluminium skin/veneer to keep it protected from water. On the front you have the operating buttons – power on/standby, platter rotation and vacuum on/off. Atop the box at the business end of the machine is the platter which has a soft foam mat on it. Here you also fit the vacuum arm which is basically a slotted metal tube (see pic above) with microfiber strips either side of the slot to stop your precious records getting scratched. Clearaudio say these strips should last around 200 sides of very dirty records. It is this slot in the arm that sucks the fluid from your record. Round the back you’ve got a power connector with an on off switch and a plastic tube with a bung in it for emptying the dirty water tank.RCMSide1s

Assembly is a piece of cake with you only having to push the vacuum arm into the hole in the top plate and plug the unit into the mains.

I set the RCM up on an IKEA table for the test.RCMFLUIDS

Cleaning your records is a simple process. Switch it on at the back, remove the vacuum arm, place the record on the platter and screw it down with the record clamp and then replace the vacuum arm. Press the power button which spins the platter clockwise, put the cleaning brush against the record and squirt a bit of the fluid onto the record and let the record spin round a few times in both directions…you change direction by pressing the “platter” button. If you have really filthy records spin the platter more times and repeat the whole process including vacuuming – I buy a lot of my records second hand from brocantes and car boot fairs and most are filthier than a very filthy thing…use your imagination. To initiate the actual vacuuming process you have to press the button marked “vacuum” (no surprises there), the arm is sucked onto the record surface and then you let the machine do its thing until your record is perfectly dry. Turn the machine off, swing the arm out of the way, turn your record over and repeat. RCMBACKS

When in the vacuum phase the machine is pretty noisy…the cat, initially curious at this new spinning round device, ran away and hid when I pushed the vacuum button…but then she does when we vacuum the carpets so no surprise there.

The first record I cleaned was a recent buy from a second hand shop and was Joaquin Rodrigo Concierto De Aranjuez with Alirio Diaz on one side and Mauro Giuliani Concerto Pour Guitare, Cordes et Timbales OP 30 on the other. It’s from 1967 and had been poorly kept and very dirty. I had to do one side a couple of times and increased the number of rotations of the platter during the cleaning process, but the result was a spankingly clean record that played with barely a snap, crackle or pop. RCMTOPS
CONCLUSION 

The Clearaudio Smart Matrix Professional is a piece of cake to use, well built and does what it says on the tin. Yes it is quite pricey, but the question needs to be asked is it cheaper to extend the life of your stylus and irreplaceable records…I reckon this is money well spent and infinitely easier than my previous manual affair. It’s difficult for me to compare this unit to any of the others on the market I’m afraid as I’ve just not used any of the similar machines, but I’m happy with it and feel it offers a good deep clean. Definitely a keeper and is my xmas present to myself…I’ve already ordered fifteen litres of IPA ( Isopropyl Alcohol ) to make up some cleaning solution which should keep me going!
Build Quality: 8.75RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Ease Of Use: 8.5 (a fully automatic machine would be a great luxury)

End Result: 9

Value For Money: 8.35

Overall: 8.65 

Pros:

Good cleaning

Easy to use

Solid build 

Cons:

Quite pricey

Not automated

Share

Martin Logan Motion 15 Standmount Loudspeakers

$
0
0

Martin Logan make the fabulous (and massive) Neolith electrostatic loudspeaker and it is electrostatics they are best known for, but they also produce a wide range of smaller and more accessible loudspeakers and here Dan Worth takes a listen to the company’s £899 Motion 15 standmounter.

When I was offered a pair of Martin Logan speakers for review I thought great! Now I need to just assemble a team of lumps to help me get them up the stairs to my place. So when I actually realised that I was to receive a pair from their Motion range I knew my back was not going to be in harms way.

The set of Motion 15s I received had already done their rounds and were subsequently ready for the review process, so I can’t convey any burning in period.

The pair I had in for review were in a black lacquer and looked very nice indeed (white and deep cherry-red (pictured) lacquered finishes are also available).Motion15small

A folded ‘Motion’ ribbon tweeter looks great adorning the upper section of the 15’s front baffle and the 5.25″ aluminium mid/bass driver with its bullet dust cap/phase plug compliments a very sleek and pleasing on the eye design. Binding posts are of the wing nut variety making connection using spades or bare wire an easy affair allowing for great clamping and grip of the speaker cable ends, 4mm plugs are also accepted.

The Motion 15 are of a diminutive size, just about sitting on my stand’s top plate fully. Measuring 173 x 290 x 242mm and weighing in at 5.4kg each their 92db sensitivity is rated at 5ohms but ML state that they are fully compatible with 4ohm and 8ohm amplifiers rated between 20-200wpc.

The 15s are rear ported for extended bass response which can of course be a hindrance sometimes regarding placement. I didn’t feel as if they really suffered from being close to the front wall and moving them about a bit didn’t really affect the overall performance much, apart from having them right up against the wall of course which is great as smaller speakers will often be used in all sorts of situations from bookshelves to desks to stands.

SOUND

The first track up on my playlist was Fink’s ‘Sort Of Revolution’ – Live version. Slightly after the short intro there is a periodic snare drum, which Dom and I argue about sometimes, he states that the drums dynamic intensity and weight should often be greater than he hears it in my system but I disagree and state that as I have solid walls and floors and his are plasterboard and floorboards that he is hearing a greater heft around this frequency which perceivably adds to the weight of the snare.Motionartys

The Motion 15s are a small standmounts and therefore will not produce all the bass of a larger speaker, although my room by its very nature gives a tighter bass response I found the MLs to produce a nice rich bass note – the amount of bass they produce and the way they extend was admirable. Yes the crispness of the snare wasn’t as apparent as say the ATC SCM7s or 11s, but the bass weight, detail and flow of the smoother response was more pleasing to my ears with acoustical music and vocals.

Next up was Loreena Mckennit’s ‘The Mask and the Mirror’ album which has a vocal that allows you to sink into your seat and be washed over with pure emotion. The combination of the wonderfully controlled and smooth Motion ribbon with the aluminium mid/bass driver gave a fully intense and natural vocal which has nice inflections and harmonics with great situational awareness.Motionsmall

I didn’t expect Pop or Dance music to be a correct match for these speakers after my initial listening tests and I was right. Bass comes over really quite thin and the speakers become mid to top dominant and this leads to a forwardness. In their favour though, what I was hearing wasn’t ever hard, bright or grainy and it did show that the ribbon has some good speed. The Motion 15s excel so well with natural instruments and vocals that anything heavily manufactured or synthesized just fails to impress. You could simply state that these are voiced for ‘real music’.

I spent a few hours with the likes of Chris Jones, Fink, Derrin Nuendorf, Sean Lakeman, Damien Rice and Ben Harper. Each male vocalist was greeted with a fleshed out lower midrange response that gave the impression that the sound could have been coming from a larger cabinet, although when AB-ing with larger speakers revealed that there was more to be had, it took this process to remind the mind.

So congratulations to Martin Logan for addressing an area of the sound which can be either stark with other smaller footprint standmounts, or over rich in order to compensate for cabinet size.Motion15342web

I was, in my system, happy with soundstage height and front to back staging from the little Logan’s allowing for nice amounts of reverb, conveying spatial awareness and, dependant on recording, I heard many details outside of the speakers boarders across the front of the soundstage.

The combination of all of these areas gives a wonderfully cohesive and involving presentation, a balance which honestly reflects cabinet size yet reaches into the room and grabs the listener’s heart at any volume.

CONCLUSION

I wouldn’t conclude the Martin Logan Motion 15 speakers to be lively and subsequently not a punchy little speaker, but what they do offer is a strong and vibrant well staged sound, with crisp and controlled treble married to a strong stable midrange – for their price and size they do a remarkable job and have a sheer enthusiasm for instruments and vocals rather than punchier electronica.

They won’t ever get caught in a speed trap, but the top-end has great pace and the bottom-end doesn’t lag behind or ever seem slow, balancing nicely for a more natural presentation.

Overall characterisation is slightly smooth, un-offensive and particularly pleasing in a smaller sized room. The design and finish is great and the included grills protect the delicate ribbon from little hands and is also non-offensive or detrimental to the sound.

Build Quality: 9/10RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Sound Quality: 8.7/10

Value For Money: 8.7/10 

Overall: 8.8/10

Price at time of review – £899

For:
Great controlled top end
Strong rich vocals
Very natural balanced presentation
Well finished

Against:
Lack a bit of punch
Character doesn’t compliment energetic music 

Dan Worth

Share

Cabasse Stream 100 Amplifier and Surf Loudspeakers

$
0
0

French based Cabasse make the renowned Sphère loudspeaker system, but they also produce more modestly priced items.Here Dominic Marsh takes a listen to the Stream 100 amplifier (£499) and Surf loudspeakers (£379)

Cabasse Loudspeakers hail from France and have a long history of quality speaker manufacture, founded by Georges Cabasse in 1950. The Cabasse name goes even further back than that, with generations of the family engaged in building musical instruments since the 1700’s and still in use today with many orchestras, much prized by their musician owners.

CONSTRUCTION

STREAM 100 AMPLIFIER

Weighing in at only 1.9kg, there is nothing lightweight in its performance, with a continuous power rating of 50 watts per channel into an 8 ohms impedance.  It measures some 21cm wide by 22cm deep (including speaker terminals) by 9cm high.  The outer case is fabricated from black gloss Perspex on all sides except the rear panel, along the bottom edge of the Perspex runs a silver coloured alloy strip, inset into which is the front panel USB socket.  To the rear we find the input and output connections, starting with the LAN Ethernet wired connection plus ‘reset’ and WPS  buttons to synchronise the internet connection, a digital data input TOSLINK socket, 2 pairs of RCA analogue inputs, a trio of RCA analogue outputs to a pre-amp and subwoofer, then two banks of four (eight in total) speaker binding posts confusingly labeled 1 to 4.  The left bank of 4 binding posts is devoted to left speaker connections, while the right hand bank corresponds to the right speaker connections.  Unusually too, the positive terminals and the negative terminals are arranged horizontally, so to connect one set of speakers you need to connect to the top pairs of binding posts in the horizontal plane only for left and right accordingly.  A second pair of speakers can then be connected to the lower tier of binding posts in the same sequence, again arranged horizontally.  Note the lack of SPDIF digital input terminal, although there isn’t much space left on the rear panel for such an inclusion.  To the left of the speaker terminals is a small switch which configures the amplifier for either 4 ohm or 8 ohm speakers.  To complete the rear panel layout, we have an IEC power inlet socket without an earth pin which tells us it’s a double insulated device, a mains protection fuse and a small fan.  The Stream 100 is also configured for AptX Bluetooth connection.Stream-AMP-front-top-4-channels-stereo-on

Without any power applied, it appears to be a plain black Perspex box with rounded corners and an alloy trim with the Cabbasse legend screen printed onto the alloy strip, but power it up and a backlit display appears.  It is also touch sensitive controlled with all functions available, so if the dog runs off with the remote control and buries it in the garden, you are not hamstrung by having a device that won’t function.  Talking of which, it is an oval or pebble shaped unit that adjusts volume, input selection and mute, which fits neatly in the hand and you have to look twice sometimes to make sure the ‘right’ end is pointed at the amplifier due to its symmetrical shape. Stream-AMP-rear

The Stream 100 amplifier has a retail price at time of review at £499.00.

SURF LOUDSPEAKER

A fairly compact enclosure measuring 29cm high by 17.5cm wide by 22cm deep, with a tweeter measuring  27mm and a long throw 13cm bass driver with a rubber roll surround, the crossover frequency being 3,600Hz, with a frequency response envelope ranging from 65Hz to 23,000Hz.  Power handling is said to be 65 watts continuous with a maximum short term peak of 450 watts so Cabasse say, with a quoted  efficiency of 85dB for 1 watt of input measured at 1 metre on axis.  There is a single pair of binding posts, so is not biwire or biamp capable.   It is a reflex cabinet design with a rear facing port.  Available in either piano gloss black or gloss white finishes, the review pair submitted were finished in black gloss.  A pair of protective perforated metal grilles is supplied, which fits snugly into vertical slotted recesses either side of the front baffle.SURF-BLACK-3-4-W-GRILL-web1

SOUND QUALITY

I was rather pleased with the sound right at that first hearing, even knowing that both were factory fresh units and needed some running hours.  The bass in particular was constrained somewhat so I left the pair running for a full 24 hours, by which time the bass cones had loosened up considerably.  My initial listening sessions concentrated on this pair’s sound quality through the RCA analogue inputs, leaving the wireless, Bluetooth and digital inputs until much later.  I noted the top of the case had become slightly warm and although there is a fan fitted to the rear panel I didn’t hear it operating, that is if it activated at all during the listening sessions.SURF-BLACK-BACK-VIEW-1-web

So, connected up to the analogue outputs from my resident CD player, I began by playing my current reference disc, namely Fink’s “Wheels Turn Beneath My Feet” live album.  Track one on this album called “Biscuits For Breakfast” contains plenty of ambience cues from the venue it was recorded in and indeed this track probably has the greater wealth of this attribute than the entire album, each track recorded in different venues.  The Stream/Surf pairing did a pretty good job of relaying that ambience, although there were not unexpected limitations as how far they could scour the last drop of detail that other systems manage – albeit at greater cost, I might add.  Throughout this opening track the drummer gives a pounding rhythmic kick drum that underpins the entire piece and some fine cymbal work with crisp rim shots to the snare drum too, all of which has to sound tonally accurate with spot on timing to be believable and the Stream/Surf pairing gave a good rendition of that.  Moving on to the track “Sort Of Revolution”, the pace quickens and the audience shows plenty of enthusiasm by clapping along with the bass guitarist’s intro, adding whistles and cheers for good measure.  Once again I expect realism in this part of the track and lesser systems tend to blur and smear here, but to their credit the Stream/Surf pairing acquitted themselves well.  Following the intro the drummer sets up a pounding kick drum beat and he really does drive down onto the floor tom which has to be delivered with crisp power and authority by the speaker and amplifier under evaluation here.  A pleasant surprise as they mustered a goodly percentage of the standards I’m expecting during this track and I then became curious which component out of the two was the better performer.

“Go for broke Dominic” I thought to myself and paired the £499.00 Cabasse amplifier with a pair of Audiofilia AF-F6 floorstanders costing 6000 Euros no less.  Much to my surprise, the Cabasse amplifier drove them with absolute ease and produced a clean open sound with some decent heft in the bass registers too.  Top end too was well extended and crisp, with the Audiofilia speakers having a sensitive ribbon tweeter installed, any deficiencies here would soon have been readily highlighted.   Time for the Surf speakers to show what they are made of and in they went into my resident system, mounted on to 60cm stands around 15cm from the rear wall.  Given the size of the enclosures and drivers, they managed to produce a big hearty sound with plenty of drive and dynamics, comparable with speakers from a much higher price bracket.  However, I would liked to have heard just a tad more resolving power and detail resolution at the very top end of the treble registers as I struggled to hear the venue ambience changes in the Fink live album.  OK, I am nit picking here and at their £379.00 price point they performed rather well against their contemporaries in a similar price bracket, so they are worthy contenders for a serious listen in maybe an overly bright sounding system where that slight curtailment in the upper treble could be beneficial.Stream-AMP-100-3-4-top-view-e1424088398893

Fine then with analogue input, so how did the digital evaluation pan out?   Cabasse have their own downloadable software suite which I duly installed on my mobile phone so I could connect to the Stream amplifier both internet wirelessly and via Bluetooth.  The software perpetually told me I had to download the latest version after it had finished installing and that was despite downloading the current version and in the end I just ignored that message.  Apart from that small hiccup, the software worked very well, it was easy to set up and navigate, so for a crusty old reprobate like me it was a small blessing.  Of course my perpetual gripe about battery life with tablets and mobile phones still holds true and my own preference would be to link via internet wirelessly from my PC running Windows rather than a mobile device relying on limited battery power with either Apple iOS or Android operating systems, which of course my PC won’t run.  I cannot be the only person on this planet who wishes to stream wirelessly from either a PC or laptop running Windows surely?  My PC recognizes that these devices are registered on the ‘net, but no software to connect with them to send music to.  There is software that purports to do that available for Windows, but I have yet to manage configuring any of them to work in that role.   Sermon over, I did manage about 90 minutes of music from my mobile phone before the battery expired.

The Stream is equipped with a TOSLINK digital input and my resident CD player has SPDIF output only so apologies for skipping that, nor does it have HDMI or USB connections and that is a hindrance at times.  I do have a convertor box thingy but that isn’t a great performer so decided that was not a worthwhile move.  OK then, a USB cable from my PC to the front panel input on the Stream produced a comparable sound to the analogue input, again a satisfactory result.

CONCLUSION

While the Stream amplifier isn’t the Swiss Army Knife of media players with a plethora of inputs like some of its immediate rivals (notably the Pro-Ject MAIA), it more than makes up for that shortfall in outright sound quality and ease of use.   I particularly liked the touch sensitive front panel controls which means that if the remote control unit stops working or gets lost, at least you have full control of the device’s functions regardless.   It would therefore be wise before purchase to ensure that your source output connections match the input connections available with the Stream, as the convertors available on the market leave a lot to be desired.

On the subject of sound quality, the Stream managed to drive really well a pair of speakers that were well out of its league and capable of showing up any deficiencies the amplifier may have had and the Stream amplifier acquitted itself really well in this respect.  Paired with the Surf speakers they produced a powerful and pleasing sound that I could not really level any criticism at, save a slight rolling off at the extreme top end and I do mean extreme, which shouldn’t perturb the average listener.  A lack of SPDIF RCA digital input should be noted here again though.

The Surf loudspeakers also deserve merit as being very good performers in their own right both for their performance to size ratio and price.

SCORED AS A PAIRINGRECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Build quality: 8.4/10

Sound quality: 8.8/10

Value for money: 8.5/10

Overall: 8.56/10

Pros:

Ease of setup and good sound quality

Front panel touch controls are a welcome feature

Cons:             

No SPDIF digital input.

Dominic Marsh

Share

Zeta Zero Venus Picolla Loudspeakers

$
0
0

At just under £20 000 the Polish Zeta Zero Venus Picolla are a substantial investment, but they are gorgeously built and something of a work of art Janine Elliot thinks? How do they sound?

Tomasz Rogula takes after my heart. He is a sound engineer and owner of a recording studio, unadventurously named TR Studios, apparently very major in Poland. More than that, he is chief designer and founder of Zeta Zero. Zeta Zero is an audio manufacturer from Warsaw, Poland, specialising is multi-ribbon tweeters with large woofer loudspeaker systems, whilst also branching into original powerful monoblocks offering damping factor of 1600 at 8Ω (that is over 1000W RMS!).zetalifes

Tomasz’ heart and soul is really in the speakers, and having seen them and heard them in a recent UK show I wanted to take them for a ride myself. My own reference system includes a Townshend ribbon supertweeter and the Wilson Benesch Torus subsonic generator, so I wanted to test for myself an all in one offering using similar technology of carbon (though smaller at 12”) woofer, and this time no less than three ribbons.

The Venus Picolla comes in a choice of four finishes (Black, Mahogony-Brown, Sahara Sand and Transparent) with other colours on request, all artistically designed curves of hundreds of beautiful layers of wood all braced together with hundreds of screws at more than 200 points, forming a design inspired by architecture and sculptures. The shape is also based on musical instruments and with the absence of any parallel points the design effectively diminishes harmful effects of standing waves or resonances.

Lionel Monageng from Superior Hifi (UK Distributor)  delivered the beautiful work of art to my living room, making my house look more like it was Tate Modern. Apparently the shape is also based on the female form. Being a Venus, I guess that relates to a woman’s beauty, as captured by Paleolithic sculpturers of the past. As long as that is not how the designer sees me; its large bottom, holding the 12” carbon woofer built to Zeta Zero’s specification, looks like it seriously needs to go to weight-watchers. Whether or not you like the looks, this certainly is a radical speaker, reminding me of Vivid and other radical enclosures, and perhaps Lawrence Audio Cello or Double Bass.

The Zeta Zero models (presently a range of 4) are all designed not just for aesthetics, but to get the best sound. Quoted at 26-50,000Hz this 3-way design of a single bass, two mid-ribbons and a super tweeter allows short-term peaks up to 1000W, meaning your house, or rather mine, was filled with music with no signs of stress or pain. Indeed, these 65kg speakers can cope with rooms of up to 100sq metres quite well and delivering in excess of 130dB peak SPL, not that I tested this.zetazeopic1

All Zeta Zero speaker systems employ ribbons for the high frequencies. Tomasz is passionate about ribbons. Indeed, his latest offering, after 6 years of development, has no less than a 360 degree array of a single ribbon and single magnetic ring, the “Orbital 360⁰  ” creating omni-directional sound.  What makes the Piccola special is the fact that the ribbons can handle such high levels of sound. These are constructed using nano technologies and the most advanced components which – Thomasz says – are usually only found in military applications. These help to keep down the temperatures.

As well as four terminals allowing biwiring, there are two port holes at the back; one a tuned hole, and the other holding a potentiometer to vary the volume level of the HF above 14dB in a range of +/- 2dB. Also in this port is an RCA socket for a small box housing a 9v battery, supplied with the speaker that activates the computer on-board the Piccola to view the history of overloads on all speaker drivers. The display panel for this is located in the Super tweeter and flashes one of three colours; amber, green or red. Amber means you are still within recommended wattage levels for this model. Being fed with more than 800Watts will turn it red, though I didn’t want to try to test this out. Usually this computer is activated by the signal fed to the speaker when playing music too loud and works as defence mechanism to protect and record overloads. As Lionel told me; “The speaker owner can happily go on holiday and be able to check if the kids had a party while they were away. A ‘Big Brother’ in the Speakers!” (or rather, big sister, going by my earlier comments). Bear in mind the top frequencies only use 1% of the power of the lower frequencies, the highest ribbon would probably only be fed 1 – 5Watts from my own listening tests, so there was no chance of overloading it. The mid ribbons, well perhaps 10 Watts max. I do have neighbours…zetapic2

This was an interesting review. At £19,990 these are not cheap. They sit alongside B&W, Focal, Kef, Sonus faber, Wilson Audio, Wilson Benesch, Vivid and many other makes of top-notch loudspeakers, so this is a serious review. For just short of twenty thousand pounds this is a lot of money for speakers, but the design and build is certainly worth every penny. There is no MDF or plywood in this model. It was beautifully carved and glossed by a carpenter and is therefore necessary to be part of the cost of owning the artwork, taking considerable time to build each pair.

SOUND

Once set up and toed into my sitting position and around a metre from walls and anything else, I began my listening. The sound was very large, covering the soundstage with mighty detail and with smoothness only ribbons can do. Vocals were precise and inviting and all sounds carried a good depth in front and behind, and a reasonable width. Some people see in colours and for me the colour was a healthy green; not red or yellow brightness or a dull or boring blue or grey. This was exact, just as it should sound. The woofer is so close to the ribbons there wasn’t even a separation of sources or frequencies like some well-known and very expensive speakers that I could name.

Berlioz Symphonie Fantastique (Scottish Chamber Orchestra, Robin Ticciati, Linn 24/192) was exact and not showing any stress when the music gets excited, and this and anything else I played had sounds that were fast and with an ease of driving that only ribbons can do well.

Passing to David Gilmour’s latest offering, ‘Rattle that Lock’, showed the 12” woofer and ribbons at their very best. I don’t normally like large woofers, preferring a smaller bass or two or more in parallel, but these Carbon fibre bass units are very light, and actually don’t move a great amount, so the sound is still quite quick. From the bird atmosphere at the start of the first track “5 am”, to the bass pizzicatos under the string line followed by the electric guitar, to the broken chords on the acoustic guitar that followed, everything was there, and so very clear.

Even with all the power I needed to feed this Venus I could still have played this at 5am without annoying the neighbours, it was so beautiful.  Indeed, a test of a really good set of speakers is your ability to talk over loud sections and still be heard. “Rattle that Lock” is very bright and with complicated harmonies, but it was still so clear.  Whatever I played gave an authoritative and clear rendition from the very lows to the highs. I only at times found the music lacked the stereo spread I was hoping for that I get from my Wilson Benesch/Townshend Supertweeters, but it was only a small criticism. Everything else was there. And that’s just it; it was all there, very clear, just like I would expect in a recording studio, or even Tomasz’s own studio for that matter. Gilmour “The Boat Lies Waiting” sounded too clinical for me. Perhaps I was missing something that wasn’t there. It was just too easy for me. This album is very top heavy and I could feel it being slightly emphasised by the ribbons; it wasn’t adding anything, just showing the album as it was.  I was sitting in a Rolls Royce with beautiful wood veneer, and I really wanted a Ferrari for my bucks. I wanted more excitement.ZETACOLLECT

Switching to the Zeta Zero 1175 poweramps the sound was a different experience, actually working better than the Krell Class A amplifier I normally use to heat up my house. Although at first thought these are Class D, they are claimed as “operating on the principle of continuous (non-digitised) modulation of signal in a purely analogue manner”. Whatever magic is inside the box these amps are very efficient with my electricity supply, which is always a good thing, and with so much oomph available to pump up the Piccola they form a good partnership, though the sound from the amps didn’t work so well when I connected them to my Wilson Benesch. These mono-blocks are really good looking and have connections for single-ended RCA or balanced XLR, with sockets hidden under a flap so you only need to open the one you need, just in case your partner is keen on tidiness.

CONCLUSION

This is a really good offering, particularly if you place importance in the looks of your hifi. You would pay thousands for a work of art such as this, and on top of this it is a pair of loudspeakers. They work well in large or small rooms alike, though if a small room you might not have room for the settee. The sound should be the very best bearing in mind great bass and ribbon tweeters, and whilst it is excellent, it didn’t warrant a 9 from me (I rarely give a nine).  There is indeed brilliant harmony between the drivers, particularly bass and mid. But, £19,990 is a large amount of cash to spend, so I would listen to these and a few alternatives before you spend your hard earned cash.

Pros:RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Looks and build to the very highest level

Detailed sound

Excellent frequency range, particularly tops

Ribbons!

Work in small and big rooms

Cons:

Price

Can expose errors in the recording

Not everyone will like the looks

 

Sound Quality: 8.5/10

Value for Money: 8.4/10

Build Quality: 9.0/10 (Not everyone will like the looks)

Overall: 8.63/10 

Janine Elliot

Read more loudspeaker reviews

 

Designer’s Notes

The beginning of   Zeta Zero was over 12 years ago but I have been building loudspeakers for over 40 years now.  The roots of the design came from pressure from my friends and family to build for them very special and rather unique in sound quality. My wife was a very sensitive audiophile but also business a woman in Citi Corporation which meant she was very tough in her demands and so she was very demanding for the overall quality of the speakers, but also regarding the ART shape design.

One day she said to me: “Thomas,  I  want  for my living room something that is the best not only in a quality, but also very  very  beautiful in its styling.  I will never allow a …” wooden rectangular coffin in my house”. This order drove me to join my ribbon drivers with unusual shapes. Fortunately for me I found shapes that are different to traditional, rectangular boxes are much better in sound quality.

For thousands of years humankind has known very well that  non-rectangular shapes are good for  music and sound reproduction – look at nearly all instruments and  nearly all  sources of sound including percussions, pianos, guitars, violins, cellos etc. We do not need a university degree to understand that gently shaped loudspeakers will be better than traditional, rectangular shaped speakers.

Unfortunately contrary to real instruments most loudspeakers are the opposite of acoustic instruments in the respect of the shape.  Most loudspeaker designers are probably simply …very very lazy and they prefer to  build ” simple coffins” because they are very easy and much cheaper to build than gently shaped or with streamlined  bodies as with violins etc…

Of course some may say ‘but  a trumpet or  a horn is very directional so what?”   Ok…  but don’t you know that all professional musicians NEVER direct their horn at you directly during the performance??  They always try to move the horn around higher or lower “above your head and into the sky” when they play,but never directly at you as a listener. So they try to create multi directional emission of energy depending on played notes.

In 90% of world class recording studios you will also not find parallel walls or any parallel windows!  Any simple shape or parallel walls or planes are strictly forbidden in any good acoustic designs. Unfortunately in most of loudspeakers this simple rule is forgotten, missed and omitted.

So streamlined Zeta Zero shapes were developed and patented.

Mr Tomasz Rogula

Share

Lab 12 gordian Power Distributor/Conditioner

$
0
0

The gordian from Lab 12 is hand built in Greece and is a multifunction power distributor/conditioner with a host of functions to measure the quality of your power supply. It costs 1398€ and Stuart Smith bought a special Hifi Pig edition for this review. 

I first met the guys from Greek company Lab 12 a couple of years ago at the Munich High-End show and have been following their progress and products with interest since then. They make a valve integrated amp, a couple of tube power amps, a DAC, a preamplifier, a headphone amplifier, a passive attenuator and the subject to this review, the gordian “multifunction power distributor/conditioner”.  gordian_fr

gordian is basically speaking, and this will of no surprise, a product that will supposedly clean up the juice getting to your rig as well as offering distribution of the power to several pieces of kit. But it’s a little bit cleverer than that and that’s why I ordered one at last year’s Munich show…in Hifi Pig pink no less. The Designer’s Notes after this review will tell you more about the techy bits and pieces, but basically what you have here is a unit that is designed to clean up your mains supply without affecting the dynamics of the system. It also cleverly analyses your power supply and gives “live” readings via the front mounted OLED display – this is great fun. It measures frequency (accurate to 0.0005%), THD (accurate to 0.005%), RMS Voltage/Current, Power Consumption, Power Factor, FFT (frequency analysis) and DC Voltage and you can play with the amount of filtering the unit is applying too…or you can let gordian get on with it all on its own. gordian will also let you know if your ground/earth and polarity are in order.

On the front panel you have two large knobs. The one on the left navigates you around the various parameters you can play with, whilst the knob on the right controls the display itself. Both are chunky and responsive and feel purposeful and solid. Round the back you have four filtered outputs and two “mains” out sockets that are also filtered but intended for kit that is more power hungry. The sockets are industrial looking and, as you’d expect, very well made with the feeling that the unit was built to industrial standards…this is a good thing for a product like this I reckon. At the moment gordian is available with European and US sockets with a UK version planned in the very near future. At this point I ought to mention that gordian is CE and RoHS certified/stamped which again is important for this kind of unit. gordian comes with a well made 20A KNACK power cord measuring 1.5M. Overall it is a sturdy and well made unit that feels carefully put together by Lab 12.gordian_back

SOUND

I had a play with the various filters and messed with the degree of filtering gordian applied, but to be honest I found that the best results were to be had with the unit in automatic mode where it continually analyses your electrics and kit and filters accordingly. Again, read the Designer’s Notes after this review as I’m no scientist and interested only in the end result and the music that comes out the speakers.

I had amps plugged into the high output sockets and DAC, CD, phonostage and (when using an active pre) preamplifier in the remaining sockets.

We live in a very old house and the electrics are a bit wayward, we also live at the end of the line with farm buildings before us and the “quality” of the juice coming into the house has always been a bit of a concern at the back of my mind…and this is what led me to buy gordian from the off. And so what does gordian do? Well it does what it says really, with there being an immediate sense that unwanted noise in the system is lowered, which in turn allows you to hear more of what is going on in the music.

In quieter sections of music there is a feeling that you are able to hear more of the micro detail present in a recording. It’s difficult to describe but there’s also a sense of there being more spatial information available… this is most evident on acoustic tracks like my copy of Concerto De Aranjuez, with guitar feeling a touch more lifelike and “there” in the hall… like I say it’s hard to describe, but it is certainly a “better” effect/sound than with the unit out of the circuit.LAB123gordqin

One of the main criticisms of units that claim to “condition” the power being supplied to your system is that dynamics are affected, but I can categorically state that this is just not the case with gordian. The system still feels as fast and lithe as it always has and nothing in the frequency spectrum feels constrained or limited.

CONCLUSION

There’s not really a lot to say about the unit in all honesty other than this reduction in the overall “noise” on the line and the sense of you being able to hear more detail and more of what is going on in the track with a “cleaner” sound overall. I could warble on about a whole host of tracks that I listened to but the effect of gordian in the system remained constantly positive and consistent and so I see little point in doing this.

I’ve had the unit in the system for around three months now and in the first month I occasionally removed it for a few days to see what happened and found I consistently missed it being there. Basically gordian is a fit and forget bit of kit. Yes you can play with the settings which I’m sure many will want to do, but whack it on autopilot and let it do its thing and you’ll be well happy.

I did initially enjoy being able to see the analytics of the power supply (particularly the power draw when turning on bits of kit) and having a play around with that and I’m sure this will be a useful tool for those interested in knowing this kind of thing, but for the last couple of months Gordian has just sat there, quietly getting on with whatever it is that it does and I can heartily recommend it.

 

Sound Quality: 8.75/10 (difficult to quantify this really but definitely positive!)

Value for Money: 8.75/10

Build Quality: 9.0/10

Overall: 8.83/10 

 

Pros:

Fit and forget

A great tool for seeing what is actually going on in your system and with your power supply

Positive effect on sound 

Cons:

No UK version at the moment

Stuart Smith

Read more reviews

Designer’s Notes

gordian combines a powerful industrial grade power analyzer, a smart and adaptive power line conditioner, a power factor corrector and a robust power distributor. It aims at providing valuable information about our main power supply quality and gently improving the quality of our system’s power without affecting the positive characteristics of our system (e.g. dynamics) .

The analogue part of its powerful analyzer consists of 8 high precision measuring modules that continuously monitor frequency, AC voltage, DC voltage, high level current, low level current, EMI noise, ground resistance and power connection polarity. The output of these modules is routed to 8 ADC components which gather 256 samples per cycle for each measurement. As a result the main processor of gordian is fed with 2048 quality measurements per cycle of your power line.

Based on these measurements gordian also performs frequency analysis (Fourier transformation) of your system’s voltage and current. In other words, it analyses your system voltage and current and finds out the amount of noise that lives in various frequency ranges. Furthermore, it calculates the total harmonic distortion (THD) of your system’s voltage and current. THD is the most fundamental indicator of our power quality. It reveals how “pure” and sinusoidal our power signal is. Moreover, it calculates the power consumption and power factor of your system which indicates how effectively your system absorbs power from the electrical network.

All this valuable information (Frequency, AC Voltage, DC Voltage, Current, EMI Noise Level, Ground Quality, Connection Polarity, Frequency analysis, THD, Power Consumption, Power Factor, THD) is accessible through a big and legible OLED display and a simple and convenient menu navigation knob. Especially for the frequency analysis, the owner of gordian may observe a nice plot with a moving cursor for exploring the noise content in the various frequencies of the voltage spectrum. This is a really cool and unique feature that cannot be found in other power conditioning systems of this category. If you find the OLED display disturbing in the night you can adjust its brightness, turn it off or let Gordian detect when your system is inactive and automatically switch off the display.

All this impressive functionality is only about the power analyzing part of gordian. We have not touched yet the power filtering capabilities of this great device. Behind the scenes an adaptive network of passive elements (capacitors and inductors) undertakes the critical work of gently cleaning up your power. And it really IS adaptive and genteel. Every single piece of information that the analyzer gathers is taken into account for automatically adjusting the filter configuration to match the characteristics of your power line optimally. The filter can be configured in 4 different setups. It can be soft or aggressive, it can target to noise that lives in both our phase and neutral wires (Common Mode Filtering) or to noise that lives between the wires (Differential Mode Filtering) or to both of them. The correct decision will be taken by the gordian main processor or you can experiment with the different configurations and manually select the preferred setup. This is equivalent to having 4 different power conditioners and always using the one that best matches the characteristics of your power line.

gordian also performs power factor correction! Our audio or multimedia systems tend to behave like inductive loads. Inductive loads usually demonstrate a low Power Factor. This means that are not good at effectively absorbing the power of our electrical networks. This can be fixed by connecting a “bank” of large capacitors to our load and make it behave more like a resistance than an inductor. Some, power conditioning systems offers this functionality as a feature but it also can be a real disaster for our power quality, because if the connected capacitance is larger than the required one, this can damage further the power factor of our system. However, Gordian will automatically calculate and connect the optimal amount of capacitance to get the Power Factor of our system to the maximum feasible level. It will automatically detect the best capacitance option among the four available but the owner may also experiment and manually setup the Power Factor Correction module. Last but not least we have to add the overvoltage protection that Gordian incorporates to protect our devices from high voltage peaks.

Stratos Vichos

 

 

 

 

 

 

Share

Hana S Range Moving Coil Cartridges

$
0
0

Air Audio are distributing this Japanese company’s new range of cartridges in the UK and Ian Ringstead takes the first UK look at the high output and low output moving coil cartridges that cost £447 and both use a Shibata stylus.

The Hana range of cartridges is manufactured by Excel Sound Corporation, a 50 year old company based in Tokyo, who started off manufacturing low cost cartridges, such as the highly regarded Excel ES70. By 1978 the company was producing MC cartridges, with particular expertise in high output MC cartridges and specializing in OEM cartridge manufacture.hanaSL

Excel Sound Corporation are perhaps seen as one of those slightly underground Japanese companies and they will certainly not reveal which cartridge brands they have manufactured for over the years.

Excel Sound Corporation prides themselves on their manufacturing quality and quality control processes at every stage, ensuring their handmade cartridges offer consistently perfect results.

The high performance Hana S range “SH” and “SL” cartridges use a nude natural diamond Shibata-stylus which the company say is capable of “excellent high frequency response with supreme transparency and excellent trackability”. The S range comes in two output options offering either high output 2.0mv/1KHz (SH) or Low output 0.5mv/1KHz (SL). Both options are £447 each which places them as a relatively modestly priced offering.hanaSH

I was sent both the high and low output versions and it was interesting to see what differences there were between the two, especially as they look identical and the specifications appear identical apart from the output level and impedance. The Shibata stylus is a design I remember well from my retail days and was a clever way of improving a cartridges performance.

When CD4 Quad 4 channel recordings were developed, the designers needed to be able to record and play back frequencies up to 45kHz – more than twice the highest goal frequency attained with the eliptical styli. The very fine corrugations in the groove required for 45kHz were more easily worn away and so a design was required that could 1) track much higher frequencies and 2) Reduce wear on the record. The first stylus that achieved this was the now famous “Shibata” (named after its inventor).hana.all4 carts (1)

Rather than providing a small circular “dot” contact point with the groove, the more complex shape of the Shibata stylus allowed a long vertical line of contact to be achieved with the groove wall. The result of contacting more of the groove wall was the achievement of the two primary goals mentioned above.

Through better wall contact, tracking was improved and information retrieval improved (facilitating higher frequencies), and because the total contact surface area increased, the amount of pressure per square area was substantially reduced – less pressure equals less wear on both the record and the stylus.

In actual fact the side radius of the Shibata is about the same as a 0.2 mil elliptical stylus – so theoretically they have the same ability to track high frequencies, but the eliptical stylus only ever contacts the same small area – which can become worn – resulting in degradation in high frequencies over time.

Playing back a record with a Shibata stylus which has been worn with a conical or eliptical stylus can result in near pristine sound – this is because the Shibata shape can “read” the groove wall in areas that were not in contact, and as such not worn by, the simpler stylus shapes.

Now all this information is interesting but how does it translate into the sound of the Hana cartridges.

SOUND

I first tried the high output model in both a Rega Planar 3 turntable with RB300 arm and my Project Extension 9 turntable running the both through my Whest Audio Two phonostage.

What immediately impressed me with both cartridges was the very low surface noise and how quiet they were overall. There was no hum even with the level turned well up and this made for an easy listen where the music was highlighted without being drowned out with irritating surface noise. I am sure the Shibata stylus helped contribute to this performance and proves what a clever design it is. High frequencies were clearly portrayed and detailing was very good on instruments like cymbals, hi-hat etc. and background detail was easily retrieved, making for an enjoyable listen. Vocals were clear and well projected in the sound stage which itself had good depth and spread. Bass was also well defined and detailed.

On trying the low output version what could this do? Well I have always liked low output moving coils and they seem to dominate the quality cartridge market, but not everyone thinks this way and some people even prefer moving magnets. I won’t try to explain why, other than to state I have found in my own personal preference for low output moving coils by auditioning lots of different types over the years.

In this case the Hana low output model just added more to the listening experience in terms of better detailing and depth over the high output model. I cannot fully explain this, it’s just what I heard and it wasn’t a subtle preference when compared to the high output model.

I listened to Deep Purple Made in Japan from 1972 and although an old recording it still sounds detailed and exciting. “Smoke On The Water” was as always very enjoyable with the classic, catchy riff many an aspiring young guitarist has tried to emulate being ably projected between my speakers in all its glory. The Mule which follows this has a drum solo by Ian Paice which was de rigeur for all rock concerts back in the seventies and the Hana managed to pick out loads of detail and the subtle clues of the drum kit were beautifully laid bare and it was easy to hear all the different techniques of Ian Paice and pick out the drum types and cymbals. I have been to many live concerts and so I can recall what these solos were like and appreciate when they were well miked up and mixed by the sound engineer so as to excite the audience and show off the drummer’s skills.

Joe Samples Carmel was played next and showed what a brilliant keyboard player he was. A jazz musician admired the world over; people will remember him for his time in the Crusaders and their huge hit with Street Life in the 80’s with Randy Crawford on vocals. I also played another album from the 80’s, Graceland, by Paul Simon. This album revitalised Paul Simon’s career after he had split from Art Garfunkel and he was discovering new sounds and musical ideas in South Africa. The album has many great tracks on it and “You Can Call Me Al” was a smash hit that is so infectious in its beat and the superb bass solo near the end that makes me smile every time I hear it. Also “Diamonds on the soles of her shoes” showcases the superb vocal prowess of the Ladysmith Black Mambazo singers. The Hana SL really picked out all the subtleties of this track and how skilled the singers are as well as their fantastic vocal harmonies in all heir glory.

CONCLUSION

I really liked these cartridges as they were fuss free and just got on with their job of producing great music. The low output for me was better but this doesn’t mean the high output was poor or wouldn’t be preferred by some listeners. If you only have a moving magnet input on your amp or pre amp then the high output version is a no brainer.

£447 is not cheap, but for a good quality moving coil it is very good value and is the lower end of a popular choice of cartridge type for audiophiles into their vinyl.

Full marks to Hana, who obviously know what they are doing, for putting their name to a range of excellent value for money cartridges for the less ‘well to do’ vinyl fanatic.

Both cartridges work well in both budget and higher-end turntable/ arm combinations and are well worth seeking out.

Low Output RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Build quality: 8.7/10  

Sound quality: 8.7/10

Value for money: 8.6/10  

Overall: 8.6/10                              

High OutputRECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Build quality: 8.7/ 10  

Sound quality: 8.3/10

Value for money: 8.6/10

Overall: 8.5/10 

Pros: 

Shibata stylus really works well

Low surface noise

Great detailing

Low and high output versions to suit tastes and pre amp capability 

Cons: 

Not budget priced but otherwise hard to fault

Ian Ringstead

Share

Lampizator Big 7 DAC

$
0
0

At €11000 plus taxes as tested the Lampizator Big 7 is certainly no budget DAC, but does it deliver on sonic ability? Stuart Smith finds out. 

I first heard the Lampizator Big 7 last year at Munich High-End in the Sound Galleries of Monaco booth, along with a pair of Avantgarde Duos, cables from Tellurium Q and room treatment by GIK and for me it was one of the standout sounds of the show. Now we put an order in for a pair of the new Duo XDs at Munich and we use TQ speaker cables in the main system much of the time along with GIK’s room treatment panels and so it seemed a sensible to at least audition the Big 7 to see if we would get along with it at home. Of course, if we liked it, there was always the option to dig deep and make it a permanent fixture. And you will need to dig deep if the Big 7 does the sonic business for you as it comes in at a not inconsiderable €11 000 plus appropriate taxes as featured here.lampizator big7balvol

Let’s get the negatives out the way first because there are a few issues I have with this unit, and, whilst these issues are not deal breakers by any stretch of the imagination, I do think certain features could be improved upon. First of all we have the packaging that this particular unit came in. Yes it arrived safe and sound, but this is a premium product and as such I expected much more than (an admittedly double boxed) package with what looked like off cuts of packing foam to protect the unit – I expected that Christmas morning feeling that we constantly bang on about! Of course this would add to the already not insignificant cost of the Big 7, but come on guys! Secondly is the joke of a remote control which is a cheap, plasticky affair that would be more at home with a seventy five quid portable television from CostCo or Argos. Finally the unit supplied had a loose digital RCA input that required tightening…this meant taking off the top of the DAC and sorting it out myself…this really should have been checked at the final stage of packing!

Now I’ve got that little lot off my chest let’s begin with the review proper.

So what do you get for your money when you buy the Lampizator Big 7? Actually you get a pretty comprehensive unit that, although expensive, can save you a few quid elsewhere in your system. The sample we have here has the preamplifier board built in that has one input via RCAs, meaning that you can use the Big 7 without a separate preamplifier and feed it straight to your amplifier (s) of choice, saving you the added expense of buying a pre. This of course only works if you have a relatively basic system, but to be fair the vast majority of folk will be catered for in this respect as you can put your CD’s digital out in to the Big 7’s S/PDIF input, your computer’s USB out into its USB input (32 bit/384 kHz PCM and DSD upto 128x ) and your phonostage (or whatever else you have that feeds a line signal) into the preamplifier section’s RCA inputs. Outputs offered on the model we have are a pair of RCAs and a pair of balanced XLRs. There’s also an AES/EBU input on XLR but that hasn’t been used. So, connection wise you are nicely covered with the Big 7 and could run a system with just a computer or transport, the DAC, amp and speakers should you wish.

On the front of the unit you get the volume knob (on this version) and an LCD display showing you the input you have selected and volume…it’s not a great display and I had to be close by to see what was selected.

Via USB you get a DSD engine that will deal with 64x and 128x and whilst I’m well aware that there is a number of people who believe that DSD is little more than a fad I would say that these folk should go out and take a listen to a properly encoded DSD recording on a proper DAC and then make their minds up. The DSD engine uses “unmanipulated, filtered, raw, native data-stream as the signal” which essentially means there is as little as possible happening to your DSD signal before it is output.  Inside the Big 7 it has to be said that it is beautifully put together and is a bit of a testament to the engineer’s skill. There are two standard chokes (the Golden Gate version has “premium chokes”) Copper/wax Jupiter caps and the unit comes as standard with four 101D Psvane tubes and a Shuguang 274B rectifier tube. Now as we are on with the tubes, you can do a good degree of tube rolling (I chose not to) and use 101D, 45, 245UX or 2A3s with the heater voltage being changed accordingly by a switch inside the DAC. Wiring inside the unit is all silver in Teflon and you get separate transformer windings for the valve circuit, a separate transformer for the digital section and separate secondary windings “for every task”. As with most reviews I write I won’t get bogged down in the technical side of things as I just don’t have the knowledge or interest other than the end result and the music that comes out the speakers and so urge you to read the Designer’s Notes that follow this review.

The Big 7 is so called with good reason because whilst it may not actually be that heavy (it weighs 16KG) it is pretty large, particularly in depth, measuring 45cm in width, 12cm in height (25cm if you account for the tubes) and…wait for it…53cm deep. Most racks will not accommodate this depth of course, but the Big 7 has six feet underneath meaning that the front two pairs will sit nicely on a standard depth rack, with the remaining pair and the back end of the DAC overhanging by 12cm on the IKEA unit I had it sat on. This is not a problem for me as I have plenty of space behind the current racks, but will mean you’ll need to pull your rack away from the wall a little further than usual…and don’t forget you’ll need space for cables too.

Apart from the gripes I outlined at the start of this piece, the Big 7 we have has been well put together, looks pretty neat (despite its size) and whilst it’s not got that “built like a tank” or luxe feel to it, it is reasonably nicely finished and feels relatively solid.

I used the Big 7 with the usual suspects – Musical Fidelity NuVista CD as transport, Laptop running JRiver and set up as per the instructions Lampizator publish online, Merrill Thor amps and a variety of cables from Chord, Tellurium Q, Atlas and Vermouth Audio. Over the time the DAC has been with us it has been used with a whole host of loudspeakers including the hORNS Mummys, Leema Xens and more latterly the Avantgarde Du XDs. Power to the DAC was filtered using the LAB 12 gordian.

First let’s have a chat about the Big 7 in use as it is not your usual “plug and play” type scenario. You turn the Lampy on with a big toggle switch located round on the back panel. This is centrally located and whilst it’s pretty easy to find, I would have preferred to have this on the front, on the side, or even underneath the DAC. Flick the switch and the unit slowly comes to life and the warm glow of the valves begins. Now you need to pick up the remote, choose your input and then turn the volume of this input up. As you turn the volume up there is an audible clicking inside the DAC which was at first a bit disconcerting. The unit defaults to zero every time you turn it off and this is a bit of a pain in the arse in the beginning until you get used to it, and the remotes “unique” layout…I can’t help thinking that a dedicated and nicer remote would be far superior, but I have to temper my frustration here and remember that the Big 7 is made for audio enthusiasts in the truest sense of the word…but then at the same time I can’t help thinking that we live in the 21st Century and really don’t need to be wearing hair shirts to get the best sound out of our systems.B7PCB-filtered

I’m reading this review through in my head and I can sense that a good few readers will be thinking that this review is going to absolutely pan the Big 7 given everything I have said up to now, but I urge you to read on as despite the obvious shortcomings of certain aspects of the DAC’s makeup, in the end what interests me most in a product that comes in for review is the pleasure (or otherwise) that it affords me sonically.B7PCB 2-filtered

SOUND

OK, it would be easy to sum up the sound when listening to DSD files as nothing short of an absolute aural revelation that simply took my breath away with each album I listened to. The immediacy and realness of what was coming out of the speakers was, in my experience, simply without match. Jazz At The Pawn Shop is a great recording in any case, but using the Naxos 2xHD file at 128x DSD ( LINK ) was nothing short of overwhelming. This is as near to a group of musicians sitting in my front room as there has ever been. This may well sound like reviewer hyperbole but I mean it…this is stunning stuff. Every nuance of the recording is laid before you, every part of the musicians’ playing style becomes apparent and you cannot help but just get lost in the music and the experience. I found myself listening to classical music on DSD simply for the sonic thrill of it all…I may not appreciate or particularly like the tunes, but the Big 7 lays an orchestra before you like I have never experienced before. Native Stereo’s “8 Ensembles in 1 Bit Stereo” is gripping, with the New Amsterdam Voices version of Randy Newman’s Short People being a bit of a standout. You can sense the recording space and you can hear every nuance and inflection in this septets’ delivery. I know it’s a bit of a Hifi cliché to harp on about the musicians “being there”, but with the Big 7 playing DSD files this is truly what you get…and it’s addictive stuff. There is a purity and rightness to the sound that is hard to describe. Yes all the component parts of bass, mids and treble are of course there, but the Lampizator does something exquisite to the DSD signal that “adds” another, wholly beautiful aspect to the music. Soundstage and imaging are “reach-out-and-touchable” with you able to aurally see the performance that is being presented before you without it feeling false. Sadly I don’t have a whole load of DSD files but the few that I do have are presented in such a fashion with the Big 7 that I became somewhat obsessive in playing them, again just for the pure and unadulterated feeling of flawlessness I got when listening to them.

Feeding the Big 7 with hi-res files from the laptop was only slightly less impressive and this is more down to the format than the fault of the DAC itself I reckon, although on techno and more “machine-made” music I did feel the Lampy lost a bit of the pizzazz you get when throwing properly recorded musicians at it. This is not to say the Big 7 is not impressive with this kind of music, it is, very, it’s more that where this DAC really does shine is on well recorded, live music where you get to experience the real feel of the recording space and the musicians within it. With techno you still get that reach out and touch it feel of the mix that surrounds you in an almost (another cliché alert) three dimensional way, but it’s just not as extraordinary as when listening to the other music I mentioned. However, what you do get when playing this kind of music is a full representation of what is on the original file – bass is hefty and pumping and hats are shimmery and sparkly. I listen to a lot of this kind of stuff and again became really addicted to it playing on the Big 7.

I should add here that the settings that Lampizator suggest you use for JRiver (as I understand it) upsample the PCM signal to DSD and I reckon this is certainly a good thing. I didn’t bother listening to straight PCM files from the computer as I really saw no point.

When playing CDs through the DAC you get the feeling that you are losing a little of the three dimensionality you get when playing DSD and hi-res files but you still get a really beautiful rendition of the music and that “live” feel. On rock like Deep Purple’s Live in Japan there is the gut wrenching bass apparent on Smoke On The Water (any product that can’t do this gets short shrift from me) and again a feeling of there being real musicians in front of you, but there is a feeling that you are using a really refined and beautiful product to reproduce music that is just the opposite…sort of like having Lemmy (RIP) play a Stradivarius… I hope that makes sense. Where the Big 7 really shone for me on CD was with vocals and real instruments. The DAC just brings a feeling of rightness to proceedings that you just can’t help but sit there with a smile on your face and get lost in the moment.

CONCLUSION 

I have real issues with companies that feel it is OK to skimp on things like packaging and finer details like decent remotes and I do think that Lampizator need to pull their finger out in this regard. It is inexcusable that a creation costing this kind of money should come packaged like a second hand product you bought off Ebay and the less said about the sorry excuse for a remote the better!

That said, sonically, the Big 7 from Lampizator is without a doubt the finest DAC that I have yet to experience in my home, though I would love to have it up against the completely different approach of the Chord DAVE. When compared to my reference DAC (VAD DAC) it comes across as (simply put) just better in every regard other than build which it equals…it should as it’s more than twice the price.

The Big 7 manages to sound unprocessed and pure in its presentation of everything you throw at it and with a fluidity and openness that just has you glued to your seat. The Big 7 is a truly breathtaking creation that brings a degree of enchantment to a listening session that is hard to ignore, and with live, well recorded music it is truly spectacular in what it does. There are going to be reviews of the Big 7 that will waffle on about how it makes the digital format sound analogue, but that is to miss the point completely I believe. Of course it doesn’t make digital sound analogue…it takes a digital signal and presents it in a fashion that is natural and unadulterated and as such allows you to connect emotionally with the music you are listening to…and for me that is what all this is about.

Build quality, aside from the loose RCA on our sample, is acceptable in a no-nonsense kind of way and, whilst the Big 7 isn’t going to win any beauty contests, it looks pretty neat sat on the rack.

This is not a product for the average person I don’t think and you do need to be able to look (and hear) beyond the Big 7s physical presentation, but if you do you will be amply rewarded.

Would I recommend the Big 7 from Lampizator? It is expensive without a doubt and the value is not immediately apparent – there is no bling, no ostentatious detailing and it all looks pretty workaday, but turn it on, faff with the remote (it’s not immediately intuitive), settle into your listening position with a glass of something nice and you will be transported to musical delight. So yes I do recommend it and if you are on the look out for a new DAC and can afford the asking price I would strongly suggest you audition it.

Build Quality: 8.1/10 (simply down to the remote and packaging)RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Sound Quality: 9.5/10

Value for Money: 8.5/10

Overall: 8.7

Pros:

Simply stunning sound

Tube rollable should you feel the urge 

Cons:

Packaging and remote are poor

Display too small

Expensive 

Stuart SmithGPOINTREVIEWAD

Designer’s Notes

“I have something very special for you. Something from the heart. My gift. “  I heard my Master of tubes  Evgennyi saying something like this very rarely, if ever. He was a shy, down to earth engineer, totally immersed in the electron cloud.

He pulled from the box a strange preamp, with huge tubes. It looked like a typical 300B amp.

“Why such gigantic tubes?” I asked, “what is so different about them ?”

“I can’t explain this, nobody can. But they have special grown up sound.”  What ? grown up sound? What do  you mean ?  He did not answer, and I never saw him again. He passed from lung cancer with a cigarette in the corner of his lips, just few months later.

To this day I can’t explain it myself, because we can’t measure it or pin it down but the big DHT tubes do sound different compared to typical small signal novals. Even with the same amplification, same current, same signal – the sound is … well … grown up. It is effortless, smooth, dynamic and 3D. It is addictive. I made my prototype 4 years ago with Russian 300B and ever since the DHT DAC became my obsession. It took us one year just to get the heaters right and another year to do everything else. These DHT tubes present huge challenge. The heating circuit and the music circuit are mixed together, entwined.  …try try try to separate them – it’s an illusion …” as the song goes. For whatever reason working with DHT for me was 10 times harder than working with small signal tubes. Still the sound from the early prototypes was encouraging enough to keep me going. We needed to design and order custom wound power transformers, use bigger chassis enclosures, rework everything I knew about grounding, etc. The first sellable unit went to Las Vegas show in 2014 and made a splash there. Thats how the Big 7 was born. Ever since this is my best seller and the marriage of big tubes and DSD made Lampizator what it is now. I take pride in designing a “current source PSU” for tube heaters allowing us to use 101D, 45, 245, 345, 300B, 6A3, 2A3, PX4, 242, – just to list the basic DHT pool of tubes for rolling. Some of them are 100 years old. Some of them cost 5000 Euro a pair. But they have one thing in common – PEOPLE LOVE ROLLING THEM. And I tend to agree.
Łukasz Fikus

 

Share


Naim Mu-So

$
0
0

John Scott is entranced by the sleek, stylish beauty of Naim’s £850 all-in-one speaker system but will she sound as good as she looks?

The Arrival Of The Queen Of Sheba

I described in the November 2014 issue of Hifi Pig Extra how I fell head over heels with the Naim Mu-So in the middle of the John Lewis department store without ever having heard her sing a note.  So, you can imagine my delight when she turned up on my doorstep and asked if she could stay for a few weeks.mu-so_2_vibrant-reds

Okay, I’ll try to stop anthropomorphising the Mu-So now before it gets really annoying but I can’t promise.  The Mu-So arrived a day earlier than I was expecting and I was just about to go out with my wife to the cinema.  “I suppose you will want to stay home and play with that now” my wife said, pointedly – how well she knows me.  I was as surprised as she was when I heard myself say that I did still want to go out but that I’d just get the Mu-So out of its box and set it up in the sitting room in the half hour we had available  before we had to leave.

So, Mu-So out of box, power cord attached and plugged in, Ethernet cable attached and Mu-So powered up.  Music immediately started playing from one of its pre-set internet radio stations.  Set up and playing music in no more than five minutes, I was impressed.  I had already downloaded the Mu-So app to my iPad in anticipation of its arrival so I fired this up and tapped the Tidal button, typed in my registration details and my Tidal music library was immediately available to play.  Impressed again.  Tapping the UPnP button brought up a Windows Media Server icon and an LMS server icon, as used by my Squeezebox Touch streamer.  Tapping the LMS icon gave me access to my extensive digital music library stored on a networked external hard drive.  Could I be more impressed?

At this point I was physically dragged away to the cinema (Spectre, thanks for asking).  As much as I was enjoying the film, my mind kept slipping back to a certain sleek silver box that was waiting for me at home.  When my son texted me to say that he had forgotten his house keys and would be shut out in the wind and rain for the next two hours I took a lot less persuasion than I normally would to leave the film and return home.

Firing the Mu-So back up, I was surprised to see no sign of the LMS icon on my app and no evident way of making it appear (Tip: tapping the iPad screen really, really hard doesn’t help and shouting at the iPad is, if anything, even less helpful; now, Siri wants to call the police any time I try to ask her a question) so I contented myself with listening via Tidal and resolved to sort out the UPnP issue in the morning.mu-so_1_vibrant-reds

I’d been advised that the Mu-So had come direct from another reviewer and that it would be advisable to reset it to its factory default settings so bright and early next day, I did this – it’s a simple matter of pressing a recessed button with a little pin-like tool – and then set about activating the Windows Media Server on my laptop – I’d never used WMS before – and importing my music library.  WMS clearly didn’t like the look of my library and kept crashing so after about an hour of restrained swearing I began to google for an alternative solution and came up with a free server called Serviio – other free servers are available but Serviio worked like a charm.  It download and installed easily and I left it alone for a few hours to become acquainted with my music library while I went Christmas shopping with my wife, totally of my own free will and with absolutely no complaints whatsoever (ahem).

Back home, lighter of wallet and heavier of heart, the app now cheered me up by presenting me with three icons: WMS, Serviio and, you’ve guessed it, LMS; I can only imagine that the Mu-So was flirting playfully with me.  I’m happy to say that all three icons remained in place afterwards.  Also, there are differences in how Serviio and LMS present your music library within the Mu-So app and each have their individual good points so having both installed is not a bad thing.

If the set up process was slightly more involved than my first 5 minutes with the Mu-So had suggested, it was still pretty straightforward.  Having said that, if buying a Mu-So is your first experience of streamed, networked audio then you will have a bit of a learning curve to contend with.  The start up guide that comes with the Mu-So is pretty basic but the Naim website does contain more comprehensive support.

Before serious listening could start there were a couple of small adjustments to make.  The app allows the Mu-So to be set up to compensate for its position in the room; if it is far from a rear wall, the lower frequencies can be boosted and if the Mu-So is to be played at low volume, a loudness filter can be activated.  I set the Mu-So to play close to a rear wall and with the loudness setting deactivated.

A Small Technical Diversion 

Behind the Mu-So’s grill lie six custom-designed speakers, each of which is powered by a 75 watt digital amplifier.  A bass port enhances performance of lower frequencies.  Naim claim that Mu-So’s 32 bit digital signal processor is capable of one hundred and fifty million calculations per second, running a custom-designed code to ensure that each speaker receives the right frequencies at exactly the right time.  Connectivity is either by Ethernet cable, wireless, USB, Airplay or Bluetooth. WAV, FLAC, AIFF, ALAC and MP3 formats are all supported.  High resolution formats required a wired connection. mu-so_4_grille-offs

A Thing Of Beauty Is A Joy Forever – Not Just Three Days, George

George Bernard Shaw said: “Beauty is all very well at first sight; but who ever looks at it when it has been in the house three days?”  George clearly wasn’t a Hifi fan; if I lost my heart to the Mu-So at first sight there was no chance of my ardour waning during the time that I had it in my possession – it truly is a lovely thing, it’s sleek, modern lines fitting in seamlessly to the traditional décor of my sitting room.  Mu-So’s cabinet is made of wood, covered by a skin of anodised aluminium to increase rigidity and damping.  The front grill features a sculpted wave that echoes the design of Naim’s flagship Statement amplifier.  The grill comes in black as default but replacement grilles are available in other colours albeit at the slightly eye-watering price of around £70.00 each.   On the top panel sits the beautifully tactile input/volume control made from a perfectly weighted sold ring of aluminium, illuminated from below.  Tapping this control turns the Mu-So on and off and provides input choices.  Turning the control adjusts the volume (from zero to eleven for Spinal Tap fans).  Control is also available via a supplied remote control or an iOS/Android app.  Such was the quality of the app that I found the remote to be entirely redundant.mu-so_6_tops

Easy Listening 

As mentioned above, the Muso’s app allows you to access and play music stored on your network or via the Tidal streaming service (if you have a subscription). Hundreds of internet radio stations are also available and you can select five of these as pre-sets.  Whatever music source you choose, navigation is quick and simple.

Having got the Mu-So set up, it time to get down to some serious listening.  As the Mu-So had been out to other reviewers before I received it, no run in time was required.  What I hadn’t anticipated however was that I was the one who was going to need a period of running in: for the first couple of days whenever I sat down to listen to some music I found myself staring at the Mu-So and thinking: “How can something as small as that be producing a sound as big as this?”   Fortunately, that feeling faded and I was soon able to give the music the attention it deserved. Playing the title track of John Martyn’s Solid Air album, all the familiar warmth and ambience I expected was present.  Martyn’s blurred vocals hung in front of the Mu-So with the instrumentation arranged around him and I could almost see the haze of cigarette (?)  smoke rising in the air.  Why So Serious from the soundtrack of The Dark Knight is a challenging track for any system to resolve correctly but the Mu-So took it in its stride.  Punishing dynamics, deep, deep bass and high rising strings were all handled without any obvious sense of strain.   Inevitably, the Mu-so’s size and design means that it never going to present the biggest of sound stages but it does a better job than you might expect; the Mu-So seemed equally at home whether playing solo acoustic guitar of large scale symphony orchestras.mu-so_7_sides

It wasn’t all plain sailing though.  An Ethernet connection allows the Mu-So to play high resolution files up to 24/192.  I found that 192 files were prone to stuttering and drop outs but I’m confident that this was a symptom of my network set up rather than a failing on the part of the player.  My set up gave me no option but to make an Ethernet connection to my router via powerline adaptors. If you intend to use 192 files then I would strongly recommend a wired Ethernet connection directly from router to Mu-So.

Conclusion 

Naim’s Mu-So delivers a level of performance that is in keeping with its build quality and stunning good looks and that belies its size.   If you already have a high-end traditional Hifi system made up of a collection of boxes and speakers then it is unlikely that you will want to replace these with a Mu-So.  If, however, your living arrangements make a traditional Hifi set up impractical, or if you want a second system for another room then the Mu-so is worthy of serious consideration. I still look at the space where “my” Mu-So used to sit and feel a little pang of loss.  But while she was with me we made beautiful music together.

Sound quality:  8.2/10 RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Value for money:  8.7/10 

Build quality/styling : 9/10 

Overall:  8.6/10

Pros

Excellent build quality and styling

A sound you would expect from the Naim pedigree

Easy set up

Intuitive, comprehensive app. 

Cons

Limited soundstage (to be expected)

May be fussy about network quality

Replacement grilles expensive

John Scott

 

 

Share

A Chord Company Budget Loom

$
0
0

The Chord Company

When we were initially discussing this review by Dave Robson with The Chord Company we wanted to see what the company’s ‘loom’ would bring to the table ‘off the shelf’ and “untailored” to the specific system being used. Chord offer a service they call The Cable Doctor in which they tailor a combination of cables specifically to what they feel your system would benefit the most from. However, we wanted this first of two reviews to set a benchmark and in the coming weeks we will be conducting a second review using cables supplied by Chord after us using the Cable Doctor service. This will allow us to compare and contrast the bog standard, ‘of the shelf’ cables with a more bespoke set up. 

The Chord Company C-Line RCA (1M) (ARAY)

Yup, feels like Christmas!! I’ve been sent a full “loom” of Chord Companies C-Line and Clearway cables to review over the festive season. These consist of the C-Line RCA 1m (£45), Clearway Digital 1m (£100), C-Stream Streaming Cable 10m (£90) and Clearway Speaker Cable 2x3m pair (£10pm unterminated).

The C-Line RCA out of the box is a nice flexible cable; moulded pale blue RCA’s cover a gold plated inner grip. These connectors look tough and hardwearing and there are little arrows on the cable showing that the wires are directional…one of those subjects that can get end in a heated debate when discussed but personally I believe it’s good to know that the research has been done by Chord and a critical decision has been made. Even if you’re not a believer then at least you can connect your RCAs the same way every time. The cables come separately which is a good thing as some electrical equipment connections are set wide apart and I have struggled in the past to get some joined cables to fit. The ARAY Technology has been used in the past on Chords high-end cables with great results. This uses very high quality copper fibres in conjunction with foil shielding incorporated within the construction of the cable with the intention of improving the sound quality of this relatively inexpensive cable. I was advised by Chord that the burn in would take approx 48hrs before the cables were fully settled. My past experiences with cables from around this price point is that usually they try too hard in one area or another, getting stuff “nearly” right but very rarely getting it completely balanced. I have seemed to accumulate RCA cables a bit like motorcycle gloves and compilation CDs  over the years and have far too many of them… I’m always willing to take a punt when something is reasonably priced!

Onward with the review. A bit of all round goodness in the guise of Dire Straits (as it’s nearly xmas and I will be by January). On “Money For Nothing” Sting’s vocal intro’ comes out of the blackness followed by the famous drumming, bouncing from side to side. Well weighted drum slam followed by the clean guitar riff we all know. The separation of the instruments and vocals are clear and not congested or woody as I’ve heard Mr Knopffler’s vocal to sound with other cables. Next up is “Walk Of Life” with the electric organ coming to the fore and with a good lively vibe to it. Again I hear good slap on the skins and kick from the bass drum. The tick tick of the cymbals could do with being a little more forward and crisp for me, but it’s all there and it’s not offensive or harsh in any way. These C-Line cables are foot tappingly rhythmical and detailed enough to be able to distinguish all the vocals and the instruments spread out in a nice arc over and across the speakers. The following tracks on the Brothers In Arms album show this cable to be quite capable of holding its own with offerings several times its price point. Whether this is good engineering, good luck or the ARAY technology at work, the C-Line puts in a good show.

Moving from the male vocals to the female side of things and “Relish” by Joan Osbourne is slid into the CD slot. St Theresa, the first track on the album, starts with thumping bass and clanky guitar sounds, the soundstage is wide and defined, each instrument in its own space forward of the speakers slightly. Ms Osbourne’s voice central to the music, this track can trip up equipment as her voice can get quite painfully sibilant on the more powerful high notes but the C-Line holds the vocals within their grasp, not letting her get out of hand. These cables show definite control and grip on the music and on vocals especially. “One Of Us”, Joan Osbourne’s 1995 UK No.6 hit single, shows her vocals hold feeling and expression with her words hanging out in front of the speakers with good detail and weight, communicating well with the listener. I now change CDs to Duffy and “Rockferry” knowing that this album throws up several challenges. The first being on the CDs title track with the pseudo raw 60’s sound which, if let to get out of hand, can sound a bit rough and amateurish – it seems to be recorded with a lot of distortion in place. The Chord C-Line is up to the job though, not letting the music become congested or too sibilant. The tambourine is kept quite separate to the music and to the far right of the soundstage and it’s defined, crisp and clear.  “Warwick Avenue” to me has a “live” club style quality to the recording with Duffy’s tuneful singing holding nicely in the middle of the soundstage. There is enough detail within the track and this is conveyed by the Chord cables to give the atmosphere of a personal concert in an intimate club scenario.

CONCLUSION

The Chord C-Line RCA’s are a surefooted way onto the audiophile path. They are a rugged no frills cable. Holding its worth on the inside, the ARAY Technology works within the make-up of the wires and their construction. Soundwise they don’t taint the music with anything untoward and are quite transparent. Bass lines are easily followed and treble never gets unruly and is held in check. Vocals within the midrange are weighty and detailed enough to carry through the emotion of the singer. Separation within the soundstage is good. Definition of instruments to the left and right is solid and precise. Depth front to back isn’t massive but it puts in a good effort. The C-Line majors in rhythmical timing and will make your musical party bounce along and won’t become tiresome or irritating. If you’re looking to spend less than £50 on a cable, whether it’s your first foray into the upgrade path or your looking to add one to a new bit of equipment, the C-Line RCA is a thoroughly safe bet.

Build Quality: 8.2/10RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Sound Quality: 8.5/10

Value for Money: 8.9/10

Overall: 8.5

 

Chord Clearway Digital RCA 1m (£100).

This Digital version of The Chord Companies ARAY cable looks and feels like a quality item. Its flexible blue ABS outer casing feels like it would bend easily around your other kit or curl up nicely in your pocket if you were using it on the move. I like the fact that the cable is directional too as this gives consistency to your connecting up. This from Chords website describes it in detail:

“Fitted with Chord VEE 3 RCA plugs, including PTFE insulation between signal/return contacts. The ABS outer shell and direct silver-plating process improve signal transfer. The ARAY conductor design reduces interference and internal reflections. This new construction method prevents any direct compression on the signal conductor, eliminating changes to impedance. The cable also benefits from a solid core, oxygen free copper signal conductor, low loss, high performance, gas foamed polyethylene insulation, high density braided shield and ARAY conductor. The outer jacket seals and protects the signal conductor from mechanical interference. This cable is available in custom lengths and can be terminated with RCA, BNC and mini-jack connectors.”… A far better description than I could assemble!chord-clearway-digital-jack-cmyk_23059073066_os

I let the cable bed in for 48 hrs giving it time to settle. I’m not 100% sure digital cable requires this burn in process, but as the connection has never been used on my test equipment I thought it best to let it breathe awhile.

Running through steely Dan’s “Gaucho” CD I immediately feel at ease with this cable and first impressions are that it has quite a smooth sound to it. Playing “19” the track bounces along nicely and it’s a detailed and quite neutral rendition, erring on the brighter side of things… not acidic or sharp, but (reviewers’ cliché alert) like a thin veil has been lifted from the speakers. Spinning “Time Out Of Mind”, the track itself lends itself to a great intro for getting the timing just right, bass drum tripping out, easily identifiable, electric piano with pronounced weight and feeling, cymbals carrying good detail and not becoming splashy and causing vocals to lose definition.

Swapping CDs to a relative newcomer to my collection of Supertramp albums is “Some Things Never Change” which is a great recording with plenty to keep you listening. The initial track “It’s A Hard Life” starts with several sound effects to test your system, including a wobble board and chimes, then breaking into deep bass rhythms. The Digital Clearway bringing all these sounds very clearly and cleanly to the party. I note a big, wide and deep soundstage across my listening space giving each instrument plenty of room to make itself known, the trumpet towards the end of the track poking its rasp forward into the room. The other tracks on the album have a similar story. The Chord Clearway Digital is a very neutral cable with a signature of being clean and rhythmical and not colouring the music with any untoward effects. There is a slight hint of the silver construction giving a shimmering treble and tuneful deep bass.

Swapping back to a no frills digital cable for comparison makes the music sound like I’ve downgraded every component and renders the sound very amateurish and clouded. I also connected to a Pure i20 iPhone dock and apart from the obvious drop in the quality to the Mp3 files, the music remained uncoloured and as it should be.

CONCLUSION

The Chord Clearway Digital is the real deal. It seems to transfer the digital signal without fuss or colouration. This cable would be a good upgrade to a budget cable, or if you’re going down the separate DAC/headphone amp route this will make your head-fi sing for you.

Build Quality: 8.8RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Sound Quality: 8.7

Value for Money: 8.9

Overall: 8.8/10

Chord Clearway Speaker Cable 2x3m (£60 unterminated, + £40 for banana plug termination) = (£100)

Out the box, the Clearway cable is quite a thick and hefty bundle. There’s a space age look to the Clearway with a clear plastic FEP (like polythene) derived from PTFE outer, with two contra wound silver foil sheathings beneath to eliminate interference with high frequencies. The cable has been designed with a lot of emphasis upon the insulation and shielding to give a neutral presentation. The cables sent for test were terminated with two banana plugs on either end, although bare wires or spades can be specified. Things didn’t get off to a great start. The 4mm Banana plugs fitted to my test sample are a bit of a bug bear with me I’m afraid, being the type with a single sprung bar. I have found these to be quite fiddly to fit in the past and, out of the eight plugs I had to fit, three needed to be inserted with the help of a set of pliers. It didn’t help that the shrink wrap holding the banana plug was quite small around the 14 AWG wires. If the round edge of the sprung bar doesn’t go into its receptacle cleanly then it takes a good bit of pressure to insert them and nobody likes forcing things into their prized possessions. On the positive side once in then you know they are secure and to be fair it’s not a connection that you have to connect or reconnect very often.

Chord recommended letting these burn in for about 24hrs but I felt that a little longer was required and I played these for about a week or so before I was happy that the sound had levelled out.

First up is Ben Howard’s “Every Kingdom” CD. “Old Pine” starts with some nicely played acoustic guitar and the strings are clear and well weighted, with good detail and feel. The sound is powerful and room filling and there is a warmer tone to the music that gives it an easy-on-the-ear feel. On “Wolves” the initial haunting vocal demonstrates good sound-depth and clarity and the snare drum raps out with a clear crisp sound that is never harsh or too hard. Onto a faster paced track “The Fear” the bass drum again has good thump and I notice a slight rounding off to bass notes resulting in loss of a little detail. There is a similar effect at the top of the spectrum too and the rounding off of the treble sound is pushing the warmth outward. However it’s not overly obvious as the midrange has feel and detail. These cables, like the others from Chord, have great timing and rhythm. Julia Fordham’s self-titled album is popped in to see how the bass would affect a deeper female singing voice and I’m glad to say it remains sweet on tracks like “My Lovers Keeper” and “Cocooned”  with the vocals never becoming overly warm or reverberantly dull. The soundstage is a wide and expressive place, giving good atmosphere to all the recordings played and instruments are well placed. “Woman Of The 80’s” bounces along with true pop verve, never getting harsh or muddled when things get complicated.

Heading for some 70’s rock and Boston’s self-titled outing, the classic “More Than A Feeling” hits out with concert like punch! Driving  drums and percussion, cymbals crisp and not too splashy, the classic vocals coming across with power and feeling. Considering the age of the recording it still has great detail. My favourite track from the album is “Foreplay/LongTime”, a track of two halves with a pseudo prog-rock instrumental start and electronic organ and piano with heavy crashing drums. The Clearway speaker cable is doing its best trying to keep it all together, only letting the fast, loud drumming get a little muddled and confused, but at the rate the skins and cymbals are getting struck it’s not surprising it lets slip a little. Part two of the track is more 70’s classic rock with a bounding bass rhythm leading the proceedings and with Brad Delp’s singing taking the lyrics to the fans. Soundstage with the Clearway has good width and depth with a nothing seeming out of place or un-natural.

CONCLUSION

This is a decent enough speaker cable from The Chord Company. It’s sturdily built with the ARAY technology from its more expensive range added. My only gripe in its construction is the type of banana plugs used and the added cost of termination seems excessive given its moderate price unterminated. The sound of the cable is on the warm, rounded side and it can lose a little focus and detail when things get complicated and so may not appeal to the heavy rock fans out there.

Build Quality: 8.5 (ignoring the plugs I don’t like)RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Sound Quality: 8.0

Value For Money: 7.8 (as tested, terminated. Cost of termination seems disproportionate to cable cost)

Overall: 8.1

 

The Chord Company “Loom” Inc C-stream Streaming Cable

Adding the full selection of Chord Company cables to my system brought about the benefits of all the cables added together. Using all the cables ARAY technology in one hit gave the music great drive and verve.

Music from Jess Glynne’s I Cry When I Laugh CD allowed the music to sing out with good timing and foot tapping rhythms, the warmer presentation doing wonders to smooth off the usual modern hardness I hear with many digital recordings. “Take Me Home” has great space around her fine vocal talents with instruments staying in the background, letting her voice project forward and giving the music an “alive” feeling. “Hold My Hand” pumps out with true disco diva bounce and funk – a powerful presentation, without becoming yobbish with the ARAY influence working together to bring about its benefits in timing and drive.

The C-Stream (10m) streaming cable was a bit of a conundrum for me to test properly. As I’m a bit outmoded when it comes to technology I don’t “stream” as such. So best I could do was attach the C-Stream to my modem and Sony Blu-Ray player and connect it to my digital pre-amp via the Chord Digital coax. Playing various music videos and concerts via the  Amazon Prime Service, the connection stayed stable and music had a good level of detail, picture quality via TV was good, colours rich and deep as was the music. Although I’m sure this Ethernet cable would really show its worth via a better dedicated streamer and using a high quality feed from the likes of Tidal/Spotify/Deezer etc… I must add one of these weird futuristic devices to my Christmas list next time round!!

CONCLUSION

The Chord Company cables supplied are of good quality in their construction and build technology. The Phono RCA and Digital interconnects are possibly of a greater sonic quality than the Clearway speaker cable, although only for the fact that I believe both the RCA and Digital cable will suit more systems given their neutrality and I believe they would shine brighter with the next step up in speaker cables offered by Chord.

Overall. 8.2/10RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

David Robson

chordco-ad-hifipig-connect-with-us-(2)

Designer’s Notes

C-line RCA (1M) (ARAY)

The Chord C-line was developed to see if we could use an ARAY conductor configuration in an affordable interconnect.  The ARAY conductor configuration was developed around the same time that we were working on the Tuned ARAY configuration that we originally used on our – at the time – flagship Sarum interconnects.  Traditionally, most Chord interconnects adopted a pseudo-balanced design.  This means that rather than using a coaxial cable where the central conductor carries the signal and the return is made by the outer shield, the pseudo-balanced design uses two identical conductors – one for signal and one for return.  By doing this, we are able to take the shield out of the signal path and currently our Crimson VEE 3 and Cobra VEE 3 cables use this configuration.

The ARAY conductor configuration is different.  There are three conductor runs within the cable and quite how these are connected remains a company secret.  The reason for doing this is that during the development of the Tuned ARAY cables, we were quite astonished at just how coherent and musically involving digital music could be made to sound.  The ARAY version has a similar effect.  The big discovery with Tuned ARAY was really just how much cables got in the way of a system to produce properly coherent music.

The C-line is also the first analogue interconnect that Chord have had produced outside of the company.  Although the RCA plug is a moulded design, the gold-plated components are the same as the ones we use on our VEE 3 series plugs.  This means a direct gold-plating process.  Conductors are oxygen free copper and multi-stranded.  Shielding comprises of two over-wound foil braids.

Clearway Digital RCA 1m 

The Clearway Digital cable is another good example of how designs originally created for our high end cables can be used in more cost effective designs.  The Chord Prodac has been our go-to affordable digital cable for many years.  It was, like many digital cables, a coaxial design.  The Tuned ARAY conductor configuration was first developed as an attempt to reduce reflections and minimise noise within digital cables.  It was the success of the Tuned ARAY configuration that made us take the design principle and apply it to both analogue and other digital cables as well as power cables.  Once again, it’s about coherence.

The Chord Clearway Digital is our entry level digital cable to use the Tuned ARAY configuration.  The design of the cable is outwardly relatively conventional.  Internally there is a high quality oxygen free copper conductor coaxial cable, featuring gas foamed polyethylene insulation as well as a combination foil and braid shield.  What sets it apart is the introduction of a Tuned ARAY conductor.  What it does mean though is that like all Tuned ARAY cables, the Clearway Digital has to be assembled by hand and because the application of Tuned ARAY is absolutely critical, we use specialist cutting machines to provide a consistent accuracy.

We think that the Tuned ARAY configuration is extremely profound because of the level of performance, particularly in a musical sense, which it brings to digital systems.

Clearway Speaker Cable 

Chord have been producing shielded speaker cables since 2003.  The reason for doing so goes back to the late 90s.  Back then, several things were happening.  First of all, switch mode power supplies were beginning to appear.  More and more homes were beginning to use personal computers and also connection to the internet was rapidly increasing.  This meant that homes and living spaces were beginning to fill with high frequency interference.  A combination of personal experiences and conversations with dealers led to the realisation that high frequency interference appeared to be having a detrimental effect on the ability of systems to produce really coherent and involving music.  What was particularly frightening about this was that whilst you can make a good argument that CD players of that time didn’t do very well with producing coherent music, vinyl systems were also suffering.

The first response to this was to start experimenting with high frequency effective shields and the first cable to be produced using high frequency effective shielding was the Chord Signature.  At that point though, it felt like we should start experimenting with shielding on speaker cables.  Several early prototypes were produced and eventually we released the Chord Signature speaker cable – our first speaker cable to feature high frequency shielding.

The challenge then was to take the principle and apply it to other speaker cables throughout the range.  The Chord Clearway is a replacement for the Chord Carnival SilverScreen.  Carnival SilverScreen was a very successful cable and Chord Clearway is a fairly similar design.  The chief differences are that Clearway features a heavier gauge stranded conductor (oxygen free copper) and critically, FEP conductor insulation.  The choice of conductor insulation has a profound effect on the performance of any cable; perhaps more markedly so with speaker cable than with interconnects.

FEP is a variation on PTFE.  It has extremely similar performance characteristics.  Our experience is that the choice of insulation material doesn’t just influence the ability of the cable to carry a signal accurately; it also has a pronounced effect on the tonal characteristic of the cable.  In truth, I suspect every cable designer sets out to produce a cable with as little tonal characteristic as possible.  However, the fact is that most cable designs do have some influence on the tonal characteristics of the speakers it is connected to.

There is an interesting point here.  When people change speaker cables, they often make judgements with a speaker in the position that had been optimised for the speaker cable they were using.  It is always worthwhile to experiment with the positioning of a speaker when a new speaker cable is introduced.  It is very unlikely that the speaker will need to be moved more than a couple of inches in either direction but experimenting with this will help to produce the most coherent performance.

The two FEP insulated conductors are then encased in a PVC jacket – the idea being to reduce the effect of mechanical noise – before a two-layer foil shield is added and finally a protective outer jacket.

It’s often very easy to be pleased and excited about high end, high performance cables.  The really exciting thing though is to take the design principles used on high end cables and work out how to apply them to more cost effective cables where material choices are constrained by cost.  This we feel is what makes Clearway so special.

Nigel Finn

 

 

 

Share

Russell K Red 100 Loudspeakers

$
0
0

Russell Kauffman’s Russell K company make just two models of loudspeaker. Here Dominic Marsh and Janine Elliot take a listen to the bigger Red 100 standmounters costing £1784 in the piano gloss finish and with grilles, though less pricey options are available. 

As a reviewer for Hifi Pig Magazine you mostly get assigned what you are going to review by our editor Stuart.  But, every once in a while either he asks if we have any components we have on our ‘hit list’ we would like to review and this particular review is the result of one of those instances.

I first set eyes upon Russell K speakers during a dealer visit to Bob Hesketh at Tavistock Audio in the early part of this year.  As always, I only spotted them as I was about to leave and the looks alone intrigued me to say the least, but there wasn’t the time available then to hook them up and have a quick listen.   It wasn’t the piano gloss black cabinetry or the bright red baffles and grey cabinets that drew me towards them, it was the name “Russell K” screen printed on the tweeter surround that said to me if someone puts their own name to a product in that way, there was a real driving passion behind it for doing so.  Brave man.RK2s

Russell who?  He has worked as a speaker designer for some famous names in the industry for a good number of years, the last being Morel, so although you may not recognize the name, he has probably been the brains behind a goodly number of class act speakers.  It has always puzzled me why the large corporations harbour a massive wealth of talent under their roofs, yet manage to frustrate them so much they end up leaving and flexing their wings and being highly successful in their own right.  Russell left Morel because him being based in the UK and Morel headquartered in Israel wasn’t conducive to a fruitful working environment. Their loss is our gain it seems.

One of the (few!) upsides of a reviewer’s  job is you get to meet the people behind the brands and the overwhelming majority are nice friendly people with the same lunatic passions as the consumers of their products possess, so they mostly understand what we in the audiophile fraternity actually seek from the products we might buy from them.

Due to a busy schedule however,  I had to put a follow up call on the back burner for a while and when I did at last have to the time to make further enquiries, Russell Kauffman was not easy to get hold of with his busy schedule either.  Such is life.  Anyway, at long last I managed to get hold of Russell and ask very nicely if he would consider a Hifi Pig review of his speakers, to which he readily agreed and here below is the result.

CONSTRUCTION

According to Russell K’s website, either side above and below each bass unit is a bracing shelf containing multiple apertures with the reflex port located under the bottom shelf. The midrange energy from the rear of the bass/mid unit is contained within the two shelves which mean only bass escapes into the full volume of the enclosure. The result is a drastic reduction of midrange standing waves and almost no midrange energy making its way out of the port tube. The very low port tuning frequency of 35Hz on the Red 100 produces a bass that is extraordinarily tight and very well extended.

Another feature of the design is the complete lack of damping material in the cabinet, either in the form of bituminous panels or long haired wool or fibre type material.  Russell Kauffman says this gives rise to sloppy bass characteristics so has completely eliminated it from his designs, by using those braces and baffles to effect the necessary damping of the bass/mid drive unit.

The crossover circuitry too plays an important part in a loudspeaker’s sound characteristics, so the design brief was to keep it simple and is centered around a 12db per octave slope crossing over at 2.2KHz with only one inductance coil for the bass driver and just one capacitor feeding the tweeter, also maintaining a benign load for the driving amplifier, even low powered single ended valve amplifiers I am told.   Nominal impedance is 8 Ohms.  Connections are made via a single pair of good quality 4mm binding posts that will accept bare wire, spades or banana plugs, with no bi-wire or bi-amping facility.Red 100 Crossover

Driver complement consists of a 165mm doped paper bass driver and a 25mm soft dome tweeter in vertical alignment to the centre of the baffle, along with the reflex port near the bottom edge.  I haven’t tried this myself, but Russell assures me that if someone pokes the tweeter cone in it will pop out of it’s own accord some time later.  I will take his word for that.  However, if you have some little persons in your household with inquisitive fingers that have the propensity to explore button-like protuberances on speaker drivers, then grilles are available to protect them from the aforesaid mischievous digits.

The grilles are an extra cost option at £84.00 a pair you will note, as the standard speaker is supplied without any grilles at all.  The grilles themselves are made from a perforated metal sheet with a metal insert in each corner to hold 4 individual magnets which for their size are quite powerful.  Embedded into the front baffle during construction are 4 equally powerful magnets which line up with the grille and are hidden from view due to the baffle’s final surface finish.  I am pleased to say that the magnets are strong enough to hold the heavy grilles in place, yet not so strong as to make removing the grilles a grappling match either.

Cabinet dimensions are  40cm high, by 26cm wide, by 27cm deep, making it slightly squat and boxy in appearance.  The buyer has a choice of finishes to choose from, ranging from a red baffle with a plastic type of grey vinyl material to the rest of the cabinet as the base model, to a satin black baffle with either real veneered Oak, Walnut, or Mahogany finishes, or the full monty piano gloss black or piano gloss white  finish on all sides including the baffle.

The pair submitted for review were finished in a piano gloss black finish.

Prices at time of testing are:

Red baffle, grey cabinet:£1,250.00 inc VAT

Satin black baffle, wood finish:£1,475.00 inc VAT

Piano gloss white or black:£1,700.00 inc VAT

Front grilles (Pair):£84.00  inc VAT

The price differential between the basic grey and red variant compared to the full piano gloss version raised some concerns with me, given that the cost of the piano gloss finish represented a good percentage of the speaker’s base cost to begin with.  Russell said it was a high price due to the fact that the piano gloss finish is hand prepared with rubbing and sanding down between the base paint coats and the final lacquer coats which is of course is highly labour intensive work and the additional cost is reflected in that.

I am informed that a dedicated stand is being designed for the 100s and will be completed in due course. In the absence of same, I tried them on 50cm stands which were too low and a 60cm pair brought the speakers up the correct height for me.  Russell said they were a bit finicky with what stands they are paired with and I am not aware if my Partington Ansa stands were on his approved stands list but they sounded fine to me.

SOUND QUALITY

With a build specification like that, you might expect a sound that was well off the beaten path and you would be right to think that.  While the overwhelming majority of the speakers out there are designed with a whole series of compromises (Including aesthetics and cost), the Russell K 100’s are not that way inclined, as the designer has reportedly spent an inordinate amount of time, effort and no doubt money too, in refining the design to have as few if any of those compromises that others are plagued with.  Russell Kauffman has put his very being into the design and every single aspect of them has been paid meticulous attention to and the sonic rewards to you the listener are immense.

The greatest triumph of the design for me has been the bass performance and while I am not an advocate of bass reflex designs as a whole with their chuffing ports and woolly bass output, much preferring the solid weight and control of an infinite baffle design, the Russell K 100s sports the very same reflex port I am wary of and have quickly come to the conclusion after hearing these speakers, is that the reflex port per se isn’t to blame, it is the poor implementation of the reflex port principle that is the real bogeyman.  A large hole drilled into the baffle or back plate and some cheap plastic tube shoved in there, do not a reflex port make and these speakers demonstrate that rather concisely.

Russell Kauffman claims the port is tuned to 35Hz and I would be the last to dispute that figure, but what I can tell you is this speaker goes LOW folks for a mere stand mounted speaker and in complete control too I might add.  No boom, no overhang, no wooliness at all, that leading edge is good enough to shave stubble off your chin, it is that keen and in truth puts many a large floor standing model to shame for good measure.  There is a slight raising of upper bass energy which the designer is aware of and I think the sound benefits from that by adding a touch or warmth to the midrange which otherwise would be on the cool side.

The word “articulate” is much bandied about by reviewers to describe bass that they hear and I often think to myself is that word used as a true description of what is being heard, or just another euphemism or plucked from the ether kind of word slotted in when the description memory bank starts running aground?   The bass output of the RK 100’s is articulate in every sense of the word, inasmuch as it’s as real a standing next to the bass guitarist, drummer, cellist, flautist, whatever and hearing every single timbre and harmonic from those instruments deep into the bass registers.  Let’s not completely ignore the tweeter’s role in this scenario either as it’s no shrinking violet by any means, as it’s not merely a supporting act for the bass driver, oh no, this driver is crisp and clean, insightful without being explicit.  The pair are very well matched to the crossover, giving a refreshing cleanliness to the midrange and I couldn’t hear any bloom or fogging in that area of the audible spectrum.

Onto some music then and hoping that you own or have listened to my often played favourite album for putting a system through its paces.   If you don’t own or have not heard it, then I suggest obtaining a copy of Fink’s “Wheels Turn Beneath My Feet” live album so you can relate to what I am referring to in my reviews.  Fink’s artistic talents may not ring your bells (it didn’t mine at first) but it has certain elements in the recording that makes faults shine like a beacon, a joy when reproduced accurately.  Tidal has a higher resolution than Spotify, which while acceptable doesn’t have the same resolving power as the original CD or high resolution downloads for a listen to this album.  Dan Worth also uses this album for the same reason.

Track one begins with “Biscuits For Breakfast” with some crisp cymbal strikes to the centre of the Ride Cymbal from the drummer that has resonances and ringing within the cymbal strikes and it takes a great tweeter to capture that essence, which the Russell K’s do admirably and run a very close second to some ribbon tweeters I have heard.  Bass guitar has a taut deep growl to it and goes very low while at the same time it captures the fret finger movements from the guitarist with uncanny realism.

This album as I have probably mentioned a good few times in my reviews, has each track recorded at different venues and it takes a very competent speaker to let you the listener know that they have been, with reverberation and ambience cues ranging from intimate to large scale.  On one track the microphone is slightly misbehaving too and the Russell K’s let you know that is occurring as well, whereas it slips under the radar with most other speakers.

When we come to the track called “Sort Of Revolution” the drummer drives down hard on to the Floor Tom and by golly it generally makes my listening room almost expand and contract with the power and energy released.  The Russell K’s though do it rather differently, by exposing every part of that strike into separate compartments, as in you can hear and almost feel the drum stick hitting the drum’s ‘skin’, the body of the drum reacting to that and begins vibrating with an almost aural picture in the air of the drum itself and yes the energy is still there, but taut and very controlled, down to the decay.   At first it was rather disconcerting, having become accustomed to a single powerful burst of energy emanating from the speakers, but since hearing what I have done from the Russell K’s it has set a brand new benchmark for me that other speakers which follow for review will have to strive towards.   This track has a visceral pounding rhythm to it and is a good test of both timing cues and separation between instruments, so while the drummer is maintaining a steady beat on the Kick Drum, the bass guitarist is mirroring that pace and the audience is clapping along.  If this doesn’t lift you up and enervate you into enjoying the music you are in need of help.Terminals

Of course being an album recorded live, I will pay particular attention to how the audience sounds.  Any speaker that makes the audience clapping sound like bacon sizzling in a frying pan or a thousand crisp (potato chips) bags being rustled is a complete no-no as far as I am concerned.   I need to be made to feel as if I am surrounded by cheering enthusiastic people, catcalling and whistling as individuals I can place in locations around me (well, as far as a stereo image will let me perceive anyway).

As a contrast to that, some electronic music in the shape of Tripswitch’s excellent album “Geometry”.  There is some superb layering in this album and it takes a sure footed pair of speakers to unfold and pull back all the layers so each strand is separated and clear.  The bass lines are really deep, subtle in places too and can easily be muddled by the music around it.  The Russell K’s certainly did untangle and strand out all of the music and the bass was separated out almost into a compartment on it’s own, untroubled by whatever else was going on around it.

Naturally, I played a large range of music genres and the Russell K Red 100’s acquitted themselves very well.  My final test though was Porcupine Tree’s “Deadwing” album and that will either sound dreadful with it’s raw uncouth recording, or acceptable, with little middle ground in between.   The opening title track has the sounds of a train pulling into a station with plenty of brake squealing sounds and it’s electric motor humming away in the background while the passengers alight.  The Russell K’s certainly picked up these sounds with great clarity and as is the norm with good sounding systems it fair set my teeth on edge.  Now if the sound was smooth and rounded then I would have been concerned.  Further into that same track there is a bass guitar riff with a long low note that shouldn’t just ‘emerge’ as a grumble from the speakers, it has to flow and roll out seemingly low down near the floor to be credible.  I got that full effect from the Russell K’s and to my surprise I could almost count the bass guitar’s string vibrations.  Spooky.

If you are the kind of listener who revels in the sound of female vocals then these speakers will delight.  Haven’t heard Loreena McKennit sounding better and Dido’s “Life For Rent” album took on some new dimensions that convinced me I should listen to it more often from now on as I had mostly dismissed it as being a typical commercial pop recording.  Not so.

CONCLUSION

When I first laid eyes on the Russell K Red 100’s there was a gut instinct feeling that they were “right”somehow.  Don’t ask me to explain why because I can’t, I just sensed it.  I hadn’t even heard of them before, nor of Russell Kauffman the designer for that matter, even less heard them fired up in action to make some sort of value judgment call and they weren’t even red, but in a piano black finish.  Certainly wasn’t their looks as they are to me a short wide box rather than a slim elegant  design that fits neatly into contemporary homes, nor was it a heady mix of exposed exotic drivers in the cabinet to get my juices flowing either.  Maybe it was the screen printed name in white on the tweeter of the man himself and I could easily go nuts here trying to figure it out where this gut feeling sprang from.  It was that gut feeling that drove me on to get in touch with Russell Kauffman to arrange a review pair and am so glad that I persisted because it has been very worthwhile.

These speakers may just change your perceptions about stand mounted speakers as it has changed mine.  Reaching  down to the bass regions where many a floor stander cannot get to is a revelation in itself, making that bass so controlled and so articulate is breathtaking and a tribute to the designer.  Great bass is one thing, matching that to an equally impressive well performing treble and midrange says these speakers are no one trick pony and a lot of thought and expertise has gone into their creation.

I had visions of clinging on to my resident speakers until my final breath and while there has been a procession of speakers through my hands for review, none have tempted me to change until the Russell K’s came along.  I have ordered a pair for myself and if that isn’t putting your money where your mouth is, then I don’t know what is and how much better a recommendation would you possibly want from me?

As ever don’t just take my word for it, arrange an audition to gauge suitability for your tastes, preferences and system synergy which will always be the ultimate arbiter.  But I do implore you to at least have a serious listen to them, as they may just raise the bar for you too.

Build quality: 8.6/10RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Sound quality: 9.3/10

Value for money: 9/10

Overall: 8.96/10 

Pros:                            

Exceptional sound quality and fine build in an affordable package.  Few rivals within this particular price band or indeed even higher for the base model red and grey cabinet variant. 

Cons:        

£84.00 for a pair of grilles. Ouch!

Dominic Marsh

I’d spoken to Stu about these loudspeakers and he mentioned that Dominic had really enjoyed them and so, intrigued, I wanted to hear them for myself.  That was all I knew, and in the light of honest reviewing I didn’t want to know anything about earlier reviews on the speakers before I listened, and won’t until this review goes live. I met up with Russell Kaufmann at his Dunstable factory to listen to the speakers there and then later in my own listening environment with my cat Toby. The speakers are tradition box-shaped 2way with front port, with 4 distinctive indented horizontal lines on the baffle, which I liked.  The cheapest version has a red front, which you can cover up with a grille, available as an accessory, though why you would want to I don’t know. All versions looked great. The review sample was shiny piano-black, beautifully built and the more expensive.rk3s

Russell was very open about his designing which helped me to understand the sound I heard and what he was trying to do. This model lies between the 50 bookshelf and 150 two-and-a-half-way floorstander.  The sound was certainly very unique and interesting. I did notice a ‘micro’-spike at around 800Hz, something he later told me only one other reviewer had ever noticed, and in fact it was 830Hz. It wouldn’t be noticeable to almost everybody, only that my hearing is exceptionally good and I have perfect pitch, so I could hear something between a G and G#. This didn’t cause any problem to music or speech, if anything helped give it its distinctive and pleasurable sound. The set-up in the “factory” wasn’t ideal, so I was glad to take it back to my house, which I have set up so there are no reflecting walls. Indeed like B11 in the Basement of Old Broadcasting House back in my days at the Beeb, where sounds were not absorbed in the walls but reflected out of the way of the listening area, my living room is set up so that some sounds are absorbed and others reflected away from the listening area. Similarly Russell uses a horizontal wooden floor above and below the woofer with holes to control and direct sounds both up to tweeter and down to the port chamber so sounds don’t need to be damped in the traditional manner of box loudspeakers. Indeed there is no internal damping, though the wood used is thick unlike old box-builds of the 60s. They were supplied to me on his own designed stand of thick metal base and solid wood sides, which worked very well.

The sound was certainly good with classical music, giving a very good controlled and polite musical rendition of The 4 Seasons, Vivaldi (Allegro (Spring; Takako Nishizaki), had the strings and harpsichord well placed and everything where I would expect it in the orchestra. Kate Bush Aerial ‘An Endless Sky of Honey’ was powerful and well composed in the bass end; indeed, the bass was the really special thing about these speakers. The bass was not woolly or uncontrolled as in a number of speakers 2 to 3 times the price. Tops were clear with an extended decay time in the end of phrases. ‘Fields of Gold’, Eva Cassidy wasn’t quite so accurate. The OTT reverb on her voice with its HF lift wasn’t so obvious or clear. Similarly the acoustic guitar wasn’t so easy to place in the soundstage and in fact sounded almost as if there was a phase issue. The guitar in John Lee Hooker Deep Blue Sea, similarly didn’t position the guitar pin sharp in front of me, as my speakers-of-choice do. The speed of the heavy microphone breath at 2’ was certainly clear, though, as was the punchy close mic’ing in ‘Besame Mucho’ (Puschnig and Sarrock). Of course this is where things get delicate; a 12dB/second order/ crossover design suggests usually the tweeters should be phase reversed, but often designers don’t bother as they adjust the crossover components to get the sound just right. This is what Russell has done, using his ears to get the measurements ‘just right’ for him. The 4+4 element bass/tweeter crossover design is typical 2 octave design apart from not doing the reversed -/+ tweeter polarity. Whilst this gave an exciting and attractive sound, understandably attractive, as a boring studio manager used to balancing music in front of a massive desk with speakers reasonably apart, this just sounded not right for me. However, its ability to make Jeff Lynne’s ELO’s latest offering ‘Alone in the Universe’ sound worth the outlay is a powerful selling point.   The bass, right down to the lowest lows, put my £5000 stand-mount monitors to shame, but that tweeter just didn’t do it for me. What was very good, however, was the way the two drivers worked so well together as a single point-source, rather than sounding like two separate drivers in a box.

CONCLUSION

I might sound overtly critical but I really did want to understand these speakers, as I felt they were my friend. They might not have been the red ones but the sound was very human and personal and I was the one who was blushing. For the price, designed in the UK by a gentleman of many years’ experience in audio design and sales and sourced in Poland, this is an excellent speaker and I really want to listen to more from the company. At under £2000 this is a very attractive proposition.

Sound Quality: 8.5/10RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Value for Money: 8.7/10

Build Quality: 8.8/10

Overall: 8.67/10

Janine Elliot

Designer’s Notes 

The design goal on the Red 100 was to make a loudspeaker that sounds as close as we could get to the real thing at an affordable price.  As a new company with Red 100 being the first product, it was essential to bring some original thinking to the party in order that the speaker would not be instantly dismissed. As a starting point we decided to cut everything from the design that was not critical to the sound. Some examples of this thinking being; the grille is an extra cost option; many customers will take the grille off and never use it, but have paid for it in the complete speaker. A Russell K customer is given the choice. The packaging for transport is simple but safe and there are no brochures. The more controversial cuts include the decision not to use famous brands for drive units, but well made, good sounding drivers adapted for Russell K, and the now familiar ribbed plastic coated grey cabinet with a Ferrari red front baffle. This finish option saves the customer a lot money with no loss of sound quality.

Starting with drive units, the first test is to connect a woofer, or for that matter a tweeter, directly to the amp with no crossover or cabinet and just listen. If the sound is bad then no crossover will really help, and it is amazing how different, and sometimes bad, even the best tweeters can sound. In the case of the Red 100 tweeter it sounds smooth and can even play a bass tune – in fact it sounds like a small speaker.

The woofer size came next and we went for a nominal 6 inch unit. We feel this  has the best compromise between efficiency, power handling, bass extension, clarity and dispersion. Next we did a bit of maths to find the optimum volume (size) for the cabinet and found it really was most comfortable being a stand mount rather than a compromised floorstanding enclosure.

There are many different ways to design a speaker and I don’t claim to have the only correct way. In many respects I try to work to my strengths and avoid going into areas that I am not so secure about. This is a roundabout way of me saying that measurements and theory are always going to be the slave of what I hear. I do believe a speaker should have a relatively flat measured response, but I will not allow the sound to suffer to get it. This sets me free to bend some of the rules such as no internal damping in the cabinet, no resistors in the signal path, and not using textbook values for the crossover components.

The design studio allows me to measure and listen without having to move the speakers or disconnect them from the Hi Fi system. This means I can listen, make an adjustment, measure and then listen again allowing me to control the process of voicing the speaker. I use a lot of different music with no particular test tracks, along with spoken word. I also check and recheck many times to be sure I didn’t fool myself into thinking I have made the best speaker in the world.

The final product is designed to work with both transistor and valve amps, and whilst it does not have a Hi-End price, it should be set up with the same care and attention. For sure I treated this speaker with the same respect during development that I lavished on a £25,000.00 loudspeaker designed for a company I was a consultant for.

Russell Kauffman 

Read More Loudspeaker Reviews 

 

Share

Arcam FMJ CDS 27 and FMJ A19 Integrated Amplifier

$
0
0

A full size integrated amplifier with phonostage, plus a CD player that is also a streamer for just shy of £1200 seems like a good deal. Stuart Smith investigates. 

FMJ CDS 27 

The CDS27 is a bit of a swiss army knife of a player and will get your tunes from SACDs, normal Red Book CDs as well as from your network, in our case NAS and Melco units connected to a straightforward and unmodified home network. Handily the CDS27 is UPnP compatible as well as CIFS…I’ll be using UPnP because that is what I know.Arcam_FMJCDS27_review_a

Inside the player you have a DAC in the form of the TI/Burr Brown PCM1794 and this is coupled with a linear phase Bessel output filter and reclocking system. Power supplies for the drive, audio and DAC boards are all discreet and “sub-regulated”. The DAC will handle files up to 24-bit 192kHz.

On the front of the unit you’ve got a pretty workaday look to the player and I actually quite like this as it harks back to the glory days of the mid 80’s when hifi looked like…well it looked like hifi really. There are no pretentions with the looks of the CDS27 and as soon as you see it you know what it is and what it is made to do. You’ve got four nicely functioning push buttons that control the CD player’s transport, an on off button, the CD drawer and a large LCD screen so you can see what is playing and where from. You can also mess with all the settings via the remote and screen too. All pretty normal and standard stuff, but all nicely done.
Round the back you have balanced audio outputs as well as the more standard RCAs and coaxial and optical outputs for digital signals allowing you to connect to an external DAC should you feel the need. Inputs provided are a remote in (didn’t try) and an RS232 (didn’t try), a network connection to connect by wire to your home network and a USB input which allows you to access files stored on a directly connected hard drive. The upper limits of media supported by the USB input are FLAC (24/192), WAV (24/192), AAC (24/96), AIFF (24/192), OGG (24/192), MP3 (320/48) and WMA (192/48) so you are well covered whatever your files…unless of course you are wanting to play DSD which, given what I feel is the target market for this unit is sensible. Also on the back cover is the aerial input to connect wirelessly to your network.. the aerial comes packed with the comprehensive and well written/illustrated owner’s manual.Arcam_FMJCDS27_review_b

The remote that comes as standard is a pretty normal looking affair with all the functions needed being available.

FMJ A19 Integrated Amplifier

The A19 is a perfect visual match for the CDS27 measuring the same 423 x 275 x 85 cm (WDH) and comes in matching black. Again, nothing to get the bling merchants hot under the collar, but nice and functionally pleasing to look at none-the-less. Claimed output power into 8 Ohms is 50W and into 4 Ohms 90 W with a quoted distortion at 80% power (8 Ohms 1kHz) of 0.003%.

Inside the A19 Arcam say there has been a focus on the power section of the amp and (I wondered what the two weird little cables in the pack were for) you can power up to two of Arcam’s r-Series products from the amp. Now I didn’t really get the point of this a first but it’s actually a pretty neat solution allowing you to add the rBlink, airDAC, irDAC or rPAC to your set up without having to fanny about with having extra wall sockets available to power them…good thinking I reckon.

Also good to see on the unit is a MM phonostage that will allow you to listen to vinyl. Sensible also they went for the MM option as I reckon the target market for this amp will be the kind of folk that will want a no nonsense kind of deck like Pro-Ject’s low and medium priced offerings that come installed with good MM cartridges. There’s also a headphone amp included, with the output socket being the mini-jack type…I’d have preferred a standard quarter inch jack here, but again this may be clever thinking given what I reckon will be the people who shell out for one of these…more of that in a mo’.Arcam_fmjA19_amp_c

On the front of the amp you’ve got eight source selector buttons, a power on off, a large infinitely turning volume knob, a self explanatory mute button, a balance button allowing you to set the output from each speaker and a button to control the brightness of the display. You’ve then got left just the minijack for the headphone amp and a minijack input so you can connect your MP3 player or mobile phone.
Round the back you’ve got 8 line level inputs which should be enough to satisfy pretty much everyone out there, plus the phono in and ground, the 3.5mm socket for the accessory power I mentioned earlier, a voltage select switch so you can choose between 120V and 240V and a pair of speaker terminals that will accept spades, bananas or bare wires.  You also get a record out (stereo RCAs) to attach to a tape player or whatever the modern equivalent is and a pre out so you can bi-amp should the fancy take you.Arcam_fmjA19_amp_b

WHAT’S THE MARKET FOR THESE?

You see not all people who want to enjoy music in the home want to have myriad boxes and wires all over the show that mess up their harmonious family lifestyle, and I reckon this is who Arcam are squarely aiming this pair of products at. The boxes look like hifi everyone will recognise and whilst they are standard width, they are pretty low profile and look nice stacked on top of each other and placed on a cabinet or AV unit…most people buying these will not want, or need to have dedicated racks and what not and will stack them. The headphone output on the amp is a mini-Jack of course, but look at the headphones most people who are not certified audio nut-jobs (I include myself in this latter social grouping) will be carrying about with them on a daily basis…the ones they will use to listen to their iPhone or whatever and these will invariably have a mini jack. And whilst we’re talking about smartphones, the inclusion of the aux input on the amps front panel allows folk to easily and simply get tunes off their players and into their main living space, so that when the teens of the house come home and treat the place like a hotel, they can simply plug in and delight their parents with the best of what the 21st Century has to offer. And then there’s the MM only phono input I’ve already mentioned that allows folk to listen to vinyl on relatively budget decks that are readily available and without faffing about with separate phonostages. Then you’ve got all the connections on the amp, some of which I have no idea what the acronyms for mean, but will be self evident to most members of the human race that were born after 1970, don’t obsess about their hifi and want a box that integrates into their entertainment system and life. You have: AV so you can connect your telly or VCR, PVR (new one on me) intended for connecting your “Personal Video Recorder”, BD for your DVD or Blu-ray player, SAT for your satellite box, Tuner for radio, CD for attaching the CDS27 (or other CD player). Finally you’ve got that nifty pair of power supplies for the r-series stuff meaning you can add an r-Blink (or other r-Series kit) and stream tunes off your phone via blu-tooth.

On the CDS27 you have the normal array of stuff you’d find on a normal CD player, but then you’ve got the advantage of being able to stream your tunes wirelessly or via wire from your NAS.
It’s an increasingly connected world out there and this is a connected set of kit, and whilst the partnering offered up here may well be scoffed at by some of the audio snobs in hifi-land, I reckon that Arcam know what they are doing, have been smart in the features they have included and have pretty much nailed it as far as offering units that are simple, elegant and useable by more members of the household than just the audiophile patriarch/matriarch. I like this approach! It is inclusive and democratic.

SET UP

I was initially a bit disappointed to find that Arcam’s UPnP app (Music Life) was iOS only and I think this is a mistake on their part given what I have said about who I think is the target market and the inclusive nature of the products on test. I would have loved to have seen this available as an Android app and whilst I am aware that a significant proportion of the population use iOS, there is an equally significant number who don’t. I do hope Arcam will address this in the very near future!

Wiring up the pairing is the usual affair for all the basic stuff and the pair power up with an attractive (I really like this) green hue to the displays. Remote is intuitive for basic functions and works well at distance, though the display isn’t great for looking at from a distance when streaming.

Connecting to the network was a doddle using the remote (the only option) and involved no more than clicking the remote to Network Setup, scanning for available networks (it found our home network immediately) and then pressing OK to connect. You then find the media you want to play from (NAS drive and Melco) and then load the library of tunes to the machine. All good, quick and very simple…we like simple! Next up was to update the firmware which again was a simple affair of scrolling through the on screen options with the remote and pressing OK. A couple of minutes and the CDS27 is all updated and ready to roll.

Now you can of course scroll through the albums and artists you have on your NAS using the remote and the screen on the CDS27 (not great), but it is more likely that the vast majority of people will choose to use a suitable app and I used BubbleUPnP to control the tunes I wanted streaming. Setting this up was fuss free too with the app seeing The Arcam “renderer” immediately. The CDS27 reacts with a slight delay when there’s a change in tune or album which was a bit annoying.

SOUND

I’m a firm believer in placing items sent for review in appropriate contexts and whilst I could pop each of these units into the main rig, I don’t think that would be relevant or useful to the people who may well be considering these products. With that in mind, the pair have been sat on an Ikea unit in the sitting room next to the television and have been partnered with a pair of mid-priced loudspeakers in the form of the Leema Xens. No special racks, but the cabling is Chord’s Epic Reference for the speakers and some Merrill Audio RCAs for connecting the two together…I’m well aware a “normal” user will probably use less expensive cables, but these are what were to hand and of suitable lengths.

What’s not to like to be perfectly honest and at this price. This combo plays music and it plays it well. No, you do not get the resolution and finesse the main rig brings to the table, but let’s not forget that this pretty all inclusive pairing costs just £595 (at the moment) per box…so for 1190 quid, plus the cost of your chosen speakers and cabling, you are getting a pretty comprehensive set up. I’d purposefully not looked at the price these were available at until having heard them for a while and quite frankly I’m a little more than gobsmacked at these units’ capabilities on a bang for buck basis.

I’m playing Miles Davis’ All of You while I’m sat here typing and my right foot is tapping away to the music and I’m finding I’m typing in time to the rhythm! The top end is a bit much and a tad harsh-sounding in absolute terms (if I was to compare to the reference) on some of the piano parts and upper registers of trumpet, but the bass and mids are really quite involving and thoroughly enjoyable. I turn the volume up a little for Bye Bye Blackbird and there is good if not spectacular presence to the music that is really agreeable. The little Xens don’t go super low, but in a smaller room (I have them set up in the telly space that is abut 6 x 4 m with the wall opposite the speakers being open into a larger area) I think much more would be overkill, but the Arcam amp controls the lower frequencies pretty well and with only a slight bloom at this louder volume and with these speakers.

Switching over to the rather excellent Crown Electric by Kathryn Williams plays to the set ups strengths and there is a nice creamy quality to her voice. Mids are a little forward in the mix, but this is what I would expect for relatively budget amp, and whilst there isn’t the resolution, or absolute detail and finer refinements you get with some more expensive kit, you are presented with an enjoyable and appealing sound that sounds great. If I was being uber-critical here I’d suggest the sound is a little “flat” perhaps, but nothing that would stop me recommending this kit.

Popping on a bit of techno from the early 90s in the form of Mark NRG’s Military City presents crispy and snappy hats and snare and there’s good insight into the stereo mix without it being holographic. Ok, you lose the vigour and verve you get with a bigger system and realistically this music demands bigger speakers, but it is still enjoyable. I have the Triangle Titus EZ speakers here and popped them into the system for a short while but the bass proved to be too much for the room at volume, but showed that bass control isn’t perfect in the very lowest registers with the Arcam amp, but it’s tolerable.

Popping on an MP3 of my old reggae band shows the Arcam kit to be forgiving of poor recordings and files and, despite what many may think, this, to my mind, is a good thing given the market place I think this kit is targeted at. Lots of people buying these will have a whole host of MP3s that they have either ripped from their CD collection or have stolen off the internet (this is not me condoning this in any way, rather it is a reality of the free for all society we live in) and do not want kit that is so utterly resolving as to render it impossible to listen to.

As you would expect given that the digital signals are going through the same DAC, you get a similar presentation with CDs as you do with streaming and to be fair I’d struggle to tell the difference.

Now, our youngest has a Pro-Ject Debut Carbon Esprit turntable at the moment that came fitted with the Ortofon 2M Red and, as I mentioned, I reckon this is the kind of level of turntable that folk buying the Arcam kit will partner it with if they have any vinyl…so that got pilfered from his room and set up through the Arcam amp. I like the idea of having a simple phonostage on a budget priced amp and again we’ve got the target market thing ticked off and added another reason for prospective buyers to consider this amp. Rather than offering perfect fidelity the phonostage offers up a presentation that is commensurate with what you would expect from this price point. This is not to suggest that listening to vinyl on this set up isn’t great fun; it is and it really took me back to the days that I fist got into vinyl in my early teens where I would listen to the music for the music’s sake.

CONCLUSION 

For just shy of £1200 you get a capable streamer, CD player and well specced amplifier that it is really hard to fault given the price. Partnered with a good but relatively budget priced pair of speakers (Q Acoustics’ offerings would be excellent if budget was tight) and turntable as I have and you can have a system that will give you years of satisfaction. Yes you could go on EBay and buy better gear secondhand, but with the Arcam kit you are getting brand new kit, in their boxes and with a guarantee… and that will be important to the target market. Their price is commensurate with the kind of gear you would have called budget in the ‘80s and that would have been seen as the perfect system through which to enter the world of high-fidelity audio – this has not changed and the Arcam gear here fits this market nicely.

Whilst not the final word in absolute resolution and fidelity, the partnering gives you a great deal of enjoyment and pleasure, where you will find yourself listening to the music you own for the music’s sake rather than what your system is doing. Again the “upper echelons” of the audiophile world need to recognise that the vast majority of people just want systems that function properly and without quirks, are reliable and give them access to the music they love in an acceptable quality… and you get this in spades with these units.
If I was looking for a relatively budget system with loads of connectivity, streaming capabilities, was simple to use and offered great value for money, without being too pretentious and faffy, then the Arcam units would definitely be on my short list.

The Phonostage is an added bonus that is the cherry on top of the cake for me and as such I can do nothing but heartily recommend both the FMJCDS27 and the FMJA19 to Hifi Pig readers looking for this kind of level of kit.

Sound Quality: 8.2/10 RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Build Quality: 8.5/10 

Value for money: 9 /10 

Overall: 8.57/10

 

Pros: 

Easy to set up

Great value

Engaging and yet forgiving sound

Phonostage built in

Good remote

Great value

Cons:  

Not the last word in absolute fidelity

Arcam’s app is iOS only

Screen not really suitable for streaming purposes

 

Stuart Smith

Read more CD Player and Amplifier Reviews

 

 

 

 

 

 

Share

Aaron “The Chrome One” Integrated Amplifier

$
0
0

Dominic Marsh takes this €4790, chrome plated integrated amplifier from German manufacturer High End GmbH for a whirl to see if its sonic attributes live up to the amps good looks.

Aaron?  Who?  I hear you ask. Let me tell.  Aaron and Sovereign are the two brand names of High End GmbH, a German company owned by Thomas and Marita Hoehne situated in Elze, Lower Saxony and founded some 20-odd years ago under the then name of Neumann Audio Teknik, which was changed to Aaron in 1989.  The Aaron brand represents their value products, while the Sovereign brand represents the very best products this company produces.  All their products are hand built.  I like the way they communicate with people by calling them “Music lovers” and wish you “Happy listening” which sums up their take on their own products.aaron_close_6s

I personally have owned an Aaron product in the past, namely a Millennium Number 3 power amplifier.  Have any of you owned a product then sold it on, only to rue the day you did that ever since?  Yep, that’s me too we are talking about here and if ever there was a truly dumb thing to do, it was selling that amplifier.  I am not very good at running, but if I could have managed even a short sprint I would have chased that courier’s van down the street to get it returned for sure.  You live and learn as they say.

The Chrome One is not simply a variant of the company’s standard No.1.a model wearing a new coat, but is totally different, particularly the preampliier section which is built to be totally novel and totally discrete. The same amplifier and preamplifier section found in The Chrome One is also available in “Let’s Rock” guise which has a cast and polished alloy front panel adorned with skulls, stars, Fleur De Lys and other motifs, a top plate with a large cast skull figure, specially designed by Marita Hoehne and comes in two variants; a Silver Machine which is the bare casting and a catacomb style which has an applied dark relief coating to the casting. If polished chrome and cast alloy figures are not your scene, then the No.1.a. base model sports a brushed aluminium from panel and top plate to match.  At the time of writing, there is also another variant called the “Aaron XX  Anniversary Limited Edition”, with a black anodised front panel,  ‘XX’ being the Roman numerals for 20, representing the number of years the business has been trading.

CONSTRUCTION

The two most obvious things that strike you with this amplifier is the chrome frontage which isn’t in the slightest bit blingy and I will tell you why I think that.  The QUALITY of the chrome is exemplary in the flesh and that takes it well away from being tacky or tasteless, because simply put, it isn’t.  The second thing that you notice is the conical control knobs which are similarly attired in high quality chromium plating.  Someone nicknamed it a “Madonna” look, for the star of the same name’s famed stage appearances wearing a brassiere with large conical points.  In actual fact there was a considerable delay in the delivery of The Chrome One for review as Thomas Hoehne wasn’t satisfied with the finish of the plating and he had to source another electroplater who could satisfy his demands for the finish quality he wanted.

That aside, it’s measurements are 440mm wide X 108mm high X 375mm deep and chassis/cover is made from plate steel with a flecked black finish.  Weight is 15.5kg.

The two conical front panel controls are for menu and source selection for the left hand control and the right hand control sets the volume and power standby.  In the centre of the front panel there is a rectangular blue fluorescent display showing the selected source and the volume control setting, doubling up as the menu options display when the left hand control is pressed.  Below the display is the remote sensor window which also houses the standby LED.  Inputs are all line level with CD, MD, TUNER, DAT, TV and AUX inputs via RCA single ended connections, each of which can be level matched by software control in the menu system. To the rear panel we find the corresponding RCA inputs plus a single set of good quality speaker binding posts which will accept bare wire, 4mm banana plugs or spades.  Mains input is via a standard chassis mounted 3 pin IEC plug connection.  An optional Phono module is available at extra cost.aaron_rear_1s

A remote control is supplied which gives direct input to any of the 6 sources, a pair of buttons to adjust volume up/down and a standby button.  Looks almost hewn from a solid billet and the domed metal buttons are fantastic functionally and appear to be able to last a lifetime, although both the remote and the rotary knob were none too precise in setting the level I wanted with up/down fiddling around as it’s a touch too sensitive.  In fact the amplifier also has that similar look, the same way as you admire a 1930s Rolls Royce driving by and you are in awe because it doesn’t belch out clouds of smoke, sound like a rattled bucket of stones and the bodywork looks as pristine as when it left the factory.

Incidentally, the square chamfered metal panel mounted on the lid isn’t just there for show purposes, it is also part of the chassis damping system and it has significant weight to it, as I found out when I popped the lid off for a quick surreptitious peek inside.  Internal layout is superb by the way.Aaron_review_insides

SOUND QUALITY

Mercifully, all of High End GmbH’s products are soak tested before leaving the factory, so they are ready to play straight out of the box.  Connect CD player, then my resident Russell K Red 100 speakers, connect the power cord and hit the right hand conical control knob . . . . . . POP!  Wasn’t loud but wasn’t expecting it either, so Dominic here had to R.T.F.M (Read The Flaming Manual) which informed me this is perfectly normal as there is no soft start relay fitted because it degrades the sound, so Aaron say. So a pop when switching on or off is part of the design and to be expected.

In keeping with solid build perception its outward appearance suggests, the sound too can be summed up in one word . . .  SOLID.  This amplifier is unflappable and whatever you throw at it, it just does its job exactly as it should do.  No bells, whistles, or fireworks, it just puts out of the speaker terminals whatever you shove in at the input.  The specifications say it is rated at 100 watts per channel into an 8 Ohms impedance and 180 watts into a 4 Ohms impedance at 0.1% total harmonic distortion and 7 amps current draw continuous, but then Aaron go further by stating it can deliver 360 watts into 2 ohms and 440 watts into 1 ohms on short burst peaks of 100ms duration with a maximum 22 amps of current draw.  This is evidenced by superb and immensely powerful dynamics that are lightning quick and with no hesitation. The leading edges are crisp and clearly defined, so you never think to yourself it is ONLY a 100 watts per channel amp because the sound makes that number entirely irrelevant.  I don’t have any speakers to hand that are deemed to be a difficult load and I couldn’t put Aaron’s claims to the test, but if those figures are accurate then you would be hard pushed to get this amplifier to clip in a normal domestic listening environment.Aaaron_front_2s

So much for the overall picture of the sound, let’s move in to look at the closer details.  Of course, the reference CD went in to the player and it has to be Fink’s “Wheels Beneath My Feet” live album.  From the first bar onwards you can tell the calibre of this amplifier is a stunningly refined act.  Treble is defined in every sense of the word, separated out from the rest of the music as is the midrange and bass for that matter, each having its own space and boundaries within the music, with no clashing or muddling. Soundstage is exemplary, plus the imaging is wide and deep, although not as high as some I have heard.  The intro strikes on the Ride cymbal the drummer plays on track one called “Biscuits For Breakfast” is so convincing and so . . . what’s the word I’m looking for . . . . . tangible, it makes the hairs on the back of your head stand up.   This CD has been recorded in different venues throughout Europe during one of Fink’s many tours so the venue ambience is different for each location and the Aaron amplifier homes in on this like a laser guided Cruise missile and misses none of it.  Each audience reacts differently too and this is the first amplifier I have installed into my system that really does make you feel you are sat in amongst the audience.  No “shooshing” sounds like bacon frying in a pan during the applause, each audience member is an individual, clapping, whistling, cheering and cat calling enthusiastically all around you.  Was it my imagination, or was I actually hearing that annoying person behind me rustling their toffee papers?  Loved it.

You can actually hear each individual string of the guitar playing during chords and riffs, you can even tell what the string is made from and what it was plucked with (Plectrum or fingers) from  Fink’s acoustic guitar playing and it felt rather smug to say “nylon” while the music was playing.  When we talk about this level of fine detail, it might be crossing your mind reading this review that this amplifier is a bit explicit or somehow spot lit in its treble and midrange resolution, but be assured it isn’t, as you can listen to this amplifier for hour after hour and it never fatigues, despite the sheer torrent of fine details and nuances it is feeding you.  If it did, I would have no hesitation at all in saying so, as the Russell K Red 100 speakers take no prisoners in this respect.

I have left the best analysis of this amplifier’s performance until last.  When I listen to this particular album, it is the drums that get the closest scrutiny from me, because there must be a latent hidden aspirational drummer inside me busting to get out and start bashing those skins myself.  Kick drum must have a clearly defined start, middle and end to each strike and you must be able to hear the shell of the drum, not just the actual strike by the beater alone – be it a hard or soft faced beater being used.  Some drummers remove the front skin for a tauter less reverberant sound and that too must be easily deciphered.  Snare drum is a very revealing instrument, full of timbres and resonances, particularly so during rim shots where the rim and the shell has to be clearly heard during each strike, but above all else it must be realistic, similarly so with the tom toms and the floor tom.  I cannot abide any “tish” sort of sound from any of the cymbals, particularly the ride, crash, or riveted cymbals and if you cannot clearly hear that a wooden stick is making contact with a metal cymbal and the resulting shimmer following the strike then something is amiss with your system.  That is a roundabout and long winded way of saying that the Aaron ‘The Chrome One’ amplifier passed all of those benchmark criteria with ease.

Put some funky Jazz music on and this amplifier will soon get you out of your chair and bopping along with the music, it is so infectious.  I was even minded to play some Classical music excerpts too (Yes, but not a full symphony for me I’m afraid!) and the scale and power of the entire orchestra was delivered through the speakers effortlessly with awesome weight and dynamics, even though Classical isn’t featured at all in my regular listening sessions or evaluations as a rule.  Must be a good amplifier then!

CONCLUSION

I can assume you get the perception that I like if not love the sound of this amplifier and you would be right in thinking that.  But, there are other factors to consider before Dominic starts handing out the plaudits and gongs.  All this eulogising about how great it sounds and the one thing I haven’t mentioned at all is price.  The amplifier featured in this review will set you back 4,790Euros, which equates to GB£3,582 or US$5,238. Uniquely though, Aaron offer payment terms if you so wish with a deposit down and monthly repayments plan of up to 36 months which is available on their website.  Given that this could be the last amplifier you would possibly buy and which will last for many years, it might be worth considering that route as a long term game plan if you don’t have the available reddies.

If you require the matching Phono module, then that will set you back another 1,590 Euros.  That makes it a fairly expensive proposition and sets it above its immediate rivals in the marketplace too, but if the price fazes you not, then go ahead and audition this very fine amplifier.

As much as I greatly appreciate the quality of the Chrome One’s appearance, if I had the money (which I don’t!)  I would personally forego that luxury finish and head towards its cheaper sibling, the No.1.a. amplifier in brushed aluminium priced at 3590 Euros, which should still give me the great sonic performances that I have heard from The Chrome One.

In my annual letter to Santa Claus I specifically requested a Chrome One to be in my stocking on Christmas Day morning.  I woke very early especially in eager anticipation.  All I got was a Satsuma.
Sound Quality: 9.6/10RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Build Quality: 8.9/10

Value For Money: 8.3/10

Overall: 8.93/10

Pros:
Awesome sound quality that’s hard to find fault with in any area.

Beautiful chromium plated highlights

Cons:
If pops on switch on or off bother you, then avoid
Price is a tad steep compared to its rivals, but hand built quality never ever comes cheap
No built in phono stage
Remote control and front panel rotary volume control a touch too sensitive

Dominic Marsh

Read more amplifier reviews

Designer’s Notes

The AARON“The Chrome One”was developed to reproduce complex Music events in a live-like sound quality and volume.
It is an integrated amplifier in modular method of construction. Composed with separate monaural output stages, preamplifier and operating sections. The preamplifier section consists of two mono-boards in a discreet design with high precision, for each channel selected components.
The power supply for the preamplifier and control section and the output modules is made by using two separate transformers.
The AARON ” The Chrome One”works very stable and is also for low impedance speakers suitable. The power output stages work in collector follower circuit.
The amplifier is equipped with discrete channel-wise selected and matched parts in a shortest possible signal path layout. This, for a short signal path optimized layout, without the use of any sound damaging capacitors, guarantees a perfect natural and balanced sound.
Six Stereo devices with line outputs, can be connected. The input and output levels of each connected device are high precise adjustable. The high quality metal AARON remote control is included. The amplifier can be used as a pure high-end amplifier in solo mode. Alternatively, the operation of speakers with an additional power amplifier, such as AARON No.3 Millennium, in Bi-amping operation is possible.
A Phono stage is available as an option.

TechnicalSpecifications:

Outputpower continuous sine wave: 100 W/8Ω 180 W/4Ω 0.1%THD

Output power pulsed: 360W/2Ω 440W/1Ω 0.1%THD
Maximum continuous current: 7A
Maximum pulsed current: 22A (100ms burst)
Minimum load 1Ω
DistortionTHD: 0.0115%8Ω –5Watt– 1kHz
DistortionTIM: 0.012% 8Ω –5Watt– 50Hz/7Khz4:1
Humand Noise level: -98dB ref: Max, output level
Bandwidth: 0 – 130kHz -3dB 1W/8Ω
Gainmax: 100x =40dB280mV for max output
Input impedance: 47KΩ
Damping factor: 600
Slewrate 21V/µS
ACvoltage: 115VAC/230V AC internal switch 50/60Hz
+/-10% Power consumption: Idle9VA – Max 550 VA
Power supply: 500VA toroidal transformer and 6×10.000µF
Volumecontrol: 64 step Log digital controlled ladder switch
Features: Each input channel programmable – input gain (-16dB). Each output channel programmable output gain (-16dB). Programmable processor switch 2 channel in/out, Infrared remote control
Protection: Internalfuseon power rail only (no current limiting). Power amp mute on switch off
Inputs: 6 x 2channel lineinput RCA gold plated
Outputs: 2channel preout +2channel proc.out RCA gold plated
Controls: 2x rotary encoder with push button
Loudspeaker outputs: 2 x pairs binding posts gold plated
Dimensions: 440x108x375mm WxHxD
Shipping weight 15,5 KG
EAN / UPC (0)609465757933

Share

PrimaLuna DiaLogue Premium HP Integrated Amplifier

$
0
0

The PrimaLuna DiaLogue Premium HP Integrated Amplifier at £2,998 is billed as a fit an forget valve amplifier that avoids many of the headaches traditionally associated with valve amp ownership. Ian Ringstead takes one for a spin. 

This was always going to be an exciting product to review. Firstly because it was a product I had always wanted to review and although not new to valves I had never taken the plunge in the past to buy one and so when given the chance to try the Prima Luna I couldn’t resist. 029-PrimaLuna DiaLogue Premium HP Integrated Amplifier Black-high res

I have followed this manufacturer from their beginnings and heard the amps at many shows over the years and have always been very impressed with what I heard. Valve amps have a certain mystique amongst audiophiles, love them or hate them, but I have always been open minded and every time I have heard one at the numerous shows I have attended over the last 40 years they always fascinated  and usually impressed me. Prima Luna is a relatively young company compared to its established rivals from the USA and Europe being founded in 2003. The name Prima Luna is Italian for first moon and founder Herman van den Dungen adopted the name from his Grandparents and a place in Italy.030-PrimaLuna DiaLogue Premium HP Integrated Amplifier Black-high res

More than 30 years of high-end experience in the fields of design, manufacturing, export, import, retail, and after-sales-service is the basis for a range of affordable and reliable, yet highly musical products. Together with Marcel Croese (of Goldmund fame) and Dominique Chenet (of Jadis fame) he heads his team to simply bring the best products, with the best service and for the best price.The philosophy of the PrimaLuna team is that it is not just the PrimaLuna products, but also the people involved in PrimaLuna that have to be top-of-the-bill. So the goal for PrimaLuna is to give you excellent designers, highest quality manufacturing and a first-class sales and after-sales network. This is all without becoming unaffordable and involves Western design and marketing, combined with Far East manufacturing under European control and Dutch after-sales-service. PrimaLuna say they are proud that skilled and experienced distributors and dealers from all over the world have now started to recognize the potential of the PrimaLuna brand for themselves and their clientèle.033-PrimaLuna DiaLogue Premium HP Integrated Amplifier Black-high res

With a philosophy like that I was eager to try the DiaLogue Premium HP Integrated Amplifier in my system. Absolute Sounds, the distributors here in the UK, very kindly supplied not just the standard EL34 valves that are normally supplied, but also a set of KT120 valves. This was great because I could then compare the difference between the valve types (tube rolling as it is called).

The DiaLogue Premium HP Integrated Amplifier is very solidly built and extremely well put together, being neat in appearance and footprint. Unlike some valve amps I have seen at this is not a great behemoth and fitted neatly on my equipment rack, being no wider than standard separates. The only proviso is that you must give it room to breathe with adequate ventilation as tubes obviously get hot, so it rested on the top shelf. I had the black version, but it is also supplied in silver. The quality of finish is to automotive paint standards and there are five coats of paint applied, not as many as a Rolls Royce , but still very impressive. The front panel is simply laid out with a volume control on the left, the input selector on the right and headphone socket. The controls are well weighted and solid in feel and use. In-between are power indication LEDs  and a neat touch is the green and red valve operation LEDs as you can switch on the fly via the remote control between triode and ultralinear mode, allowing one to alter the sound at the flick of a remote switch. What a great feature. Although not a new innovation, being switchable via the remote is so convenient.

PrimaLuna amps are famous for long tube life and running relatively cool. What they’ve done is increase the power and output transformer size, designed and built a larger Adaptive AutoBias board, and all the supporting circuitry required to run eight power tubes instead of four.  This doubles the power and increases bass slam. Customers can use almost any tube on the market and the new DiaLogue Premium HP can be shipped with EL-34s, Gold Lion KT88s, or Tung-sol KT120s

The headphone amp runs from all the power tubes and the elegant, well designed circuit allows you to switch from speakers to headphone as you wish.  If you love private listening, this amp is ideal. I tried this feature near the end of my time with the amp and I have to say it was excellent with very low noise and no detectable hum.

The design and development that has gone into the PrimaLuna range is astonishing.

As with all PrimaLuna amps, you never have to worry about biasing your amp ever again, and the need for matched tubes is eliminated.  Just plug in EL34, KT88, or KT120 (as well as many others) and the on-board Exclusive Adaptive AutoBias does the rest.  Tubes are constantly monitored and kept in their best operating range, reducing distortion by up to a claimed 50%!

Silver-plated, oxygen-free continuous crystal (OCC) copper with a Teflon dielectric wiring is used in the critical signal paths (point-to-point wiring is used throughout) and an ALPS Blue Velvet motorized volume control is used as standard. TAKMAN premium resistors made in Japan are used inside the amp, as are SCR Tinfoil Caps in the critical signal paths and while they are expensive, the PrimaLuna team felt they could not be left out.

PrimaLuna custom-winds their own AC toroidal transformer and instead of a cheap selector switch, PrimaLuna has a relay and circuit mounted at every input.  If you select a CD player input, for example, a relay closes and a perfect load is presented to the item you are listening to.  All other relays are open so as to prevent crosstalk between inputs.  If the power transformer should overheat, the “Power Transformer Protection” circuit cuts primary power, allows the amp to cool down, then resets itself.034-PrimaLuna DiaLogue Premium HP Integrated Amplifier Black-high res

The DiaLogue Premium uses three 12AU7 tubes per channel and as mentioned previously you can switch between Triode/Ultralinear from the remote. In ultralinear you get the flattest response, whilst in triode mode you get a sound that PrimaLuna say people have compared to 300B single-ended amps.  On the chassis’ deck in front of each power tube, is a small LED that lights up if the tube goes bad. The circuit then puts the amp into protection mode, you just replace the tube it tells you to and turn the amp back on. Another useful safety feature is the “Output Transformer Protection” circuit that protects the output transformers in the event of users crossing speaker wires. A “+B relay” replaces the plate fuse and works in conjunction with the OTP-circuit to protect the amp against tube failure.

The amp has dedicated subwoofer output for those that prefer smaller speakers and a sub.

That is one comprehensive list of features but what about the sound of the amp? I found this amp immediately engaging, solid and real sounding with a lovely depth to the sound being produced. There is no hint of a syrupy sound or lack of clarity here which is a negative attribute that is often levelled at valve amps, particularly older designs. All types of music were beautifully portrayed. I tried Fink’s album Wheels Turn Beneath My Feet, a favourite of my colleague Dominic Marsh, because it is a superb live recording from several venues during their European tour. Each venue has a different acoustic and it was easy to hear the differences with the PrimaLuna in place. Also very apparent was the excellent quality of the sound recording and I was able to pick up every nuance of the atmosphere and characteristics of the guitar, bass and drums. The kick drum on Sort of Revolution was amazing and had a real palpable feel and wallop to it…almost as if the drummer was in the room with you. Tracey Chapman’s Fast Car, amongst the many great tracks from her first album from the eighties, sounded fresh and still had a joyous feel to it even all these years later. Great music never dies out.

CONCLUSION

What I learned listening to the PrimaLuna  DiaLogue Premium HP Integrated Amplifier was valve amps can be domestically acceptable as well as “fit and forget”, something that has not always been the case and one of the reasons valve amps have not gained universal acceptance. PrimaLuna have certainly done their best to arrest this issue and I feel they have succeeded admirably. Now as to which mode was best is truly down to personal taste and will depend on many variables. I switched many times and although it was obvious on occasions, I wouldn’t like to say which was best. The same was true of the output tubes, EL34’s or KT120’s, with the KT120s having a more powerful sound than the former. Again you choose. Both were excellent and it may well depend on your room size and speaker efficiency as to which ones you choose.

At £2,998 this amp isn’t cheap, but when you appreciate the effort that has gone into this design I think it is fantastic value compared to many of the more expensive brands out there. The remote control is excellent, hewn out of metal with rubber protective bands either end. Recently PrimaLuna announced you can add a Phono module, allowing owners to use a turntable with a moving magnet or high output moving coil cartridge on one of the amps inputs for a very reasonable cost. Nice touch and keeps the box count down.

The power output was more than adequate and I had loads on tap, after all valve watts are certainly more powerful than transistor watts in my opinion.

Power output si quoted as follows: EL34 – Ultralinear  73 watts, Triode 42 watts and KT120 – Ultralinear 89 watts, Triode 51watts

All in all a truly versatile amp. What more could you ask for? Well PrimaLuna also make pre amps, power amps and a nice looking CD player. If you fancy taking the plunge into valve territory the PrimaLuna range is a great way to enter without fear of problems. There are of course other excellent companies producing valve amps, but PrimaLuna seem to have covered all bases and although not budget they don’t bankrupt you if you are serious about owning a very reliable long term investment.

Sound Quality: 9.2/10RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Build Quality: 9.1/10

Value for money: 8.9/10

Overall: 9.06/10 

Pros        

A true “fit and forget”, easy to use valve amp with remote control

Great sound with tube rolling capability and switchable triode/ ultralinear mode

Headphone output

Valve cage included

Excellent build quality 

Cons

Remote is metal and very heavy so don’t drop it on your foot!

Requiring eight output tubes can make changing expensive.

 

Share

MCRU Limited Edition Silver Plated 6 Way Mains Block

$
0
0

Dominic Marsh takes a look at the £180, silver plated power block from MCRU.

Mains Cables R Us (MCRU for short) have been specialising in mains cable products for a good number of years now and in addition to selling products from manufacturers such as Furutech, Black Rhodium and Tellurium Q, they also sell products under their own brand name and this mains block is one of these MCRU branded products.mcru-ltd-edition-silver-plated-mains-block

CONSTRUCTION

At first glance this looks just like any other mains block, that is until you look much closer in detail.  The 3 pin mains plug appears to be a standard UK mains plug from MK, but the MCRU motif on the cap says otherwise and when you turn it over you are greeted by silver plating to all three pins, carried out by MCRU.  The entry lead is built using silver plated copper conductors, approximately 9mm wide, is extremely flexible and covered in black expandable braiding, measuring a standard 1.5 metres in length, with other lengths available to order.  Once again, the block itself looks nothing special being made of black plastic, but you will find no neon indicator or on/off switch present, as they are said to be detrimental to sound quality and have been removed for that purpose.  Internally though, all of the bus bars have been silver plated especially by MCRU at a local electroplaters and a soldered connection to the entry lead by using Audio Note 6% silver solder, again with conductivity in mind.

Price at time of testing is £180.00.

SOUND QUALITY

Or rather a lack of sound quality, as a mains block should never impose any of its own sonic imprint on to a hifi system, especially any form of compression and limiting of dynamics.   Remember too, you are not putting something “wonderful” in, you are taking out a component that has inadequacies and replacing it with a component that has less faults – none of them are in actual fact perfect anyway no matter how much money you pay.  It is those progressive steps up the hierarchy in sound quality terms that also has a commensurate rise in price as well, because removing those ‘imperfections’ in the products does not come cheap either.

My regular readership will also know that I do not do direct comparisons between competing components in the marketplace, because each has their own merits and so giving and taking away of points doesn’t always mean the ‘best’ product with the highest wins the battle or shootout.  However, with this particular review I felt I had to use some comparisons with other products to put into perspective and context what this product’s capabilities were, because there are so many of these blocks available to buy, so I hope you will bear with me just this once.  This is not to say either that the MCRU mains block occupies a particular place in the market and that should be borne in mind when reading this review.  All of the products mentioned below including the MCRU block were run in for approximately 50 hours as I am aware that cables not used for any length of time need running in once more to sound at their optimum.mcru-ltd-edition-silver-plated-mains-block (1)

The real issue facing me before I even started the evaluation was comparable products to pit the MCRU block against.  My resident MS Audio block costs at least twice as much and so that was no equally matched contender, so I had to venture into the dark and gloomy spares cupboard to upset all the spiders in there to find what I was looking for.  Amazing what can be found when you look hard enough and I found a generic 6 way mains block from a well known DIY store, a Brennenstuhl aluminium bodied 6 way block and a Russ Andrews Yellow 6 way block.  That should do nicely for comparisons and closed the cupboard door to let the spiders get back to doing what spiders do best – whatever that is.

First up then was the DIY store block for the princely sum of £5.99.  No on/off switch, but there is a neon indicator lamp, a thin captive mains lead and a generic UK 3 pin plug.  Slow timed boomy bass, clouded midrange, indistinct treble, goodness me I had forgotten what one of these was like to be truthful.  If this is what you currently run your system on, then do yourself a huge favour and use it in the shed for your power tools instead.

Next to try was the Brennenstuhl 6 way aluminium bodied block with a captive mains lead of decent thickness already fitted.  This one has a mains switch, a neon indicator lamp and the mains lead almost 2.5 metres in length, neatly storable (is that a valid word?) by winding the cable around the block’s length with a channel at each end to hold it, a rather neat solution if you ask me.  The aluminium casing gives the perception that it is robust and long lasting, although I wouldn’t use it as an axle stand when repairing the car.  Cannot remember what it cost when it was new, but the number “45” sticks in the mind somewhere.  For all the robust build and attractive looks, this didn’t fare much better in sonic terms than the generic DIY one, except the bass was just a bit  firmer and tauter, still lacking in weight and power, plus the top end had slightly better resolution.

Although long since obsolete, the Russ Andrews Yellow 6 way block did at one time power my entire system.  It wasn’t a superb performer by any stretch of the imagination, but I did get a huge improvement in sound quality switching to one after a generic cheap £5 block bought from a supermarket as I recall and for that I was grateful at the time of course.   I cannot recall how much I paid for it.  No neon lamp, no switch either and no details about construction were ever given.  For the purpose of this test, I now heard a leap forward in sound from the previous two candidates, as bass was now much fuller bodied and the midrange cloudiness was lifted.  Treble too acquired some air and space.

Finally we come to the MCRU 6 way block and there was some anticipation that given how much attention MCRU has paid to silver plating all the metal conducting components, that there would be some benefits to be heard from it.  Indeed there was, as the treble acquired more clarity and a much better focus, while dynamics was raised a notch or two, the leading edges of notes having a sweet taut crispness.  Bass extension didn’t increase further down into the lower registers, but there was a lush warmness to the sound with less overhang and more articulation.  I also noticed a big improvement in sound staging and the noise floor seemed lower too.

Naturally, at the end of the evaluation I re-installed my MS Audio mains block and I know I said clearly at the very beginning of this review that it wasn’t a good comparison because it was more than twice the price, but the MCRU block fared very well against the MS Audio block, much to my surprise.

CONCLUSION

As the old saying goes “Never judge a book by its cover” then that wise set of words applies equally so to the MCRU Limited Edition 6 way mains block.  It looks superficially plain and uninteresting (most no doubt will be installed out of sight anyway), but MCRU have placed more emphasis on what goes on inside the device than what has gone into its outward appearance.  On that basis then it could be a viable candidate if you are looking to buy a better mains block to improve the sound of your system, especially so if you currently use a generic block of indeterminate parentage like the one that was found in my spares cupboard.  It easily saw off the contenders I pitted it against in sound terms and came close on the heels of my resident mains block that’s more than double the price, so for that reason I will give it a recommendation.

Build quality:8.1/10RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Sound quality:8.8/10

Value for money:8.6/10

Overall:8.5/10

Pros: Good sound quality owing to that custom silver plating of all the conductor surfaces.

Cons: Mains block body is not the best quality to look at.

Dominic Marsh

Share


Fezz Audio Silver Luna EL34 Valve Amplifier

$
0
0

The Silver Luna integrated valve amplifier from Polish company Fezz Audio uses EL34 tubes and costs £725 including European shipping, which is something of a budget price for tube amp. Dominic Marsh takes a listen. 

Whoever said that turntables and valve amplifiers were strictly yesterday’s technology?  Far from being the dinosaurs of hifi from days gone past, there is a huge unprecedented resurgence of both and this trend shows no sign of letting up just yet either.wzmak_01_front_reds

Enter then the Fezz Audio (A newly formed division of Toroidy.pl) Silver Luna valve amplifier sporting EL34 output valves and designed and manufactured in Poland.  The most critical component in valve amplifiers is of course the transformers and who better to specify and build them than Toroidy who have been manufacture high quality transformers for many years.  I have used Toroidy myself not too long ago when a CD player I owned originating from the far east decided one of its mains transformers needed a permanent holiday. This was not long after the manufacturer ceased trading but a quick email to Toroidy had a custom built replacement winging its way to me a week later and at a very sensible price too I might add.  My fellow reviewer Dan Worth has balanced mains units feeding his system, fitted with Toroidy transformers.

CONSTRUCTION

The entire chassis is formed of folded mild steel plate and is nothing remarkable to look at in form and shape.  Fezz Audio do make at least make an attempt regarding the aesthetic aspect by giving a choice of paint colours.  Black Ice gloss chassis with matte black finish transformer covers, White gloss chassis with Sky Blue gloss transformer covers, Burgundy gloss chassis with matte black transformer covers and Burning Red gloss chassis with matte black transformer covers.  The colourways do at least make the amplifiers more attractive than plain black all over with no relief.  To the centre of the front panel is a bright metal oval plaque proclaiming “Fezz Audio”  in laser cut relief.

Instead of using the traditional laminated plate type of construction for the output transformers, Fezz Audio use Toroidy’s own in-house designed and built toroidal transformers in the output stages as well as the mains transformer.  Fezz Audio say there are many quality components installed like Alps volume pots and Nichicon FG Fine Gold capacitors.

The review sample provided was finished in the Burning Red finish with silver lettering which I found difficult to read, especially round the back when making connections due to the contrast in tones between the red and the silver.  It was less important on the front panel for me as remembering what only two controls do wasn’t dependant at all on the lettering to recall.  On any of the other colours the lettering is clear and distinct with higher contrast ratios and in the case of the white chassis variant, black lettering is used.

The valves were packed separately in their original Electro Harmonix boxes, each thoughtfully numbered in the order they were to be installed into the amplifier.  Nice to see good quality valves being used.  It is wise to do a quick check of the valve biasing (Easy to perform, well explained in the handbook) and all was still within specification when installed.

The amplifier has three line level inputs, selectable by the right hand front panel rotary control.  The left side of the front panel sports the volume level rotary control.  The rear of the chassis we find three sets of single ended RCA inputs, then the loudspeaker connectors with a single pole for the negative or return connection and either an 8 Ohm or 4 Ohm tapped connection for the corresponding impedance value of the speakers being employed.  Finally, an IEC mains inlet plug with a mains on/off switch above it.  This is one of my personal bugbears as it means components fitted with rear mounted power switches give you a choice of either having them sited on the top shelf of the rack for easy access, or having to contort your body and arm to reach it between the shelves lower down in the rack.  With the heat from the valves to contend with during switch off or inadvertently knocking a valve and breaking it, it makes even less sense to rear mount the power switch.  Yes I know, it is all to do with cost, but I have seen many amps with power switches on the side panel or underneath the front panel, which takes all that stress and risk away and doesn’t add THAT much to the build cost in reality.

There is no remote control facility.wzmak_01_tyl_reds

SOUND QUALITY

EL34 valves and their circuits do have a reputation that precedes them and are often accused of being syrupy, warm toned, coloured and combinations thereof.  It’s all in the implementation of course and usually it’s because designers try to wring more performance from EL34’s than they are comfortable in delivering.  Reputations, rumours and whispers do not interest me in the slightest and this was just another amplifier submitted for review and so I began listening with an open mind.

As is the case with most valve amplifiers, they seem to need around 20 – 30 minutes to come “on song” from switch on and I gave  a comfortable 30 minutes warm up time before each listening session.

What first struck me was how light and airy it sounded, that is not to say light in power or weight, more by the transparency and delicacy it was showing me.  Images were hanging in the air as if supported by near invisible gossamer threads and it was very close to being a true walk around the sound stage experience.  I would expect that kind of performance from a 6550 valve and above, but not from an EL34, which shows some care has been taken with the circuit topology in the design of this amplifier.  Having a rated 35 watts per channel into 8 ohms to play with, you could be forgiven for thinking this amplifier doesn’t have a lot of headroom to play with, but you would be wrong.  It could go very loud without showing any signs of break up or distress and that was a test rather than saying this amplifier could belt out heavy rock music day after day, because that’s not what this amplifier’s true forte is by any means.

It was in its element with female vocals, acoustic, jazz and middle of the road kind of music, where the natural organic sounds of these genres shone through.  It would play large scale orchestral and rock music in moderation at sensible levels, but push the volume control around past 12 o’clock and the edges started to fray a bit, albeit at a level that wasn’t comfortable to listen to.  A party or disco amplifier it is not, for sure.  Keep the volume control below that 12 o’clock mark and it held it together really well and when I put James Newton Howard and Friends direct cut album on to play the Silver Luna gave me a fast, lithe and vivid performance that was a real pleasure to listen to.wzmak_01_bok_reds

Whenever I listen to Fink’s “Wheels Beneath My Feet” live album I have certain benchmarks I pay particular attention to during my evaluations and here are just some of the key points.  Kick drum must have a clearly defined start, middle and end to each strike and you must be able to hear the shell of the drum, not just the actual strike by the beater alone – be it a hard or soft faced beater being used.  Some drummers remove the front skin for a tauter less reverberant sound and that too must be easily deciphered.  Snare drum is a very revealing instrument, full of timbres and resonances, particularly so during rim shots where the rim and the shell has to be clearly heard during each strike, but above all else it must be completely realistic, similarly so with the Tom Toms and the Floor Tom.  I cannot abide any “tish” sort of sound from any of the cymbals, particularly the Ride, Crash, or Riveted cymbals and if you cannot clearly hear that a wooden stick is making contact with a metal cymbal and the resulting shimmer following the strike then something is amiss.  That is a roundabout and long winded way of saying that the Fezz Audio Silver Luna amplifier passed all of those benchmark criteria.FEz3s

CONCLUSION

Well, the Fezz Audio Silver Luna EL34 just about shrugged off all that I pitted against it and it didn’t offend me at any point either.  It is a sweet natured beast rather than a snorting bull of an amp, but it can kick like a mule when called to do so, provided you don’t pair it with inefficient speakers.  It wouldn’t win a beauty pageant, but to me most of the budget seems to have gone into the internals rather than wearing a fancy coat designed to impress.  A choice of colours deflects the mind away from that though and is a good compromise.

In the value for money stakes, costing some 950.00 Euros (GB £725.00) which includes shipping within the EU, it offers good value.  At US$1033.25 plus shipping it still looks to be good value.

As an introduction to the world of valve amplifiers, it gives an insight into that velvety “Valve sound” without busting the bank balance and you can be sure it will have both reliability and longevity too.

Build quality: 8.1/10fezz_audio_recommended_valve_amp_el34

Sound quality: 8.7/10

Value for money: 8.5/10

Overall: 8.43/10

Pros:

Great sound, quality components used throughout and chassis colour choices should find many fans

Cons:   

Lack of valve protection cage and rear mounted power switch (see text above)

Dominic Marsh

SPECIFICATIONS (Not verified by Hifi Pig)

Maximum output power : 2 x 35W / 8Ω
Circuit type : AB class
Output impedance : 4Ω / 8Ω
Inputs : 3 x RCA
Harmonic distortions THD : < 1%
Frequency response : 15Hz-77kHz (-3dB)
Power consumption : 150W
AC fuse : 3,15A T
Net weight : 15,3kg

 

Dimensions : 400x320x165mm
Tubes : EL34 x 4 (power output), ECC83 x 2 (pre-amplifier and power drivers)
 

 

 

 

Share

Audiofilia AF-S6 Loudspeakers

$
0
0

Audiofilia make a range of loudspeakers, electronics and accessories, here Dominic Marsh tries out the Italian company’s AF-S6 floorstanding loudspeaker that costs € 6160.

Audiofilia are an Italian company specialising in loudspeaker and electronics manufacture, founded in 2011 by Alessio Paolizzi and Francesco Stocchi.  The unique feature of this company’s loudspeaker lineup is their “S System” which the company claims tackles head on the problems associated with cabinet resonances, which I have no intention of explaining, but it will be mentioned in the review body.AF_S6reviezpics

CONSTRUCTION

The pair of loudspeakers submitted for review were the AF-S6 model, large three and a half way floor standers.  Natural wood finishes are also available, as are piano gloss black and white.  I must also mention that the supplied speakers were fitted with the optional (at extra cost) Fountek ribbon tweeter rather than the standard issue dome tweeter.  The remainder of the drive units are sourced from Morel which already intimates this isn’t going to be a “budget” speaker by any means, rather one that certainly has aspirations towards high end sound quality.  Unusual too in this day and age is having a domed midrange driver fitted.  I still don’t understand why this driver isn’t as popular as it once was, as it helps to avoid critical crossover points in the upper midrange.  Cabinet loading is by a front mounted reflex port.

These are substantial cabinets weighing some 20-odd kilograms each and fitted with Audiofilia’s own design of feet, which they say should not be replaced by spikes, or placed on plinths.  No doubt, but my listening room has thick carpets and a thick underlay beneath that and these speakers almost swayed around like a palm tree in a hurricane, so despite Audiofilia’s best advice, some thick solid Oak slabs went underneath which increased stability hugely, yet still allowed a small amount of movement.  At least I could relax during the listening sessions knowing that the speakers weren’t going to topple over at any minute.  The speakers arrived without any jumper links fitted, so I pressed into service a set of pure silver jumpers that I keep in a spares drawer for just such eventualities.

The cabinet is built with Audiofilia’s “S System” which is designed to harnesses the drive unit’s natural vibrations to generate a “hybrid waveguide” of a pneumatic nature, which interacts with the air flow and pressure inside the cabinet by accelerating or slowing it until a precise point, previously set in the design phase, is reached.  It is akin I gather to a piano’s or violin’s body, whereby the strings excite the whole instrument so it is the wood itself not the strings themselves which creates the sound that we hear, hence why Stradivarius violins and Steinway pianos are not made of concrete.

One last thing to mention before I move onto how these speakers sound and that is I was told they needed around 400 (Yes, that FOUR HUNDRED) hours of running in before old Dominic’s ears could even begin to assess their sound qualities. And that was on top of three other components with similar break in periods at the same time.  Gulp!

SOUND QUALITY

It is not easy “ignoring” speakers for 400 hours or so and then turning your attention to them.   They do however run in exponentially as most other speakers do and after around 80 hours or so the rate of change decreased so I could at least hear what they were capable of at that point without analyzing them too deeply.    Even at that milestone I could formulate a good take on what they were capable of and I wouldn’t say they were a “Hifi” sounding speaker full of verve and fireworks to grab your attention and I’d say they were rather grown up and sophisticated in fact, consistent from the lowest octaves right up to the highest treble, with no peaks or troughs along the way.  It is that very sophistication in sound that draws you into the music, so deep that you become totally immersed in it and the listening time just seems to fly by without you even realising it.  One could be forgiven then for assuming they are a rather mild or polite kind of speaker, but trust me they can produce fireworks when you ask them nicely and my listening tests will demonstrate that, so bear with me.AF_S6-02

They are not a power hungry speaker by any means and I drove them easily with a variety of amplifiers ranging from an EL34 valve amplifier from Fezz Audio, a compact streamer/amplifier from Cabasse, the Aaron “The Chrome One”, a diminutive little TAGA valve/hybrid amplifier, plus of course my resident amplifier and all produced a sound I could easily live with, so matching them to amplification of whatever persuasion shouldn’t prove to be difficult.

As my regular readers will know, I don’t generally listen to orchestral or jazz music, but the Audiofilia speakers simply begged me to play some through them.  In to the CD drawer then went my trusty old compilation CD that has around 15 or so excerpts from well known, popular orchestral recordings.  I particularly enjoyed Eric Satie’s “Gymnopedie”  played on a Concert Grand and the luscious tonal palette produced by that instrument had the hairs on the back of my neck bristling.  PHEW!  I can though now understand how orchestral aficionados get so energized by listening to this kind of music, as performed well it has a lot going for it – but still not for me and my classical excerpts CD is plenty enough for me.

Jazz isn’t my thing either, but I will admit to liking Dave Brubeck’s “Take Five” occasionally and some while ago I transferred the direct cut recording “A Cut Above” vinyl to CD when I sold a turntable, so I could at least enjoy the dynamics of this recording for the times when a turntable didn’t grace my system (I used to change them frequently).  Anyway, the drum solo in Take Five is something else and if there ever was a recording with no compression and big fast dynamics, then this was it.  The Audiofilia AF-S6 speakers certainly could kick up a dust cloud when required to and however much I turned the volume up I couldn’t detect any signs of distress from them.  There are some drum rolls and snare drum strikes in this recording that can certainly make speaker drivers jump around  and if you, like me, revel in fast transients, this recording will no doubt please.

Down to the nitty gritty when I finally hit the four hundred hour mark in the running in process and the gloves were then off and the real evaluation process began.  In to the CD player went Porcupine Tree’s “Deadwing” album which is a raw, uncouth recording that either sounds rough and ragged, or smooth as silk and it is the kind of sound that shows up a speaker’s true characteristics.  The Audiofilia’s, much to my surprise, managed to walk along the hair’s breadth sized tightrope between revealing all the harshness this album contains that makes it a real wince listen, filing off the rawer edges to make it at least tolerable to listen to.  Had they rounded everything off and made it sound smooth, pleasurable and musical, I would have been concerned.drivers

Of course, the stock reference recording had to be played and Fink’s “Wheels Beneath My Feet” live album was inserted into the CD player so I could really get to grips with the AF-S6’s sonic palette.  The opening cymbal strikes in “Biscuits For Breakfast” didn’t quite muster the sheen and polish from my resident speakers (Russell K Red 100), the shimmer of the cymbal was there, but without the level of refinement I have been accustomed to.  We are talking a very subtle effect, but noted nonetheless.  Ambience cues from the venue were well conveyed though and the audience was heard without any “shooshing” sounds and I could pick out individuals easily.  Kick drum had a firm pounding crisp beat to it and I could tell a hard beater was being used.  Snare drum rims shots came across very realistically, so good marks there.  Fink’s voice can sound rather nasal on this track with some speakers, but thankfully the  AF-S6’s managed to avoid that, so again good marks there.  Moving on to the “Sort of Revolution” track, this has some very powerful strikes to the Floor Tom on the drums and this is my test for bass control.  Yes, the force and power must be relayed, but I also want to hear a good clean leading edge and no overhang, yet still be able for it to make me feel the energy being released in the pit of my stomach, like a mule kick.  No problem with any of those criteria from the AF-S6’s.  Throughout this album I should be able to hear the different reverb and ambience cues from each of the venues the album was recorded in and this wasn’t as easy to determine with these speakers as clearly as I can from my resident speakers.  I could hear them, but I had to work at it rather than let the speakers do it for me.  Contrary to that though, the sound staging was impressive, being well out beyond the speaker boundaries and with good depth too.

CONCLUSION

All in all then, a good performance from these speakers with only one exception.  It seemed to me that the tweeters were reaching high up the frequency range, but at the very top end they lacked the absolute power, clarity and resolution I was expecting from the ribbon tweeter, which I felt was ever so slightly rolled off.  That can be a blessing of course, depending on partnering equipment where that silkiness at the very top end could be beneficial.  It didn’t offend me as such and if you asked me if I could live with these speakers full time the answer would be in the affirmative, as overall they gave a fine performance with many genres of music, especially so with acoustic, classical and jazz where the speakers gave of their best.   With that small proviso, I will give them a recommendation and an audition is well advised before purchase.

Build quality: 8.3/10RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Sound quality: 8.9/10

Value for money: 8.6/10

Overall: 8.6/10

Price at time of writing 6160 Euros

 

Pros:

A good solid all round performer with no major vices.

Cons:

A slightly rolled off upper treble – could be beneficial in some systems

 

Dominic Marsh

SPECIFICATIONS

Drive units: 2x woofer 6”, 1x dome midrange 2”, 1x dome tweeter 1” (or ribbon 1,5”)

Tecnology: “S” system transverse channeled

Type: 3½ way Reflex

Frequency response: 16Hz – 25kHz (or 40kHz) +/- 3db

Sensitivity: 90 db SPL (1W 2.83V / 1m)

Harmonic distortion: < 0,9% 63Hz – 25kHz (or 40kHz)

Impedance: 8 Ω

Recommended amplifier power: 3W / 200W

Dimensions: H 1100 x W 200 x D 380

Finishes: Wood or Lacquered

Krell Digital Vanguard Integrated Amplifier

$
0
0

Janine Elliot takes a listen to the Krell Digital Vanguard, an integrated amplifier costing £5998 and boasting a whole host of features relevant to today’s modern home. 

Krell were one of the first manufacturers to bring out amplifiers “built like a tank”; heavy-weights full of masses of capacitors, toroidal power supplies and front panels as thick as, well, tank armoury. Indeed, makers from across the big pond, including those in Canada have always had a reputation of building big and thick and Krell’s latest integrated amplifier The Vanguard is no exception with the distinctive “I mean business” bonnet on the front and four large wheels to hold it down, though at only 10.5cm tall it is small by Krell standards.Krell_vanguard_fronts

For those who have studied Krell, this product is a typical no-expenses-spared offering with a fully discrete and balanced Class A circuit. Krell rightly believe that Class A designs are the most musically accurate circuit designs, and don’t suffer from the characteristic distortions that Class AB amplifiers create. The Vanguard is Class A through-and-through, both in the power and in the preamp section, as is employed in their top-of-the-line Illusion preamps. The amplifier also has Krell’s Current Mode technology to ensure significant signal bandwidth, vital for those PCM or DSD sources.

The word Vanguard means ‘a group of people leading the way in new developments or ideas’, and this product certainly isn’t short on facilities. There are 4 analogue inputs; three RCA and one balanced XLR. One RCA input can be set as “Theatre”, meaning the input goes straight through to the power amplifier stage and misses out the preamp for use as part of a surround sound theatre setup.  I used this setting for some of my review, using my MFA transformer passive preamp.  Connection to loudspeakers is provided by high-quality WBT terminals.  There is also a 3.5mm jack for IR input and 12-volt trigger input and output, as well as optional rack-mount ears, should you want to fit it onto a 19” rack. I’m not sure why you would want to do that; you really would want to show off this beautiful integrated rather than sticking it in a rack hidden away in a cupboard.

The latest version, the Digital Vanguard, has an all-encompassing digital module on board, which gives USB, 3 HDMI inputs and output, and more conventional coax and optical digital inputs. The coaxial and HDMI inputs support PCM up to 24-bit/192kHz, with optical input supporting up to 24-bit/96kHz. Moreover it also offers Ethernet music streaming controlled through dedicated iOS and Android apps; and Bluetooth wireless for convenient streaming from phones, tablets and computers. The USB and Network streaming works well with MP3, AAC, WMA, WAV (PCM), FLAC and ALAC up to 192kHz, and the Bluetooth streaming supports A2DP, AVRCP, HFP and HSP formats. The HDMI inputs support DSD and 4K video content. HDMI output supports Audio Return Channel (ARC). Quite some line-up then!  If you don’t choose the digital option that section on the back panel is blanked over.vanguard11

For this review I used my Krell KPS20i CD player and vinyl for analogue sources, and for digital inputs I used the mConnect Player app from Google to stream audio from my Xperia phone using Bluetooth, and my laptop and Fiio X5. For those who buy the basic Vanguard you can add the digital board at a later date, installed by Krell or the retailer, and you can you can update software when required.  The UK retail price for the Vanguard with digital board is £5,998, and the standard analogue Vanguard is £4,498, both highly competitive prices when you consider all you get.

Turn it to standby and above the KRELL logo in the centre of the panel it lights up a row of red. I like this. Then turn it on and the colour spread changes to blue, both of which means that at some point it matches the blue and red LEDs of my other equipment. All amplifiers in their present range have this distinctive bonnet, just as previous Krells have had a distinctive design in the centre. Also typical of Krell is the substantial power supply, in this case a 750 VA toroidal transformer and 80,000 microfarads of storage capacitance, meaning the Vanguard will have a very intimate relationship with your mains supply, whatever quality it is. All this adds weight, though at 17.7 kg, it is actually very light for a Krell.Vanguard_INTERIORs

SOUND

Whenever I think of Krell I think first of music like Beethoven and words like ‘gutsy, big, menace’ and ‘force’.  Their amplifiers have always had that reputation and in some respects it has perhaps put people off. I have followed Krell since Dan and Rondi D’Agostino formed the company in 1980, having both a KAV250a power amp and KPS20i CD player, and KAV150 and KRC before that. I like my music to leave an impact, and Krell certainly turns that prospect into a reality. I wanted to see just how good this entry-level product compared with other Krells I know well, and of course everything else around this price point. Putting on Beethoven to start with was therefore the obvious choice, and all playing through my Wilson Benesch speakers.  The Dresden Philharmonic under Herbert Kegel is an excellent performance full of energy that some amplifiers just cannot deal with. This one left nothing untouched. My speakers came alive such that even my cat sat up and listened. Symphony number 7, complete with hitting mic stand at one minute in (never heard that on my KAV) had the dynamic range of Mahler or Bruckner. I was worried when I initially unpacked this unit that the two fans at the rear, which cool down the heatsink, would make this quite loud in operation, but ironically this 400W/4Ω beauty was as quiet as, well, silence, even with the two thermostatically controlled fans at the back. It still gets hot inside, though that was as expected, so good ventilation above is still a necessity.

The front panel is minimalist in comparison with the accompanying remote, but has all the functions you needed to operate should you lose the latter. The remote itself was typical of Krell products, putting many, many other companies to shame with the solidity of build and weight; being a slab of aluminium, machined to insert the electronics, mirroring the controls on the amplifier and with many extra buttons, and offering access to other Krell products such as my aged CD player. With its ribbed back-and-sides black finish with silver buttons, this remote was quite simply gorgeous. The Vanguard itself has a two line LCD display, below the USB socket which is only operable if you have the digital card attached. The LCD display stops illuminating after around 15 seconds of inaction, though the blue line above the KRELL wording stays lit, I’m pleased to say.

Using MP3 from my Xperia, Track 2 of Heathen, David Bowie, had powerful top and an amazing definition making compressed audio sound almost acceptable. Eagles ‘Long Road out of Eden’ Title track on disc 2 of this great double album had a depth and width that made for an exceptionally invigorating listen. If you wanted warmth and easy listening then you needed valve, however the bass from this behemoth was definitely valve inspired. This bass was so good, and the tops were pin-sharp and quick. This was like having just had my ears syringed, and my listening soon became all about power, detail and fun! Moving swiftly to CD the energetic Naim “The Ark” album playing “Mambo Jumbo” (John van der Veer), had detail and energy that really took me aback with jumbo stereo spread of the two guitars. This was good.Vanguard 3-4 views

Turning to vinyl I went via my Manley and MFA pre, turning the Vanguard into “Theatre” mode so I missed out the on-board class-A pre. Mozart Piano Concerto No 21 in C major, something I played when I was a young piano student, sounded as musical and gentle as I would expect from the young female pianist Geza Anda (Camerata Academica of the Salzburg Mozarteum) showing this bulldog could also be tamed when needed. This music had pizazz, sweetness and space that let every nuance of the music through. The famous slow movement was not hurried, but performed in my living room like I was there at the recording. The Krell pre-amp stage, though, is still excellent and worked well when I removed the MFA from the chain.

Turning to the Queen Studio Collection, this was now getting seriously good. The brilliantly remixed set of albums had extensive depth and detail as Freddie and the team whizzed between, as well as in front and behind my speakers with energy. ‘A Night at the Opera’ is one of the best albums from Queen, not only in its content, but also in the sound engineering. With tracks like ‘Bohemian Rhapsody’, ‘You’re my Best Friend’ and ‘Love of My Life’ it is no wonder this album hit the number one spot in 1975. The fading in and out of the musical stabs in ‘Death on Two Legs’ showed just how good the original sources – and this, the remixed version – were. But equally it showed how well the Krell performed. Queen albums are not the easiest to play well, and many amps cannot cope with such a wide degree of sounds and dynamics with such ease as the Krell.  Turning to Mike Valentine’s ‘Big Band Spectacular’ suddenly the soundstage grew by metres, with forceful sounding brass at one extreme and precise and gentle ride cymbal at the other, beautifully married together. The Krell showed off with both vivacity and gentleness in equal amounts. The 200W/8Ω integrated might be the baby of the Krell range, but this was no slouch. Everything was there, from the detail that is missing from so many amplifiers to the grunt when it needed to have it. Class-A rules A-O.K, and I really started enjoying this. The clarity was better than on my KAV250a, though the grunt wasn’t quite as big; the sound was much more in control and the stereo width and speed was one of the best I have heard, resolving imagery faster and more accurately. All it lacked was a headphone socket. It could do everything else, well, perhaps except vinyl, but I guess fitting a vinyl card in as well would be a tight squeeze in this already anorexic Krell.  And, to top it all, it was made in The USA, rather than China!

CONCLUSION

Those not convinced of just how good Krell can be, should give this one a go, and particularly the digital version. This one just does everything except make coffee, and allows user adjustment of settings from the comfort of your armchair, and does it all with both authority and tenderness. If you want a large-scale performance in your living room, especially in the speed of sound and stereo spread, you will like this one, but if you want easy listening, then go elsewhere; this Vanguard will keep your attention for as long as it’s switched on.

Sound Quality – 8.90/10

Value for Money – 8.6/10

Build Quality – 8.8/10

Overall – 8.77/10 

Price at time of review £5,998 

Pros:

Digital features pleases everyone
Muscle where you need it
Well behaved bass
fast and accurate imagery
Petite size of amplifier will please more folk
Quiet fans keep the heat down
Love the red and blue lights

Cons:

Pretty expensive but a lot of features for the money
You might not like the bonnet

Janine Elliot

SPECIFICATIONS

Inputs 
1 pr. balanced via XLR connectors
3 pr. single-ended via RCA connectors
1 HDMI
1 USB

 

Outputs 
1 pr. speaker outputs via WBT gold-plated binding posts

 

Control inputs 
1 remote IR detector input via 3-conductor 3.5 mm connector
1 12 VDC trigger input via 2-conductor 3.5 mm connector

 

Control output 
1 programmable 12 VDC trigger output (300 mA maximum current) via 2-conductor 3.5 mm connector

 

Input impedance 
Balanced: 95 kΩ
Single-ended: 47.5 kΩ

 

Frequency response 
20 Hz to 20 kHz +0, –0.01 dB
<2 Hz to 150 kHz +0, –3 dB

 

Signal-to-noise ratio 
>90 dB, wideband, unweighted, at maximum gain, referred to full power output
>97 dB, “A”-weighted

 

Gain 
48 dB

 

Input sensitivity 
Single-ended or balanced: 160 mV RMS

 

Total harmonic distortion 
<0.015% at 1 kHz, at 200 W, 8 Ω load
<0.13% at 20 kHz, at 200 W, 8 Ω load

 

Output power 
200 W RMS per channel at 8 Ω
400 W RMS per channel at 4 Ω

 

  Output voltage 
113 V peak to peak
40 V RMS

 

Output current 
16 A peak

 

Slew rate 
50 V/μs

 

Output impedance 
<0.066 Ω at 20 Hz
<0.075 Ω, 20 Hz to 20 kHz

 

Damping factor 
>121 at 20 Hz, referred to 8 Ω
>106, 20 Hz to 20 kHz, referred to 8 Ω

 

Power consumption
Standby: 12 W
Idle: 70 W
Maximum: 1300 W

 

Heat output 
Standby: 41 BTU/hr
Idle: 239 BTU/hr
Maximum: 4436 BTU/hr

 

Dimensions 
17.1 in W x 4.15 in H x 17.5 in D
434 mm W x 105 mm H x 445 mm D

 

Weight 
Unit only: 39 lb [17.7 kg]
As shipped: 47 lb [21.3 kg]

 

Digital Module Specs 
Coaxial and HDMI inputs support PCM up to 24-bit/192kHz. Optical input up to 24-bit/96kHz

 

HDMI inputs support DSD and 4K video content. HDMI output supports Audio Return Channel (ARC)

 

USB and Network streaming support MP3, AAC, WMA, WAV(PCM), FLAC, ALAC up to 192kHz

 

Bluetooth streaming supports A2DP, AVRCP, HFP, HSP

 

Audiobyte Black Dragon DAC

$
0
0

Dan Worth takes a listen to this well connected, £1200 DAC from Romanian company Audiobyte.

When purchasing a new DAC I want a host of connections to allow the opportunity to plug and play multiple digital sources at one time, or to interchange sources for review purposes.

Despite a recent flurry in HDMI over I2S devices being produced, the format is often overlooked by some of the mainstream manufacturers; however, Audiobyte have embraced the standard and this is a positive move from the Romanian company in my opinion. As well as my own Audiobyte X+ spdif converter sporting a HDMI digital output the Black Dragon also has the latest standard as an input.Black_dragon_dac_03

CONNECTIONS AND FEATURES

Along with BNC, RCA and optical spdif inputs, the Black Dragon also has asynchronous USB and the 110ohm AES/EBU professional standard connection type too. Outputs are via a set of either balanced XLRs or unbalanced RCAs.

Sampling rates and bit depth are as follows:

32bit – 44.1-384 KHz on USB, I2S (PCM)

DSD64, 128 on USB

24bit – 44.1-192 KHz on spdif, aes-ebu

24bit – 44.1-96 KHz on toslink

The Dual Mono Conversion, using 2 X AK4396s, offers a fully balanced implementation mode which is designed to give better analogue conversion and lower jitter rates and the onboard Femtovox Clock 300fs is an extremely accurate and precise clock from Rockna, and here is used to increase timing accuracy and to reduce jitter.

The custom Minimal Phase Digital Filter aids in producing high performance up-sampling for conditioning the incoming digital signals. Of course this filter can be switched on or off.

The LNS Linear Power Supply – There are a total of 11 linear stabiliser I/Cs and 8 of them are said to be very low noise. There are a total of 50,000uF capacitors for smoothing and two separate toroidal transformers provide power to all individual pcb sections.

The Black Dragon has a preamplifier and headphone amplifier onboard, with the digital volume controller being useable for all inputs and outputs. The headphone amplifier, rated at 32ohms and outputting 800mW, should offer the flexibility of use that consumers want to see from a modern digital hub such as this.

Visually the Black Dragon is pretty nice looking, with sleek lines and a compact size. The dot matrix screen is clear, with connector layout on the rear being tidy and easily accessible. Overall build quality could be a little better in my opinion, with the lid of the unit being very thin and a little rattly… more screws and some damping would be very welcome here. However, the Black Dragon certainly does look great on either a desk or in rack.Black_dragon_dac_02

THE SOUND

My first impressions of the sound were very positive, the unit has done the rounds already so was more than ready for action after a quick warm up when it arrived here from BD Audio.

Initial findings were that vocals are very distinguished and the top end, with the FIR filter set to off, is beautifully open and very well extended. Whilst playing a Fink live album I felt the metallic clang of cymbals to be expressed very well and the shimmering decay felt nice and true to the venue’s acoustic.

With poor recordings, such as Derrin Nuendorf’s live album, I felt the top end to be a little over explicit, but flicking the filter back to the ‘on’ position cured this exceptionally well. I used Spotify extensively and threw a good range of genres at the Black Dragon and felt the filter offered terrific flexibility, allowing me to enjoy tracks in a much more musical manner than if it was not present. There is also some benefit to the upper midrange here.

The midrange as a whole is wonderfully analogue-like and very expressive, and I loved how the Black Dragon rendered a strong female vocalist, particularly in the higher registers and how it added grunt to males tones. I particularly enjoyed Sinead O’Connor’s ‘Am I Not Your Girl’ where there’s a certain sweetness to her vocal when played through good equipment and The Dragon allowed her vocal to remain intimate and unrestrained.

Busier tracks had nice separation, again especially when it came to vocals, and I really like how The Dragon can take the lead singer and separate them from the haze of noise that can surround them, allowing for a clear and articulate emphasis on centre stage performance.

The soundstage produced from the DAC as a whole was very appealing. Depth is good, leaving vocalists in the foreground and width and height is what I would class as ‘expected in my room’ from a quality component. There is a cohesive thickness to the sound and the stage isn’t overblown, but nor is it warm or oversaturated. Definition and clarity is the overall nature of the sound and when fed with good recordings this DAC sounds surprisingly natural for its price point.

Bass notes seemed to represent the actual instruments in use very well and where some DACs in this price range can be more of a one note affair, The Dragon gave me each note. For example, when listening to ‘Hey Now’ by London Grammar, there are actually eight bass notes being played consecutively in the track and I have had DACs here costing a fair bit more than the Black Dragon that have failed to accurately portray this. Bass is really very rhythmical and carries the flow of the music exceptionally well and I think Audiobytes certainly know how to tune equipment – which I guess is why I still use their Hydra X+ to this day from my Mac.

SONY DSC

SONY DSC

HEADPHONE AMPLIFIER

I attached my Audio Technica ATH AD2000X headphones to the Black Dragon and I felt it would make for a great all in one, desktop headphone rig. Now I’m sure dedicated “headphone-aphiles” out there would demand more from an all in one experience, but for those who like our sound to predominantly come from in front of us rather than ‘inside our heads’ I really enjoyed quite a few hours listening to a great range of music from The Dragons headphone output.

Soundwise I found The Dragon to be on the slightly warmer side of neutral and I loved the fact that the top end behaved just like the headphones do, taking the treble to the edge and then leaning back a notch or so to give lots of extension and openness, without any harshness.

Again, the FIR filter works a treat when listening to headphones.

Volume control on the DAC is wonderful when wanting to make small volume adjustments, and allows for a very smooth incline or decline in decibels when pressed, although I would have liked it to be faster when changing large volume swing.

CONCLUSION

Audiobytes have once again come up with a product that offers fantastic performance for the money. The Black Dragon is a feature rich digital to analogue converter which sounds detailed, open and natural. With great extended highs, a fantastically informative midrange and a realistic bass performance, music has a rhythmic flow and engaging enthusiasm. 

Build Quality: 8.2/10RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Sound Quality: 9/10

Value For Money: 8.8/10

Overall: 8.66/10 

Price at time of review: £1200 

Pros:

Lots of inputs

Balanced and unbalanced outputs

Great vocals and cohesive sound

Nice headphone amp 

Cons:

Lid is a bit flimsy

Volume can take an age to move large increments 

 

Dan Worth

 

ATC SCM7 Loudspeakers

$
0
0

The ATC SCM7 is a diminutive loudspeaker of just 7 litres and costing from £810. Dan Worth takes a listen.

Over this past year Dominic and I have had the pleasure of listening to the SCM11s and 19s from British loudspeaker company ATC. Before we received each of the speakers we were both a little apprehensive about the new design, yet likewise excited. The reason being is that we had both had experience with ATC speakers before and both really enjoyed their dynamics, attack, insight and truthfulness, even if this was sometimes to their detriment when the older style tweeter would bite back hard, especially with less than good quality recordings, which would be shown no mercy. ATC-SCM7-speaker-front_no-grill-large RGBs

ATC however came through with a redesign that was simply stunning. The roughness of the older tweeter was gone. The new unit is more refined and better controlled, but still it grasped notes with the truthfulness we hoped wouldn’t be lost. ATC touched the design just right and with the newly developed enclosures, both the 11s and 19s received our highest accolades.

AT FIRST GLANCE

The SCM7s arrive and these are dinky – a tiny 7 litre cabinet that gives them their name, measuring just 300x174x215mm. The 7s sport the same tweeter as the other SCMs and a 5″ linear mid/bass driver with the cabinet finished to ATC’s solid, sturdy and sleek design. The review specimens were once again in my favoured real cherry wood veneer, costing £810 a pair, the same as the black ash option, however the piano black model comes in at a hefty £1243.

I was pleasantly surprised when I lifted the first speaker from the box, it’s weight is a little deceptive and they have some good mass coming in at around the 7.4kg mark each and sporting bi-wirable terminals. Packaging as always with ATC is fuss free and protective. ATC-SCM7-speaker-3-4-view_no-grill RGBs

THE SOUND

Dominic and I have had many conversations regarding the SCM11s and 19s – Which we preferred and why. The 11s are pure excitement and have a punchier sound whereas the 19s come across richer, more full and perceivably more refined.

I’m writing this today without Dominic having a chance to listen yet to the SCM7s and for me they are really exciting. The imaging that comes from this design is fantastic, they struggle with height if you are sitting too close to them due to their size, but sat back and with not too much volume they just get going so easily for an 84db sensitive speaker, disappearing into the foreground in an instant and placing instruments way beyond any boundary you would imagine them ever able to touch.

I would definitely suggest that they have more of the zip and enthusiasm of the 11s which we both loved so much. They punch rather than pound, but the bass is so representative of truthful playback (within their 60hz roll off point) that I only hankered for more bass on the odd occasions.

I’d also confidently state that these are for those of you who obviously have a more limited space to listen in, but also for music lovers who enjoy such genres as pop and electronic music, although vocals and acoustic guitar are equally as impressive –  I would prefer a bass reflex design in this sized cabinet for the latter. They won’t dig down deep with bass guitars and oboes but they will strike a beat. A sparkling triangle or shimmering cymbal sounds terrifically accurate with all the dynamics and naturalness they deserve from these small boxes and when hooked up on my desk in place of the active Focals, I was extremely impressed with their overall response in the alcove which enhanced the bass response a little. ATC SH25-76 tweeterss

I think what I enjoy so much about these and the 11s is that due to their smaller cabinets and higher cutoff point, the upper frequencies are just allowed to breath so well, allowing for more perceived accuracy in the higher frequencies and mid level notes, making for a crystal clear vocal reproduction. As I listen I am thinking that a set of 11s or 7s with ATCs own C1 subwoofer could make for a stunning listen. Taking the extra bass away from the main enclosures would allow the new tweeter and mid/bass drivers to really breath and image impeccably well. Maybe ATC could design a speaker similar to a Wilson, an 11 or 7 on top for instance and a separate enclosure for the bass? … just a thought…

Well, I don’t have any 11s here at the moment but I do have the 7s and fast forward a few days…

Now I have a C1 subwoofer here courtesy of ATC’s PR agent. I put together a little system comprising of a Primare I32 with MM30 multimedia board/DAC fed by my Mac and of course the SCM7s and C1 sub.

Wow, this is a real treat! I’m currently sat here working my way through some popular music in order to get a feel of all different types of music and boy this combo rocks. I love the increased definition of the midrange especially, under pinned with tremendous weight poise and control. Even the treble sounds beefier. Dialing the sub in to around 60Hz to integrate with the 7s was magic.

Dance music had an intense rhythm and a crystal clear top end, rock had a grip and sharpness of leading edge that may well have been too overpowering with the 7s alone but with the C1 had more meat on the bone and more substance. Acoustic music and vocals sounded more accurate in the sense that each instrument still had a defined space in the soundstage but with all undertones filled-in they demanded the attention of the listener more with a rich weight and more complexity to notes.

In each scenario the 7s worked ever so well. Space and needs will determine speaker choice ultimately, but if you have room for a subwoofer I would wholeheartedly recommend the one from ATC as it truly adds another dimension to the sound. ATC SH25-76 tweetersss

CONCLUSION

For a change I’ve not written a long review, let’s keep this one short and sweet just like the 7s. Think of the imaging of the old Proac Tablettes, the surprisingly bass of a Totem One and the enthusiasm of an old AE1. Each of these speakers is renowned for being special and have characteristics that really stay with you.

The ATC SCM7 is one of those diminutive speakers that are just so damn addictive and so unassuming that I think I’m going to have to have a pair. They are like the adorable little runt of the litter that you simply have to take home. Over time the personality, confidence and livability is simply undeniable and even the thought of being without them has one reaching for a tissue.

Build Quality – 8.5/10RECOMMENDED LOGO NEW

Sound Quality – 8.7/10

Value For Money – 8.75/10

Overall – 8.65/10 

Price at time of review:

Cherry/black ash – £810

Piano black lacquer – £1243

Pros:

Emphatic, transparent, detailed presentation

Solid imaging and strong dynamics

Great build

Cons:

At this price, nothing

Dan Worth

TECHNICAL SPEC’

Drivers: HF ATC 25mm Neodymium Soft Dome, Mid/LF ATC 125mm SC
Matched Response: ±0.5dB
Frequency Response (-6dB): 60Hz-22kHz
Dispersion: ±80° Coherent Horizontal, ±10° Coherent Vertical
Sensitivity: 84dB @ 1W @ 1metre
Max SPL: 103dB
Recommended Power Amplifier: 75 to 300 Watts
Nominal Impedance: 8 Ohm
Crossover Frequency: 2.5kHz
Connectors: Binding Posts/4mm Plugs, bi-wire
Cabinet Dimensions (HxWxD): 300x174x215mm (grill adds 28mm depth)
Weight: 7.5kg

DESIGNER’S COMMENTS

Tweeter

SH25-76

The SH25-76 is a 25mm soft dome tweeter designed and built by ATC Loudspeaker Technology and exclusively employed on ATC’s SCM7, 11, 19 and 40 ‘passive series’ speakers.  The drive unit has been designed with the same no compromise philosophy as all other ATC drive units.

Sharing technology with the SM75-150 mid-range, the SH25-76 employs a dual suspension design, ensuring pistonic motion and suppressing rocking modes even at high drive levels. This also enables the use of a narrow magnetic gap and negates the requirement for ferrofluid. The SH25-76 is therefore, free from the detrimental effects of ferrofluid drying out over time.

A short coil, long gap configuration ensures linearity and incredibly low distortion through its intended operating band. The soft dome diaphragm is based on a complex geometry which maximises power transfer from the former, extending the high frequency response and giving a smooth off-axis response.

The FEA optimised neodymium motor with heat treated top plate is designed to give 15,000 Gauss (1.5 Tesla) in the magnetic gap and the motor assembly also performs the secondary function of dissipating heat away from the voice coil, ensuring high power handling and low power compression. The underhung design, small coil-gap clearance and black plating ensures heat dissipation is as efficient as possible.

The geometry of the waveguide is designed for optimum dispersion and the flattest possible on-axis frequency response. It is made from a precision machined alloy so that the entire structure is extremely rigid and free from resonances.

Bass Driver

SB45-125SC

The bass driver used in the SCM7 is a proprietary design, manufactured in-house.  Like the vast majority of all our larger drive units, the so called ‘underhung’ design uses a short coil operating in long magnetic gap for the best possible linearity.  The advantages of this type of motor topology are:

  1. Less variation in the force acting on the coil vs excursion.
  2. Less variation in coil inductance vs excursion.

The result is that distortion is greatly reduced. The music benefits from greater clarity and tonal balance and the listener benefits from reduced listening fatigue.

The voice coil technology employed greatly benefits the performance of the loudspeaker.  Firstly, a large voice coil diameter is chosen for increased power handling and, as important, low power compression.  Loudspeakers are quite inefficient and much of the amplifier power ends up heating the voice coil.  This, in turn causes:

  1. A rise in resistance.
  2. A drop in efficiency.
  3. Increase of the system low frequency ‘Q’ (causing a tendency for pronounced ‘boomy’ bass).
  4. Modification of the crossover performance which, in turn, changes the perceived balance of the loudspeaker.

Using the largest possible voice coil diameter increases the coil surface area which reduces the rate of voice coil heating and minimises the problems associated with it.

Not only is great attention paid to the coil but also to the wire we wind the coil from.  Round wire does not ‘pack’ (tessellate) well, leaving gaps between the windings (think pool balls racked before a break).  These gaps are wasted space and fill with glue and air, slowing the escape of heat from the coil.  ATC chooses to use the more complex and costly process of winding flat ‘ribbon’ wire voice coils.  The ribbon wire, when wound on edge, results in a greater volume of copper in the magnetic gap (vs round wire) and the efficiency of the drive mechanism is improved.  The air and glue filled gaps are also greatly reduced, leading to a more rapid escape of heat from the voice coil.

The cone and dust cap of the bass driver used in the SCM7 are formed into curve-linear profiles from resin impregnated fabric.  The fabric chosen uses a very strong and dense weave, with high internal damping.  Two different polymer coatings are then applied to the fabric surface: a PVA based coating to the rear and a proprietary coating to the front.  Both of these coatings increase cone stiffness and also, very importantly, the mechanical damping of the cone structure.  Materials high in damping suppress resonances, minimising the audibility of cone break up modes and extending the useable bandwidth at the top of the bass driver’s range.  This in turn greatly simplifies crossover design (which I’ll get to shortly).  ATC believes that as a loudspeaker manufacturer, you are defined by your drive unit components and that is why every loudspeaker system we produce begins with in-house designed and built components, optimised for their application.

Crossover

By investing heavily in the drive unit engineering, ATC produces components with a well-controlled response that require only simple filters to integrate into multi-driver systems.  The SCM7 employs 2nd order filters for both the low-pass and high-pass sections.  The bass section also uses a R-C zobel network to correct for the rising bass driver impedance, ensuring correct operation of the bass low pass filter.  The high frequency section uses a resistive ‘T’ attenuation network to pad the tweeter output down to match the bass.  All of the inductors used are air-cored types for lowest distortion and the capacitors are 250Vdc rated metallised polypropylene parts.  An area of the crossover design we pay particular attention to is that of impedance vs frequency and ensuring the loudspeaker system (drivers + crossover + wiring) present an easy load for an amplifier to drive.  The loudspeaker load an amplifier ‘sees’ is just as important as the sensitivity of the loudspeaker, although loudspeaker load doesn’t seem to be debated quite so regularly.  Not only must the magnitude of the impedance be balanced with a reasonable system sensitivity, the phase angle must also be considered.  Low impedance values or large phase angles will lead to large current demands from an amplifier and could lead to increased distortion and, at worst, amplifier hard clipping.  The combination of both a low impedance magnitude and large phase angle is very difficult for an amplifier, especially when it occurs at a frequency where music has a great deal of energy.  Through careful drive unit design which, in turn, allows simple crossover design, free from ‘ringing’ filters that are used to reinforce a frequency band lacking in energy, we can deliver a loudspeaker that presents an easy load to an amplifier.

ATC Technical Sales Manager, February 2016

 

Viewing all 672 articles
Browse latest View live